An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard

P. H. Blard, G. Balco, P. G. Burnard, K. A. Farley, C. R. Fenton, R. Friedrich, A. J.T. Jull, S. Niedermann, R. Pik, J. M. Schaefer, E. M. Scott, D. L. Shuster, F. M. Stuart, M. Stute, B. Tibari, G. Winckler, L. Zimmermann

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

25 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This study reports an inter-laboratory comparison of the 3He and 4He concentrations measured in the pyroxene material CRONUS-P. This forms part of the CRONUS-Earth and CRONUS-EU programs, which also produced a series of natural reference materials for in situ produced 26Al, 10Be, 14C, 21Ne and 36Cl.Six laboratories (GFZ Potsdam, Caltech Pasadena, CRPG Nancy, SUERC Glasgow, BGC Berkeley, Lamont New York) participated in this intercomparison experiment, analyzing between 5 and 22 aliquots each. Intra-laboratory results yield 3He concentrations that are consistent with the reported analytical uncertainties, which suggests that 3He is homogeneous within CRONUS-P. The inter-laboratory dataset (66 determinations from the 6 different labs) is characterized by a global weighted mean of (5.02±0.12)×109atg-1 with an overdispersion of 5.6% (2σ). 4He is characterized by a larger variability than 3He, and by an inter-lab global weighted mean of (3.60±0.18)×1013atg-1 (2σ) with an overdispersion of 10.4% (2σ).There are, however, some systematic differences between the six laboratories. More precisely, 2 laboratories obtained mean 3He concentrations that are about 6% higher than the clustered other 4 laboratories. This systematic bias is larger than the analytical uncertainty and not related to the CRONUS-P material (see Schaefer etal., 2015). Reasons for these inter-laboratory offsets are difficult to identify but are discussed below. To improve the precision of cosmogenic 3He dating, we suggest that future studies presenting cosmogenic 3He results also report the 3He concentration measured in the CRONUS-P material in the lab(s) used in a given study.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)11-19
Number of pages9
JournalQuaternary Geochronology
Volume26
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2015

Fingerprint

interlaboratory comparison
pyroxene
laboratory
material

Keywords

  • He
  • He
  • Calibration
  • Cosmogenic
  • CRONUS-P
  • Radiogenic
  • Standard

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geology
  • Stratigraphy
  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Blard, P. H., Balco, G., Burnard, P. G., Farley, K. A., Fenton, C. R., Friedrich, R., ... Zimmermann, L. (2015). An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard. Quaternary Geochronology, 26(1), 11-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quageo.2014.08.004

An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard. / Blard, P. H.; Balco, G.; Burnard, P. G.; Farley, K. A.; Fenton, C. R.; Friedrich, R.; Jull, A. J.T.; Niedermann, S.; Pik, R.; Schaefer, J. M.; Scott, E. M.; Shuster, D. L.; Stuart, F. M.; Stute, M.; Tibari, B.; Winckler, G.; Zimmermann, L.

In: Quaternary Geochronology, Vol. 26, No. 1, 01.01.2015, p. 11-19.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Blard, PH, Balco, G, Burnard, PG, Farley, KA, Fenton, CR, Friedrich, R, Jull, AJT, Niedermann, S, Pik, R, Schaefer, JM, Scott, EM, Shuster, DL, Stuart, FM, Stute, M, Tibari, B, Winckler, G & Zimmermann, L 2015, 'An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard', Quaternary Geochronology, vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 11-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quageo.2014.08.004
Blard, P. H. ; Balco, G. ; Burnard, P. G. ; Farley, K. A. ; Fenton, C. R. ; Friedrich, R. ; Jull, A. J.T. ; Niedermann, S. ; Pik, R. ; Schaefer, J. M. ; Scott, E. M. ; Shuster, D. L. ; Stuart, F. M. ; Stute, M. ; Tibari, B. ; Winckler, G. ; Zimmermann, L. / An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard. In: Quaternary Geochronology. 2015 ; Vol. 26, No. 1. pp. 11-19.
@article{06dcaadc89124c6c96a708204bf39dad,
title = "An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard",
abstract = "This study reports an inter-laboratory comparison of the 3He and 4He concentrations measured in the pyroxene material CRONUS-P. This forms part of the CRONUS-Earth and CRONUS-EU programs, which also produced a series of natural reference materials for in situ produced 26Al, 10Be, 14C, 21Ne and 36Cl.Six laboratories (GFZ Potsdam, Caltech Pasadena, CRPG Nancy, SUERC Glasgow, BGC Berkeley, Lamont New York) participated in this intercomparison experiment, analyzing between 5 and 22 aliquots each. Intra-laboratory results yield 3He concentrations that are consistent with the reported analytical uncertainties, which suggests that 3He is homogeneous within CRONUS-P. The inter-laboratory dataset (66 determinations from the 6 different labs) is characterized by a global weighted mean of (5.02±0.12)×109atg-1 with an overdispersion of 5.6{\%} (2σ). 4He is characterized by a larger variability than 3He, and by an inter-lab global weighted mean of (3.60±0.18)×1013atg-1 (2σ) with an overdispersion of 10.4{\%} (2σ).There are, however, some systematic differences between the six laboratories. More precisely, 2 laboratories obtained mean 3He concentrations that are about 6{\%} higher than the clustered other 4 laboratories. This systematic bias is larger than the analytical uncertainty and not related to the CRONUS-P material (see Schaefer etal., 2015). Reasons for these inter-laboratory offsets are difficult to identify but are discussed below. To improve the precision of cosmogenic 3He dating, we suggest that future studies presenting cosmogenic 3He results also report the 3He concentration measured in the CRONUS-P material in the lab(s) used in a given study.",
keywords = "He, He, Calibration, Cosmogenic, CRONUS-P, Radiogenic, Standard",
author = "Blard, {P. H.} and G. Balco and Burnard, {P. G.} and Farley, {K. A.} and Fenton, {C. R.} and R. Friedrich and Jull, {A. J.T.} and S. Niedermann and R. Pik and Schaefer, {J. M.} and Scott, {E. M.} and Shuster, {D. L.} and Stuart, {F. M.} and M. Stute and B. Tibari and G. Winckler and L. Zimmermann",
year = "2015",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.quageo.2014.08.004",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "26",
pages = "11--19",
journal = "Quaternary Geochronology",
issn = "1871-1014",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - An inter-laboratory comparison of cosmogenic 3He and radiogenic 4He in the CRONUS-P pyroxene standard

AU - Blard, P. H.

AU - Balco, G.

AU - Burnard, P. G.

AU - Farley, K. A.

AU - Fenton, C. R.

AU - Friedrich, R.

AU - Jull, A. J.T.

AU - Niedermann, S.

AU - Pik, R.

AU - Schaefer, J. M.

AU - Scott, E. M.

AU - Shuster, D. L.

AU - Stuart, F. M.

AU - Stute, M.

AU - Tibari, B.

AU - Winckler, G.

AU - Zimmermann, L.

PY - 2015/1/1

Y1 - 2015/1/1

N2 - This study reports an inter-laboratory comparison of the 3He and 4He concentrations measured in the pyroxene material CRONUS-P. This forms part of the CRONUS-Earth and CRONUS-EU programs, which also produced a series of natural reference materials for in situ produced 26Al, 10Be, 14C, 21Ne and 36Cl.Six laboratories (GFZ Potsdam, Caltech Pasadena, CRPG Nancy, SUERC Glasgow, BGC Berkeley, Lamont New York) participated in this intercomparison experiment, analyzing between 5 and 22 aliquots each. Intra-laboratory results yield 3He concentrations that are consistent with the reported analytical uncertainties, which suggests that 3He is homogeneous within CRONUS-P. The inter-laboratory dataset (66 determinations from the 6 different labs) is characterized by a global weighted mean of (5.02±0.12)×109atg-1 with an overdispersion of 5.6% (2σ). 4He is characterized by a larger variability than 3He, and by an inter-lab global weighted mean of (3.60±0.18)×1013atg-1 (2σ) with an overdispersion of 10.4% (2σ).There are, however, some systematic differences between the six laboratories. More precisely, 2 laboratories obtained mean 3He concentrations that are about 6% higher than the clustered other 4 laboratories. This systematic bias is larger than the analytical uncertainty and not related to the CRONUS-P material (see Schaefer etal., 2015). Reasons for these inter-laboratory offsets are difficult to identify but are discussed below. To improve the precision of cosmogenic 3He dating, we suggest that future studies presenting cosmogenic 3He results also report the 3He concentration measured in the CRONUS-P material in the lab(s) used in a given study.

AB - This study reports an inter-laboratory comparison of the 3He and 4He concentrations measured in the pyroxene material CRONUS-P. This forms part of the CRONUS-Earth and CRONUS-EU programs, which also produced a series of natural reference materials for in situ produced 26Al, 10Be, 14C, 21Ne and 36Cl.Six laboratories (GFZ Potsdam, Caltech Pasadena, CRPG Nancy, SUERC Glasgow, BGC Berkeley, Lamont New York) participated in this intercomparison experiment, analyzing between 5 and 22 aliquots each. Intra-laboratory results yield 3He concentrations that are consistent with the reported analytical uncertainties, which suggests that 3He is homogeneous within CRONUS-P. The inter-laboratory dataset (66 determinations from the 6 different labs) is characterized by a global weighted mean of (5.02±0.12)×109atg-1 with an overdispersion of 5.6% (2σ). 4He is characterized by a larger variability than 3He, and by an inter-lab global weighted mean of (3.60±0.18)×1013atg-1 (2σ) with an overdispersion of 10.4% (2σ).There are, however, some systematic differences between the six laboratories. More precisely, 2 laboratories obtained mean 3He concentrations that are about 6% higher than the clustered other 4 laboratories. This systematic bias is larger than the analytical uncertainty and not related to the CRONUS-P material (see Schaefer etal., 2015). Reasons for these inter-laboratory offsets are difficult to identify but are discussed below. To improve the precision of cosmogenic 3He dating, we suggest that future studies presenting cosmogenic 3He results also report the 3He concentration measured in the CRONUS-P material in the lab(s) used in a given study.

KW - He

KW - He

KW - Calibration

KW - Cosmogenic

KW - CRONUS-P

KW - Radiogenic

KW - Standard

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85027944746&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85027944746&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.quageo.2014.08.004

DO - 10.1016/j.quageo.2014.08.004

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85027944746

VL - 26

SP - 11

EP - 19

JO - Quaternary Geochronology

JF - Quaternary Geochronology

SN - 1871-1014

IS - 1

ER -