A separable two-dimensional random field model of binary response data from multi-day behavioral experiments

Noa Malem-Shinitski, Yingzhuo Zhang, Daniel T. Gray, Sara N. Burke, Anne C. Smith, Carol A Barnes, Demba Ba

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: The study of learning in populations of subjects can provide insights into the changes that occur in the brain with aging, drug intervention, and psychiatric disease. New method: We introduce a separable two-dimensional (2D) random field (RF) model for analyzing binary response data acquired during the learning of object-reward associations across multiple days. The method can quantify the variability of performance within a day and across days, and can capture abrupt changes in learning. Results: We apply the method to data from young and aged macaque monkeys performing a reversal-learning task. The method provides an estimate of performance within a day for each age group, and a learning rate across days for each monkey. We find that, as a group, the older monkeys require more trials to learn the object discriminations than do the young monkeys, and that the cognitive flexibility of the younger group is higher. We also use the model estimates of performance as features for clustering the monkeys into two groups. The clustering results in two groups that, for the most part, coincide with those formed by the age groups. Simulation studies suggest that clustering captures inter-individual differences in performance levels. Comparison with existing method(s): In comparison with generalized linear models, this method is better able to capture the inherent two-dimensional nature of the data and find between group differences. Conclusions: Applied to binary response data from groups of individuals performing multi-day behavioral experiments, the model discriminates between-group differences and identifies subgroups.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalJournal of Neuroscience Methods
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

Haplorhini
Learning
Cluster Analysis
Age Groups
Reversal Learning
Macaca
Reward
Individuality
Psychiatry
Linear Models
Brain
Pharmaceutical Preparations
Population

Keywords

  • Aging
  • Bayesian inference
  • Behavior
  • Change-point test
  • EM algorithm
  • Gibbs sampling
  • Laplace prior
  • Learning
  • MAP estimation
  • Markov Chain Monte Carlo
  • Reversal learning task
  • Separable random field model

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

A separable two-dimensional random field model of binary response data from multi-day behavioral experiments. / Malem-Shinitski, Noa; Zhang, Yingzhuo; Gray, Daniel T.; Burke, Sara N.; Smith, Anne C.; Barnes, Carol A; Ba, Demba.

In: Journal of Neuroscience Methods, 01.01.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Malem-Shinitski, Noa ; Zhang, Yingzhuo ; Gray, Daniel T. ; Burke, Sara N. ; Smith, Anne C. ; Barnes, Carol A ; Ba, Demba. / A separable two-dimensional random field model of binary response data from multi-day behavioral experiments. In: Journal of Neuroscience Methods. 2018.
@article{ca87e039fd8f4156b4cae594193774ca,
title = "A separable two-dimensional random field model of binary response data from multi-day behavioral experiments",
abstract = "Background: The study of learning in populations of subjects can provide insights into the changes that occur in the brain with aging, drug intervention, and psychiatric disease. New method: We introduce a separable two-dimensional (2D) random field (RF) model for analyzing binary response data acquired during the learning of object-reward associations across multiple days. The method can quantify the variability of performance within a day and across days, and can capture abrupt changes in learning. Results: We apply the method to data from young and aged macaque monkeys performing a reversal-learning task. The method provides an estimate of performance within a day for each age group, and a learning rate across days for each monkey. We find that, as a group, the older monkeys require more trials to learn the object discriminations than do the young monkeys, and that the cognitive flexibility of the younger group is higher. We also use the model estimates of performance as features for clustering the monkeys into two groups. The clustering results in two groups that, for the most part, coincide with those formed by the age groups. Simulation studies suggest that clustering captures inter-individual differences in performance levels. Comparison with existing method(s): In comparison with generalized linear models, this method is better able to capture the inherent two-dimensional nature of the data and find between group differences. Conclusions: Applied to binary response data from groups of individuals performing multi-day behavioral experiments, the model discriminates between-group differences and identifies subgroups.",
keywords = "Aging, Bayesian inference, Behavior, Change-point test, EM algorithm, Gibbs sampling, Laplace prior, Learning, MAP estimation, Markov Chain Monte Carlo, Reversal learning task, Separable random field model",
author = "Noa Malem-Shinitski and Yingzhuo Zhang and Gray, {Daniel T.} and Burke, {Sara N.} and Smith, {Anne C.} and Barnes, {Carol A} and Demba Ba",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jneumeth.2018.04.006",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Journal of Neuroscience Methods",
issn = "0165-0270",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A separable two-dimensional random field model of binary response data from multi-day behavioral experiments

AU - Malem-Shinitski, Noa

AU - Zhang, Yingzhuo

AU - Gray, Daniel T.

AU - Burke, Sara N.

AU - Smith, Anne C.

AU - Barnes, Carol A

AU - Ba, Demba

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Background: The study of learning in populations of subjects can provide insights into the changes that occur in the brain with aging, drug intervention, and psychiatric disease. New method: We introduce a separable two-dimensional (2D) random field (RF) model for analyzing binary response data acquired during the learning of object-reward associations across multiple days. The method can quantify the variability of performance within a day and across days, and can capture abrupt changes in learning. Results: We apply the method to data from young and aged macaque monkeys performing a reversal-learning task. The method provides an estimate of performance within a day for each age group, and a learning rate across days for each monkey. We find that, as a group, the older monkeys require more trials to learn the object discriminations than do the young monkeys, and that the cognitive flexibility of the younger group is higher. We also use the model estimates of performance as features for clustering the monkeys into two groups. The clustering results in two groups that, for the most part, coincide with those formed by the age groups. Simulation studies suggest that clustering captures inter-individual differences in performance levels. Comparison with existing method(s): In comparison with generalized linear models, this method is better able to capture the inherent two-dimensional nature of the data and find between group differences. Conclusions: Applied to binary response data from groups of individuals performing multi-day behavioral experiments, the model discriminates between-group differences and identifies subgroups.

AB - Background: The study of learning in populations of subjects can provide insights into the changes that occur in the brain with aging, drug intervention, and psychiatric disease. New method: We introduce a separable two-dimensional (2D) random field (RF) model for analyzing binary response data acquired during the learning of object-reward associations across multiple days. The method can quantify the variability of performance within a day and across days, and can capture abrupt changes in learning. Results: We apply the method to data from young and aged macaque monkeys performing a reversal-learning task. The method provides an estimate of performance within a day for each age group, and a learning rate across days for each monkey. We find that, as a group, the older monkeys require more trials to learn the object discriminations than do the young monkeys, and that the cognitive flexibility of the younger group is higher. We also use the model estimates of performance as features for clustering the monkeys into two groups. The clustering results in two groups that, for the most part, coincide with those formed by the age groups. Simulation studies suggest that clustering captures inter-individual differences in performance levels. Comparison with existing method(s): In comparison with generalized linear models, this method is better able to capture the inherent two-dimensional nature of the data and find between group differences. Conclusions: Applied to binary response data from groups of individuals performing multi-day behavioral experiments, the model discriminates between-group differences and identifies subgroups.

KW - Aging

KW - Bayesian inference

KW - Behavior

KW - Change-point test

KW - EM algorithm

KW - Gibbs sampling

KW - Laplace prior

KW - Learning

KW - MAP estimation

KW - Markov Chain Monte Carlo

KW - Reversal learning task

KW - Separable random field model

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85049610929&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85049610929&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2018.04.006

DO - 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2018.04.006

M3 - Article

C2 - 29679704

AN - SCOPUS:85049610929

JO - Journal of Neuroscience Methods

JF - Journal of Neuroscience Methods

SN - 0165-0270

ER -