A review of algae-based biofuel production: Sustainability and life cycle assessments

Christina Canter, Robert Handler, Chris Young, Paul Blowers, David Shonnard

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

The National Alliance for Advanced Biofuels and Bioproducts (NAABB) is a consortium of universities, bioenergy companies, and national laboratories whose goal is to overcome technical, economic, and environmental barriers to large scale algae-based biofuels production. One of the important areas in the NAABB research portfolio is environmental sustainability, and life cycle assessment of the entire algae-based biofuels value chain is one of the key integrative projects in this area. Due to lack of quality land and competition with food production, current terrestrial sources of carbohydrates for conversion to bio-ethanol or oils for conversion to bio-diesel are inadequate for fully meeting the United States' transportation fuel needs. Algal sources of biomass offer many novel sustainable opportunities to partially or fully replace the use of fossil fuels for motor vehicle use, due to large yields per unit of land area and low reliance on other inputs relative to other alternative feedstocks. This work evaluates past peer reviewed life cycle assessments (LCAs) of biofuels production using algae feedstocks to identify areas where prior analyses have missed opportunities for putting sustainability into a whole life cycle context, and also to conduct an analysis of the range of potential data being used to describe this emerging industry. System boundaries of prior studies are described to highlight limitations of past assessments and to aid in building more complete analyses with the use of additional experimental data. Regional and technological limitations are also evaluated, so that future work can consider these issues in their evaluations. Data quality of previous LCAs is discussed by distinguishing input in all studies as being assumed, modeled, or derived from experimental data, and by using our meta-analysis to provide appropriate uncertainties on several key system inputs. Our review of the LCA literature shows that there is a wide range in the quality of inventory data, and a prevalence of assumed (estimated) or modeled data as opposed to measured data. In addition, many previous studies omitted critical processing steps altogether due to lack of data and lack of knowledge. For example, previous assessments have not considered cell disruption methods and the energy requirements added to the total material and energy needs. Water evaporation from raceways has been either ignored or simplified without considering local weather through annual cycles to identify the water burden on the local region. When considering biodiesel production in warm sunny areas such as the southwestern United States, this may play a large role in the overall sustainability of the process. Models of the missing elements discussed above are introduced to show how the life cycle inventories (LCIs) and the resulting LCAs are impacted by the addition of new data. In many cases, it is found that neglecting some material and energy flows was unimportant to overall sustainability, but others are critically important, depending on the location of biofuel generation and processing. Impacts of different nutrient input sources with various levels of material recycling are also illustrated in an effort to indicate how system co-location or integration with other utilities and industries may be a critical factor in the economic and environmental sustainability of this technology.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publication11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings
StatePublished - 2011
Event2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, 11AIChE - Minneapolis, MN, United States
Duration: Oct 16 2011Oct 21 2011

Other

Other2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, 11AIChE
CountryUnited States
CityMinneapolis, MN
Period10/16/1110/21/11

Fingerprint

Biofuels
Algae
Sustainable development
Life cycle
Biodiesel
Feedstocks
Industry
Economics
Water
Carbohydrates
Processing
Fossil fuels
Nutrients
Recycling
Oils
Evaporation
Biomass
Ethanol

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemical Engineering(all)

Cite this

Canter, C., Handler, R., Young, C., Blowers, P., & Shonnard, D. (2011). A review of algae-based biofuel production: Sustainability and life cycle assessments. In 11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings

A review of algae-based biofuel production : Sustainability and life cycle assessments. / Canter, Christina; Handler, Robert; Young, Chris; Blowers, Paul; Shonnard, David.

11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings. 2011.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Canter, C, Handler, R, Young, C, Blowers, P & Shonnard, D 2011, A review of algae-based biofuel production: Sustainability and life cycle assessments. in 11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings. 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, 11AIChE, Minneapolis, MN, United States, 10/16/11.
Canter C, Handler R, Young C, Blowers P, Shonnard D. A review of algae-based biofuel production: Sustainability and life cycle assessments. In 11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings. 2011
Canter, Christina ; Handler, Robert ; Young, Chris ; Blowers, Paul ; Shonnard, David. / A review of algae-based biofuel production : Sustainability and life cycle assessments. 11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings. 2011.
@inproceedings{816b07240fd842ddb6f995750b03ec8f,
title = "A review of algae-based biofuel production: Sustainability and life cycle assessments",
abstract = "The National Alliance for Advanced Biofuels and Bioproducts (NAABB) is a consortium of universities, bioenergy companies, and national laboratories whose goal is to overcome technical, economic, and environmental barriers to large scale algae-based biofuels production. One of the important areas in the NAABB research portfolio is environmental sustainability, and life cycle assessment of the entire algae-based biofuels value chain is one of the key integrative projects in this area. Due to lack of quality land and competition with food production, current terrestrial sources of carbohydrates for conversion to bio-ethanol or oils for conversion to bio-diesel are inadequate for fully meeting the United States' transportation fuel needs. Algal sources of biomass offer many novel sustainable opportunities to partially or fully replace the use of fossil fuels for motor vehicle use, due to large yields per unit of land area and low reliance on other inputs relative to other alternative feedstocks. This work evaluates past peer reviewed life cycle assessments (LCAs) of biofuels production using algae feedstocks to identify areas where prior analyses have missed opportunities for putting sustainability into a whole life cycle context, and also to conduct an analysis of the range of potential data being used to describe this emerging industry. System boundaries of prior studies are described to highlight limitations of past assessments and to aid in building more complete analyses with the use of additional experimental data. Regional and technological limitations are also evaluated, so that future work can consider these issues in their evaluations. Data quality of previous LCAs is discussed by distinguishing input in all studies as being assumed, modeled, or derived from experimental data, and by using our meta-analysis to provide appropriate uncertainties on several key system inputs. Our review of the LCA literature shows that there is a wide range in the quality of inventory data, and a prevalence of assumed (estimated) or modeled data as opposed to measured data. In addition, many previous studies omitted critical processing steps altogether due to lack of data and lack of knowledge. For example, previous assessments have not considered cell disruption methods and the energy requirements added to the total material and energy needs. Water evaporation from raceways has been either ignored or simplified without considering local weather through annual cycles to identify the water burden on the local region. When considering biodiesel production in warm sunny areas such as the southwestern United States, this may play a large role in the overall sustainability of the process. Models of the missing elements discussed above are introduced to show how the life cycle inventories (LCIs) and the resulting LCAs are impacted by the addition of new data. In many cases, it is found that neglecting some material and energy flows was unimportant to overall sustainability, but others are critically important, depending on the location of biofuel generation and processing. Impacts of different nutrient input sources with various levels of material recycling are also illustrated in an effort to indicate how system co-location or integration with other utilities and industries may be a critical factor in the economic and environmental sustainability of this technology.",
author = "Christina Canter and Robert Handler and Chris Young and Paul Blowers and David Shonnard",
year = "2011",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9780816910700",
booktitle = "11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - A review of algae-based biofuel production

T2 - Sustainability and life cycle assessments

AU - Canter, Christina

AU - Handler, Robert

AU - Young, Chris

AU - Blowers, Paul

AU - Shonnard, David

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - The National Alliance for Advanced Biofuels and Bioproducts (NAABB) is a consortium of universities, bioenergy companies, and national laboratories whose goal is to overcome technical, economic, and environmental barriers to large scale algae-based biofuels production. One of the important areas in the NAABB research portfolio is environmental sustainability, and life cycle assessment of the entire algae-based biofuels value chain is one of the key integrative projects in this area. Due to lack of quality land and competition with food production, current terrestrial sources of carbohydrates for conversion to bio-ethanol or oils for conversion to bio-diesel are inadequate for fully meeting the United States' transportation fuel needs. Algal sources of biomass offer many novel sustainable opportunities to partially or fully replace the use of fossil fuels for motor vehicle use, due to large yields per unit of land area and low reliance on other inputs relative to other alternative feedstocks. This work evaluates past peer reviewed life cycle assessments (LCAs) of biofuels production using algae feedstocks to identify areas where prior analyses have missed opportunities for putting sustainability into a whole life cycle context, and also to conduct an analysis of the range of potential data being used to describe this emerging industry. System boundaries of prior studies are described to highlight limitations of past assessments and to aid in building more complete analyses with the use of additional experimental data. Regional and technological limitations are also evaluated, so that future work can consider these issues in their evaluations. Data quality of previous LCAs is discussed by distinguishing input in all studies as being assumed, modeled, or derived from experimental data, and by using our meta-analysis to provide appropriate uncertainties on several key system inputs. Our review of the LCA literature shows that there is a wide range in the quality of inventory data, and a prevalence of assumed (estimated) or modeled data as opposed to measured data. In addition, many previous studies omitted critical processing steps altogether due to lack of data and lack of knowledge. For example, previous assessments have not considered cell disruption methods and the energy requirements added to the total material and energy needs. Water evaporation from raceways has been either ignored or simplified without considering local weather through annual cycles to identify the water burden on the local region. When considering biodiesel production in warm sunny areas such as the southwestern United States, this may play a large role in the overall sustainability of the process. Models of the missing elements discussed above are introduced to show how the life cycle inventories (LCIs) and the resulting LCAs are impacted by the addition of new data. In many cases, it is found that neglecting some material and energy flows was unimportant to overall sustainability, but others are critically important, depending on the location of biofuel generation and processing. Impacts of different nutrient input sources with various levels of material recycling are also illustrated in an effort to indicate how system co-location or integration with other utilities and industries may be a critical factor in the economic and environmental sustainability of this technology.

AB - The National Alliance for Advanced Biofuels and Bioproducts (NAABB) is a consortium of universities, bioenergy companies, and national laboratories whose goal is to overcome technical, economic, and environmental barriers to large scale algae-based biofuels production. One of the important areas in the NAABB research portfolio is environmental sustainability, and life cycle assessment of the entire algae-based biofuels value chain is one of the key integrative projects in this area. Due to lack of quality land and competition with food production, current terrestrial sources of carbohydrates for conversion to bio-ethanol or oils for conversion to bio-diesel are inadequate for fully meeting the United States' transportation fuel needs. Algal sources of biomass offer many novel sustainable opportunities to partially or fully replace the use of fossil fuels for motor vehicle use, due to large yields per unit of land area and low reliance on other inputs relative to other alternative feedstocks. This work evaluates past peer reviewed life cycle assessments (LCAs) of biofuels production using algae feedstocks to identify areas where prior analyses have missed opportunities for putting sustainability into a whole life cycle context, and also to conduct an analysis of the range of potential data being used to describe this emerging industry. System boundaries of prior studies are described to highlight limitations of past assessments and to aid in building more complete analyses with the use of additional experimental data. Regional and technological limitations are also evaluated, so that future work can consider these issues in their evaluations. Data quality of previous LCAs is discussed by distinguishing input in all studies as being assumed, modeled, or derived from experimental data, and by using our meta-analysis to provide appropriate uncertainties on several key system inputs. Our review of the LCA literature shows that there is a wide range in the quality of inventory data, and a prevalence of assumed (estimated) or modeled data as opposed to measured data. In addition, many previous studies omitted critical processing steps altogether due to lack of data and lack of knowledge. For example, previous assessments have not considered cell disruption methods and the energy requirements added to the total material and energy needs. Water evaporation from raceways has been either ignored or simplified without considering local weather through annual cycles to identify the water burden on the local region. When considering biodiesel production in warm sunny areas such as the southwestern United States, this may play a large role in the overall sustainability of the process. Models of the missing elements discussed above are introduced to show how the life cycle inventories (LCIs) and the resulting LCAs are impacted by the addition of new data. In many cases, it is found that neglecting some material and energy flows was unimportant to overall sustainability, but others are critically important, depending on the location of biofuel generation and processing. Impacts of different nutrient input sources with various levels of material recycling are also illustrated in an effort to indicate how system co-location or integration with other utilities and industries may be a critical factor in the economic and environmental sustainability of this technology.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84857202071&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84857202071&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:84857202071

SN - 9780816910700

BT - 11AIChE - 2011 AIChE Annual Meeting, Conference Proceedings

ER -