A critical analysis of recreational water guidelines developed from temperate climate data and applied to the tropics

Marc P. Verhougstraete, Kristen Pogreba-Brown, Kelly A. Reynolds, Claudia Condé Lamparelli, Maria Inês Zanoli Sato, Timothy J. Wade, Joseph N.S. Eisenberg

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Recreational water epidemiology studies are rare in settings with minimal wastewater treatment where risk may be highest, and in tropical settings where warmer temperature influences the ecology of fecal indicator bacteria commonly used to monitor recreational waters. One exception is a 1999 study conducted in São Paulo Brazil. We compared the risk and exposure characteristics of these data with those conducted in the United Kingdom (UK) in the early 1990s that are the basis of the World Health Organization's (WHO) guidelines on recreational water risks. We then developed adjusted risk difference models (excess gastrointestinal illness per swimming event) for children (<10 years of age) and non-children (≥10 years of age) across five Brazil beaches. We used these models along with beach water quality data from 2004 to 2015 to assess spatial and temporal trends in water quality and human risk. Risk models indicate that children in Brazil have as much as two times the risk of gastrointestinal illness than non-children. In Brazil, 11.8% of the weekly water samples from 2004 to 2015 exceeded 158 enterococci CFU/100 ml, the highest level of fecal streptococci concentration measured in the UK study. Risks associated with these elevated levels equated to median NEEAR-Gastrointestinal Illness (NGI) risks of 53 and 96 excess cases per 1000 swimmers in non-children and children, respectively. Two of the five beaches appear to drive the overall elevated NGI risks seen during this study. Distinct enteric pathogen profiles that exist in tropical settings as well as in settings with minimal wastewater treatment highlight the importance of regionally specific guideline development.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number115294
JournalWater research
Volume170
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2020

Fingerprint

Tropics
critical analysis
Water
water
Beaches
beach
Wastewater treatment
Water quality
tropics
temperate climate
water quality
Epidemiology
World Health Organization
Pathogens
Ecology
epidemiology
Bacteria
pathogen
Health
ecology

Keywords

  • Beaches
  • Brazil
  • Enterococci
  • Escherichia coli
  • Quantitative microbial risk assessment
  • South America

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecological Modeling
  • Water Science and Technology
  • Waste Management and Disposal
  • Pollution

Cite this

A critical analysis of recreational water guidelines developed from temperate climate data and applied to the tropics. / Verhougstraete, Marc P.; Pogreba-Brown, Kristen; Reynolds, Kelly A.; Lamparelli, Claudia Condé; Zanoli Sato, Maria Inês; Wade, Timothy J.; Eisenberg, Joseph N.S.

In: Water research, Vol. 170, 115294, 01.03.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{4f66e8b156cb41dd90b3d5c1cc10c7bf,
title = "A critical analysis of recreational water guidelines developed from temperate climate data and applied to the tropics",
abstract = "Recreational water epidemiology studies are rare in settings with minimal wastewater treatment where risk may be highest, and in tropical settings where warmer temperature influences the ecology of fecal indicator bacteria commonly used to monitor recreational waters. One exception is a 1999 study conducted in S{\~a}o Paulo Brazil. We compared the risk and exposure characteristics of these data with those conducted in the United Kingdom (UK) in the early 1990s that are the basis of the World Health Organization's (WHO) guidelines on recreational water risks. We then developed adjusted risk difference models (excess gastrointestinal illness per swimming event) for children (<10 years of age) and non-children (≥10 years of age) across five Brazil beaches. We used these models along with beach water quality data from 2004 to 2015 to assess spatial and temporal trends in water quality and human risk. Risk models indicate that children in Brazil have as much as two times the risk of gastrointestinal illness than non-children. In Brazil, 11.8{\%} of the weekly water samples from 2004 to 2015 exceeded 158 enterococci CFU/100 ml, the highest level of fecal streptococci concentration measured in the UK study. Risks associated with these elevated levels equated to median NEEAR-Gastrointestinal Illness (NGI) risks of 53 and 96 excess cases per 1000 swimmers in non-children and children, respectively. Two of the five beaches appear to drive the overall elevated NGI risks seen during this study. Distinct enteric pathogen profiles that exist in tropical settings as well as in settings with minimal wastewater treatment highlight the importance of regionally specific guideline development.",
keywords = "Beaches, Brazil, Enterococci, Escherichia coli, Quantitative microbial risk assessment, South America",
author = "Verhougstraete, {Marc P.} and Kristen Pogreba-Brown and Reynolds, {Kelly A.} and Lamparelli, {Claudia Cond{\'e}} and {Zanoli Sato}, {Maria In{\^e}s} and Wade, {Timothy J.} and Eisenberg, {Joseph N.S.}",
year = "2020",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.watres.2019.115294",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "170",
journal = "Water Research",
issn = "0043-1354",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A critical analysis of recreational water guidelines developed from temperate climate data and applied to the tropics

AU - Verhougstraete, Marc P.

AU - Pogreba-Brown, Kristen

AU - Reynolds, Kelly A.

AU - Lamparelli, Claudia Condé

AU - Zanoli Sato, Maria Inês

AU - Wade, Timothy J.

AU - Eisenberg, Joseph N.S.

PY - 2020/3/1

Y1 - 2020/3/1

N2 - Recreational water epidemiology studies are rare in settings with minimal wastewater treatment where risk may be highest, and in tropical settings where warmer temperature influences the ecology of fecal indicator bacteria commonly used to monitor recreational waters. One exception is a 1999 study conducted in São Paulo Brazil. We compared the risk and exposure characteristics of these data with those conducted in the United Kingdom (UK) in the early 1990s that are the basis of the World Health Organization's (WHO) guidelines on recreational water risks. We then developed adjusted risk difference models (excess gastrointestinal illness per swimming event) for children (<10 years of age) and non-children (≥10 years of age) across five Brazil beaches. We used these models along with beach water quality data from 2004 to 2015 to assess spatial and temporal trends in water quality and human risk. Risk models indicate that children in Brazil have as much as two times the risk of gastrointestinal illness than non-children. In Brazil, 11.8% of the weekly water samples from 2004 to 2015 exceeded 158 enterococci CFU/100 ml, the highest level of fecal streptococci concentration measured in the UK study. Risks associated with these elevated levels equated to median NEEAR-Gastrointestinal Illness (NGI) risks of 53 and 96 excess cases per 1000 swimmers in non-children and children, respectively. Two of the five beaches appear to drive the overall elevated NGI risks seen during this study. Distinct enteric pathogen profiles that exist in tropical settings as well as in settings with minimal wastewater treatment highlight the importance of regionally specific guideline development.

AB - Recreational water epidemiology studies are rare in settings with minimal wastewater treatment where risk may be highest, and in tropical settings where warmer temperature influences the ecology of fecal indicator bacteria commonly used to monitor recreational waters. One exception is a 1999 study conducted in São Paulo Brazil. We compared the risk and exposure characteristics of these data with those conducted in the United Kingdom (UK) in the early 1990s that are the basis of the World Health Organization's (WHO) guidelines on recreational water risks. We then developed adjusted risk difference models (excess gastrointestinal illness per swimming event) for children (<10 years of age) and non-children (≥10 years of age) across five Brazil beaches. We used these models along with beach water quality data from 2004 to 2015 to assess spatial and temporal trends in water quality and human risk. Risk models indicate that children in Brazil have as much as two times the risk of gastrointestinal illness than non-children. In Brazil, 11.8% of the weekly water samples from 2004 to 2015 exceeded 158 enterococci CFU/100 ml, the highest level of fecal streptococci concentration measured in the UK study. Risks associated with these elevated levels equated to median NEEAR-Gastrointestinal Illness (NGI) risks of 53 and 96 excess cases per 1000 swimmers in non-children and children, respectively. Two of the five beaches appear to drive the overall elevated NGI risks seen during this study. Distinct enteric pathogen profiles that exist in tropical settings as well as in settings with minimal wastewater treatment highlight the importance of regionally specific guideline development.

KW - Beaches

KW - Brazil

KW - Enterococci

KW - Escherichia coli

KW - Quantitative microbial risk assessment

KW - South America

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85075264033&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85075264033&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.watres.2019.115294

DO - 10.1016/j.watres.2019.115294

M3 - Article

C2 - 31765827

AN - SCOPUS:85075264033

VL - 170

JO - Water Research

JF - Water Research

SN - 0043-1354

M1 - 115294

ER -