A critical evaluation of the Miller and Miller similar media theory for application to natural soils

Morteza Sadeghi, Bijan Ghahraman, Arthur W. Warrick, Markus Tuller, Scott B. Jones

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Miller-Miller similar media theory is widely applied to characterize the spatial variability of soil hydraulic properties. For a group of soils, a distinct scaling factor is commonly assigned to each individual soil to coalesce the soil water characteristic and hydraulic conductivity functions to single curves. It is generally assumed that the Miller-Miller theory is valid as long as soils are "similar" either with regard to their microscopic pore space geometry or the closely related macroscopic soil hydraulic functions. In this paper, it is illustrated that similarity is not the sole required condition for validity of the Miller-Miller theory. In addition, the interrelation between the soil water characteristic and the hydraulic conductivity functions considered for scaling need to be comparable. The interrelation is dependent not only on the pore space geometry, but also on solid-liquid interactions. Hence similar interrelation cannot be concluded from similarity of microscopic pore space geometry. A dimensionless parameter termed the "joint scaling factor" was defined and applied to evaluate the soundness of the interrelation condition for 26 soils from the UNSODA database that were grouped into six classes of similar soils. Obtained results clearly reveal the crucial importance of the interrelation condition for the Miller-Miller scaling theory, which has been hidden behind the "similarity" requirement, and contradict the general belief that Miller-Miller scaling is valid as long as soils are "similar."

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalWater Resources Research
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - 2016

Fingerprint

soil
pore space
geometry
hydraulic conductivity
soil water
evaluation
hydraulic property
hydraulics
liquid

Keywords

  • Miller and Miller scaling
  • Similarity
  • Soil water characteristic
  • Unsaturated hydraulic conductivity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Water Science and Technology

Cite this

A critical evaluation of the Miller and Miller similar media theory for application to natural soils. / Sadeghi, Morteza; Ghahraman, Bijan; Warrick, Arthur W.; Tuller, Markus; Jones, Scott B.

In: Water Resources Research, 2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f69b84f8fbae440d93e1e1acb404fec6,
title = "A critical evaluation of the Miller and Miller similar media theory for application to natural soils",
abstract = "The Miller-Miller similar media theory is widely applied to characterize the spatial variability of soil hydraulic properties. For a group of soils, a distinct scaling factor is commonly assigned to each individual soil to coalesce the soil water characteristic and hydraulic conductivity functions to single curves. It is generally assumed that the Miller-Miller theory is valid as long as soils are {"}similar{"} either with regard to their microscopic pore space geometry or the closely related macroscopic soil hydraulic functions. In this paper, it is illustrated that similarity is not the sole required condition for validity of the Miller-Miller theory. In addition, the interrelation between the soil water characteristic and the hydraulic conductivity functions considered for scaling need to be comparable. The interrelation is dependent not only on the pore space geometry, but also on solid-liquid interactions. Hence similar interrelation cannot be concluded from similarity of microscopic pore space geometry. A dimensionless parameter termed the {"}joint scaling factor{"} was defined and applied to evaluate the soundness of the interrelation condition for 26 soils from the UNSODA database that were grouped into six classes of similar soils. Obtained results clearly reveal the crucial importance of the interrelation condition for the Miller-Miller scaling theory, which has been hidden behind the {"}similarity{"} requirement, and contradict the general belief that Miller-Miller scaling is valid as long as soils are {"}similar.{"}",
keywords = "Miller and Miller scaling, Similarity, Soil water characteristic, Unsaturated hydraulic conductivity",
author = "Morteza Sadeghi and Bijan Ghahraman and Warrick, {Arthur W.} and Markus Tuller and Jones, {Scott B.}",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1002/2015WR017929",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Water Resources Research",
issn = "0043-1397",
publisher = "American Geophysical Union",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A critical evaluation of the Miller and Miller similar media theory for application to natural soils

AU - Sadeghi, Morteza

AU - Ghahraman, Bijan

AU - Warrick, Arthur W.

AU - Tuller, Markus

AU - Jones, Scott B.

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - The Miller-Miller similar media theory is widely applied to characterize the spatial variability of soil hydraulic properties. For a group of soils, a distinct scaling factor is commonly assigned to each individual soil to coalesce the soil water characteristic and hydraulic conductivity functions to single curves. It is generally assumed that the Miller-Miller theory is valid as long as soils are "similar" either with regard to their microscopic pore space geometry or the closely related macroscopic soil hydraulic functions. In this paper, it is illustrated that similarity is not the sole required condition for validity of the Miller-Miller theory. In addition, the interrelation between the soil water characteristic and the hydraulic conductivity functions considered for scaling need to be comparable. The interrelation is dependent not only on the pore space geometry, but also on solid-liquid interactions. Hence similar interrelation cannot be concluded from similarity of microscopic pore space geometry. A dimensionless parameter termed the "joint scaling factor" was defined and applied to evaluate the soundness of the interrelation condition for 26 soils from the UNSODA database that were grouped into six classes of similar soils. Obtained results clearly reveal the crucial importance of the interrelation condition for the Miller-Miller scaling theory, which has been hidden behind the "similarity" requirement, and contradict the general belief that Miller-Miller scaling is valid as long as soils are "similar."

AB - The Miller-Miller similar media theory is widely applied to characterize the spatial variability of soil hydraulic properties. For a group of soils, a distinct scaling factor is commonly assigned to each individual soil to coalesce the soil water characteristic and hydraulic conductivity functions to single curves. It is generally assumed that the Miller-Miller theory is valid as long as soils are "similar" either with regard to their microscopic pore space geometry or the closely related macroscopic soil hydraulic functions. In this paper, it is illustrated that similarity is not the sole required condition for validity of the Miller-Miller theory. In addition, the interrelation between the soil water characteristic and the hydraulic conductivity functions considered for scaling need to be comparable. The interrelation is dependent not only on the pore space geometry, but also on solid-liquid interactions. Hence similar interrelation cannot be concluded from similarity of microscopic pore space geometry. A dimensionless parameter termed the "joint scaling factor" was defined and applied to evaluate the soundness of the interrelation condition for 26 soils from the UNSODA database that were grouped into six classes of similar soils. Obtained results clearly reveal the crucial importance of the interrelation condition for the Miller-Miller scaling theory, which has been hidden behind the "similarity" requirement, and contradict the general belief that Miller-Miller scaling is valid as long as soils are "similar."

KW - Miller and Miller scaling

KW - Similarity

KW - Soil water characteristic

KW - Unsaturated hydraulic conductivity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84971440540&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84971440540&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/2015WR017929

DO - 10.1002/2015WR017929

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84971440540

JO - Water Resources Research

JF - Water Resources Research

SN - 0043-1397

ER -