Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment

Alan R. Dennis, Annette C. Easton, George K. Easton, Joey F. George, Jay F Nunamaker

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Most experimental group research (whether conducted in an Electronic Meeting System (EMS) environment or not) has used ad hoc groups (i.e., randomly assembled groups of individuals that have no history and no future) rather than established groups that have a history and probable future of working together. This may be one factor that partially accounts for the differences in research findings between prior EMS experimental and field research. The present study, which examined otherwise similar ad hoc and established groups working in similar EMS environments, found that, while the total amount of communication within both types of groups was similar, there were significant differences in the type of communication that occurred. Established groups made more uninhibited comments and more process-oriented comments, had a less equal distribution of participation among the group members, and perceived a lesser focus on the task. While there were similar levels of direct conflict within the two types of groups, members of ad hoc groups were more likely to 'sugar-coat negative comments. For ad hoc groups, conflict was negatively correlated with the quality of meeting outcomes. Perhaps the most interesting finding for future research is that there was a significantly higher degree of variability among the established groups across virtually all measures, i.e., ad hoc groups tended to be more similar, while established groups exhibited distinct personalities.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationProceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science
EditorsLee W. Hoevel, Bruce D. Shriver, Jay F.Jr. Nunamaker, Ralph H.Jr. Sprague, Velijko Milutinovic
PublisherPubl by Western Periodicals Co
Pages23-29
Number of pages7
Volume3
ISBN (Print)0818620102
StatePublished - 1990
EventProceedings of the Twenty-Third Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Volume 1: Architecture Track - Kailua-Kona, HI, USA
Duration: Jan 2 1990Jan 5 1990

Other

OtherProceedings of the Twenty-Third Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Volume 1: Architecture Track
CityKailua-Kona, HI, USA
Period1/2/901/5/90

Fingerprint

Communication
Sugars

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Engineering(all)
  • Software
  • Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering

Cite this

Dennis, A. R., Easton, A. C., Easton, G. K., George, J. F., & Nunamaker, J. F. (1990). Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment. In L. W. Hoevel, B. D. Shriver, J. F. J. Nunamaker, R. H. J. Sprague, & V. Milutinovic (Eds.), Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science (Vol. 3, pp. 23-29). Publ by Western Periodicals Co.

Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment. / Dennis, Alan R.; Easton, Annette C.; Easton, George K.; George, Joey F.; Nunamaker, Jay F.

Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science. ed. / Lee W. Hoevel; Bruce D. Shriver; Jay F.Jr. Nunamaker; Ralph H.Jr. Sprague; Velijko Milutinovic. Vol. 3 Publ by Western Periodicals Co, 1990. p. 23-29.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Dennis, AR, Easton, AC, Easton, GK, George, JF & Nunamaker, JF 1990, Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment. in LW Hoevel, BD Shriver, JFJ Nunamaker, RHJ Sprague & V Milutinovic (eds), Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science. vol. 3, Publ by Western Periodicals Co, pp. 23-29, Proceedings of the Twenty-Third Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Volume 1: Architecture Track, Kailua-Kona, HI, USA, 1/2/90.
Dennis AR, Easton AC, Easton GK, George JF, Nunamaker JF. Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment. In Hoevel LW, Shriver BD, Nunamaker JFJ, Sprague RHJ, Milutinovic V, editors, Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science. Vol. 3. Publ by Western Periodicals Co. 1990. p. 23-29
Dennis, Alan R. ; Easton, Annette C. ; Easton, George K. ; George, Joey F. ; Nunamaker, Jay F. / Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment. Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science. editor / Lee W. Hoevel ; Bruce D. Shriver ; Jay F.Jr. Nunamaker ; Ralph H.Jr. Sprague ; Velijko Milutinovic. Vol. 3 Publ by Western Periodicals Co, 1990. pp. 23-29
@inproceedings{d14a731d74bc4788a27e0ade9f7bac53,
title = "Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment",
abstract = "Most experimental group research (whether conducted in an Electronic Meeting System (EMS) environment or not) has used ad hoc groups (i.e., randomly assembled groups of individuals that have no history and no future) rather than established groups that have a history and probable future of working together. This may be one factor that partially accounts for the differences in research findings between prior EMS experimental and field research. The present study, which examined otherwise similar ad hoc and established groups working in similar EMS environments, found that, while the total amount of communication within both types of groups was similar, there were significant differences in the type of communication that occurred. Established groups made more uninhibited comments and more process-oriented comments, had a less equal distribution of participation among the group members, and perceived a lesser focus on the task. While there were similar levels of direct conflict within the two types of groups, members of ad hoc groups were more likely to 'sugar-coat negative comments. For ad hoc groups, conflict was negatively correlated with the quality of meeting outcomes. Perhaps the most interesting finding for future research is that there was a significantly higher degree of variability among the established groups across virtually all measures, i.e., ad hoc groups tended to be more similar, while established groups exhibited distinct personalities.",
author = "Dennis, {Alan R.} and Easton, {Annette C.} and Easton, {George K.} and George, {Joey F.} and Nunamaker, {Jay F}",
year = "1990",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "0818620102",
volume = "3",
pages = "23--29",
editor = "Hoevel, {Lee W.} and Shriver, {Bruce D.} and Nunamaker, {Jay F.Jr.} and Sprague, {Ralph H.Jr.} and Velijko Milutinovic",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science",
publisher = "Publ by Western Periodicals Co",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Ad hoc versus established groups in an electronic meeting system environment

AU - Dennis, Alan R.

AU - Easton, Annette C.

AU - Easton, George K.

AU - George, Joey F.

AU - Nunamaker, Jay F

PY - 1990

Y1 - 1990

N2 - Most experimental group research (whether conducted in an Electronic Meeting System (EMS) environment or not) has used ad hoc groups (i.e., randomly assembled groups of individuals that have no history and no future) rather than established groups that have a history and probable future of working together. This may be one factor that partially accounts for the differences in research findings between prior EMS experimental and field research. The present study, which examined otherwise similar ad hoc and established groups working in similar EMS environments, found that, while the total amount of communication within both types of groups was similar, there were significant differences in the type of communication that occurred. Established groups made more uninhibited comments and more process-oriented comments, had a less equal distribution of participation among the group members, and perceived a lesser focus on the task. While there were similar levels of direct conflict within the two types of groups, members of ad hoc groups were more likely to 'sugar-coat negative comments. For ad hoc groups, conflict was negatively correlated with the quality of meeting outcomes. Perhaps the most interesting finding for future research is that there was a significantly higher degree of variability among the established groups across virtually all measures, i.e., ad hoc groups tended to be more similar, while established groups exhibited distinct personalities.

AB - Most experimental group research (whether conducted in an Electronic Meeting System (EMS) environment or not) has used ad hoc groups (i.e., randomly assembled groups of individuals that have no history and no future) rather than established groups that have a history and probable future of working together. This may be one factor that partially accounts for the differences in research findings between prior EMS experimental and field research. The present study, which examined otherwise similar ad hoc and established groups working in similar EMS environments, found that, while the total amount of communication within both types of groups was similar, there were significant differences in the type of communication that occurred. Established groups made more uninhibited comments and more process-oriented comments, had a less equal distribution of participation among the group members, and perceived a lesser focus on the task. While there were similar levels of direct conflict within the two types of groups, members of ad hoc groups were more likely to 'sugar-coat negative comments. For ad hoc groups, conflict was negatively correlated with the quality of meeting outcomes. Perhaps the most interesting finding for future research is that there was a significantly higher degree of variability among the established groups across virtually all measures, i.e., ad hoc groups tended to be more similar, while established groups exhibited distinct personalities.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0025225930&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0025225930&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:0025225930

SN - 0818620102

VL - 3

SP - 23

EP - 29

BT - Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Science

A2 - Hoevel, Lee W.

A2 - Shriver, Bruce D.

A2 - Nunamaker, Jay F.Jr.

A2 - Sprague, Ralph H.Jr.

A2 - Milutinovic, Velijko

PB - Publ by Western Periodicals Co

ER -