A critical reanalysis of planetary accretion models

R. A. Kolvoord, Richard J. Greenberg

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Planet formation models and simulations appear to be converging toward a consensus on how growth may have occured, at least up to the emergence of a few dominant planetary embryos from the vast swarm of planetesimals, which is similar to the scenario described by Greenberg et al. (1978, Icarus 35, 1-26). The various approaches to simulation differ in many details, so comparison is now needed to understand the relation of assumed physical processes and computational approximations to the modeled evolutionary behavior of the system. The algorithms of Greenberg et al. for (a) mutual velocity stirring between planetesimals and (b) mass shifting between adjacent numerical "size-bins" are described in detail. Experiments with the original code, as well as with subsequent revisions, show that the computational methods were accurate to the level of precision appropriate at the time, and the model incorporated the relevant physics including dynamical friction, so its then-novel conclusions remain robust and generally in agreement with various, more recent models. We demonstrate that use of continuum equations is inappropriate for modeling growth with initially all-equal masses; numerical models with discrete building blocks allow incipient runaway growth even with such an initial condition.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2-19
Number of pages18
JournalIcarus
Volume98
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 1992

Fingerprint

planetesimal
accretion
protoplanets
growth modeling
simulation
embryo
embryos
stirring
physics
friction
planet
planets
continuums
experiment
approximation
code
physical process
comparison
method

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics

Cite this

A critical reanalysis of planetary accretion models. / Kolvoord, R. A.; Greenberg, Richard J.

In: Icarus, Vol. 98, No. 1, 1992, p. 2-19.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kolvoord, R. A. ; Greenberg, Richard J. / A critical reanalysis of planetary accretion models. In: Icarus. 1992 ; Vol. 98, No. 1. pp. 2-19.
@article{593462ca3a0e4972a0e0e506b4af74b3,
title = "A critical reanalysis of planetary accretion models",
abstract = "Planet formation models and simulations appear to be converging toward a consensus on how growth may have occured, at least up to the emergence of a few dominant planetary embryos from the vast swarm of planetesimals, which is similar to the scenario described by Greenberg et al. (1978, Icarus 35, 1-26). The various approaches to simulation differ in many details, so comparison is now needed to understand the relation of assumed physical processes and computational approximations to the modeled evolutionary behavior of the system. The algorithms of Greenberg et al. for (a) mutual velocity stirring between planetesimals and (b) mass shifting between adjacent numerical {"}size-bins{"} are described in detail. Experiments with the original code, as well as with subsequent revisions, show that the computational methods were accurate to the level of precision appropriate at the time, and the model incorporated the relevant physics including dynamical friction, so its then-novel conclusions remain robust and generally in agreement with various, more recent models. We demonstrate that use of continuum equations is inappropriate for modeling growth with initially all-equal masses; numerical models with discrete building blocks allow incipient runaway growth even with such an initial condition.",
author = "Kolvoord, {R. A.} and Greenberg, {Richard J.}",
year = "1992",
doi = "10.1016/0019-1035(92)90201-H",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "98",
pages = "2--19",
journal = "Icarus",
issn = "0019-1035",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A critical reanalysis of planetary accretion models

AU - Kolvoord, R. A.

AU - Greenberg, Richard J.

PY - 1992

Y1 - 1992

N2 - Planet formation models and simulations appear to be converging toward a consensus on how growth may have occured, at least up to the emergence of a few dominant planetary embryos from the vast swarm of planetesimals, which is similar to the scenario described by Greenberg et al. (1978, Icarus 35, 1-26). The various approaches to simulation differ in many details, so comparison is now needed to understand the relation of assumed physical processes and computational approximations to the modeled evolutionary behavior of the system. The algorithms of Greenberg et al. for (a) mutual velocity stirring between planetesimals and (b) mass shifting between adjacent numerical "size-bins" are described in detail. Experiments with the original code, as well as with subsequent revisions, show that the computational methods were accurate to the level of precision appropriate at the time, and the model incorporated the relevant physics including dynamical friction, so its then-novel conclusions remain robust and generally in agreement with various, more recent models. We demonstrate that use of continuum equations is inappropriate for modeling growth with initially all-equal masses; numerical models with discrete building blocks allow incipient runaway growth even with such an initial condition.

AB - Planet formation models and simulations appear to be converging toward a consensus on how growth may have occured, at least up to the emergence of a few dominant planetary embryos from the vast swarm of planetesimals, which is similar to the scenario described by Greenberg et al. (1978, Icarus 35, 1-26). The various approaches to simulation differ in many details, so comparison is now needed to understand the relation of assumed physical processes and computational approximations to the modeled evolutionary behavior of the system. The algorithms of Greenberg et al. for (a) mutual velocity stirring between planetesimals and (b) mass shifting between adjacent numerical "size-bins" are described in detail. Experiments with the original code, as well as with subsequent revisions, show that the computational methods were accurate to the level of precision appropriate at the time, and the model incorporated the relevant physics including dynamical friction, so its then-novel conclusions remain robust and generally in agreement with various, more recent models. We demonstrate that use of continuum equations is inappropriate for modeling growth with initially all-equal masses; numerical models with discrete building blocks allow incipient runaway growth even with such an initial condition.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0010876576&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0010876576&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/0019-1035(92)90201-H

DO - 10.1016/0019-1035(92)90201-H

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0010876576

VL - 98

SP - 2

EP - 19

JO - Icarus

JF - Icarus

SN - 0019-1035

IS - 1

ER -