Aversion and attraction to harmful plant secondary compounds jointly shape the foraging ecology of a specialist herbivore

Parris T. Humphrey, Andrew D. Gloss, Nicolas M. Alexandre, Martha M. Villalobos, Marcella R. Fremgen, Simon C. Groen, Lisa N. Meihls, Georg Jander, Noah K Whiteman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Most herbivorous insect species are restricted to a narrow taxonomic range of host plant species. Herbivore species that feed on mustard plants and their relatives in the Brassicales have evolved highly efficient detoxification mechanisms that actually prevent toxic mustard oils from forming in the bodies of the animals. However, these mechanisms likely were not present during the initial stages of specialization on mustard plants ~100 million years ago. The herbivorous fly Scaptomyza nigrita (Drosophilidae) is a specialist on a single mustard species, bittercress (Cardamine cordifolia; Brassicaceae) and is in a fly lineage that evolved to feed on mustards only in the past 10-20 million years. In contrast to many mustard specialists, S. nigrita does not prevent formation of toxic breakdown products (mustard oils) arising from glucosinolates (GLS), the primary defensive compounds in mustard plants. Therefore, it is an appealing model for dissecting the early stages of host specialization. Because mustard oils actually form in the bodies of S. nigrita, we hypothesized that in lieu of a specialized detoxification mechanism, S. nigrita may mitigate exposure to high GLS levels within plant tissues using behavioral avoidance. Here, we report that jasmonic acid (JA) treatment increased GLS biosynthesis in bittercress, repelled adult female flies, and reduced larval growth. S. nigrita larval damage also induced foliar GLS, especially in apical leaves, which correspondingly displayed the least S. nigrita damage in controlled feeding trials and field surveys. Paradoxically, flies preferred to feed and oviposit on GLS-producing Arabidopsis thaliana despite larvae performing worse in these plants versus non-GLS-producing mutants. GLS may be feeding cues for S. nigrita despite their deterrent and defensive properties, which underscores the diverse relationship a mustard specialist has with its host when lacking a specialized means of mustard oil detoxification.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalEcology and Evolution
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - 2016

Fingerprint

mustard (condiment)
glucosinolates
herbivore
herbivores
mustard oil
foraging
ecology
detoxification
oil
damage
Scaptomyza
Brassicales
Cardamine
field survey
host plant
Drosophilidae
phytophagous insects
jasmonic acid
acid treatment
Brassicaceae

Keywords

  • Drosophila
  • Glucosinolate
  • Inducible defense
  • Jasmonic acid
  • Oviposition
  • Preference-performance

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Ecology
  • Nature and Landscape Conservation

Cite this

Aversion and attraction to harmful plant secondary compounds jointly shape the foraging ecology of a specialist herbivore. / Humphrey, Parris T.; Gloss, Andrew D.; Alexandre, Nicolas M.; Villalobos, Martha M.; Fremgen, Marcella R.; Groen, Simon C.; Meihls, Lisa N.; Jander, Georg; Whiteman, Noah K.

In: Ecology and Evolution, 2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Humphrey, Parris T. ; Gloss, Andrew D. ; Alexandre, Nicolas M. ; Villalobos, Martha M. ; Fremgen, Marcella R. ; Groen, Simon C. ; Meihls, Lisa N. ; Jander, Georg ; Whiteman, Noah K. / Aversion and attraction to harmful plant secondary compounds jointly shape the foraging ecology of a specialist herbivore. In: Ecology and Evolution. 2016.
@article{08ff97b8f2624abcbf8ed44ece0711fc,
title = "Aversion and attraction to harmful plant secondary compounds jointly shape the foraging ecology of a specialist herbivore",
abstract = "Most herbivorous insect species are restricted to a narrow taxonomic range of host plant species. Herbivore species that feed on mustard plants and their relatives in the Brassicales have evolved highly efficient detoxification mechanisms that actually prevent toxic mustard oils from forming in the bodies of the animals. However, these mechanisms likely were not present during the initial stages of specialization on mustard plants ~100 million years ago. The herbivorous fly Scaptomyza nigrita (Drosophilidae) is a specialist on a single mustard species, bittercress (Cardamine cordifolia; Brassicaceae) and is in a fly lineage that evolved to feed on mustards only in the past 10-20 million years. In contrast to many mustard specialists, S. nigrita does not prevent formation of toxic breakdown products (mustard oils) arising from glucosinolates (GLS), the primary defensive compounds in mustard plants. Therefore, it is an appealing model for dissecting the early stages of host specialization. Because mustard oils actually form in the bodies of S. nigrita, we hypothesized that in lieu of a specialized detoxification mechanism, S. nigrita may mitigate exposure to high GLS levels within plant tissues using behavioral avoidance. Here, we report that jasmonic acid (JA) treatment increased GLS biosynthesis in bittercress, repelled adult female flies, and reduced larval growth. S. nigrita larval damage also induced foliar GLS, especially in apical leaves, which correspondingly displayed the least S. nigrita damage in controlled feeding trials and field surveys. Paradoxically, flies preferred to feed and oviposit on GLS-producing Arabidopsis thaliana despite larvae performing worse in these plants versus non-GLS-producing mutants. GLS may be feeding cues for S. nigrita despite their deterrent and defensive properties, which underscores the diverse relationship a mustard specialist has with its host when lacking a specialized means of mustard oil detoxification.",
keywords = "Drosophila, Glucosinolate, Inducible defense, Jasmonic acid, Oviposition, Preference-performance",
author = "Humphrey, {Parris T.} and Gloss, {Andrew D.} and Alexandre, {Nicolas M.} and Villalobos, {Martha M.} and Fremgen, {Marcella R.} and Groen, {Simon C.} and Meihls, {Lisa N.} and Georg Jander and Whiteman, {Noah K}",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1002/ece3.2082",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Ecology and Evolution",
issn = "2045-7758",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Aversion and attraction to harmful plant secondary compounds jointly shape the foraging ecology of a specialist herbivore

AU - Humphrey, Parris T.

AU - Gloss, Andrew D.

AU - Alexandre, Nicolas M.

AU - Villalobos, Martha M.

AU - Fremgen, Marcella R.

AU - Groen, Simon C.

AU - Meihls, Lisa N.

AU - Jander, Georg

AU - Whiteman, Noah K

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Most herbivorous insect species are restricted to a narrow taxonomic range of host plant species. Herbivore species that feed on mustard plants and their relatives in the Brassicales have evolved highly efficient detoxification mechanisms that actually prevent toxic mustard oils from forming in the bodies of the animals. However, these mechanisms likely were not present during the initial stages of specialization on mustard plants ~100 million years ago. The herbivorous fly Scaptomyza nigrita (Drosophilidae) is a specialist on a single mustard species, bittercress (Cardamine cordifolia; Brassicaceae) and is in a fly lineage that evolved to feed on mustards only in the past 10-20 million years. In contrast to many mustard specialists, S. nigrita does not prevent formation of toxic breakdown products (mustard oils) arising from glucosinolates (GLS), the primary defensive compounds in mustard plants. Therefore, it is an appealing model for dissecting the early stages of host specialization. Because mustard oils actually form in the bodies of S. nigrita, we hypothesized that in lieu of a specialized detoxification mechanism, S. nigrita may mitigate exposure to high GLS levels within plant tissues using behavioral avoidance. Here, we report that jasmonic acid (JA) treatment increased GLS biosynthesis in bittercress, repelled adult female flies, and reduced larval growth. S. nigrita larval damage also induced foliar GLS, especially in apical leaves, which correspondingly displayed the least S. nigrita damage in controlled feeding trials and field surveys. Paradoxically, flies preferred to feed and oviposit on GLS-producing Arabidopsis thaliana despite larvae performing worse in these plants versus non-GLS-producing mutants. GLS may be feeding cues for S. nigrita despite their deterrent and defensive properties, which underscores the diverse relationship a mustard specialist has with its host when lacking a specialized means of mustard oil detoxification.

AB - Most herbivorous insect species are restricted to a narrow taxonomic range of host plant species. Herbivore species that feed on mustard plants and their relatives in the Brassicales have evolved highly efficient detoxification mechanisms that actually prevent toxic mustard oils from forming in the bodies of the animals. However, these mechanisms likely were not present during the initial stages of specialization on mustard plants ~100 million years ago. The herbivorous fly Scaptomyza nigrita (Drosophilidae) is a specialist on a single mustard species, bittercress (Cardamine cordifolia; Brassicaceae) and is in a fly lineage that evolved to feed on mustards only in the past 10-20 million years. In contrast to many mustard specialists, S. nigrita does not prevent formation of toxic breakdown products (mustard oils) arising from glucosinolates (GLS), the primary defensive compounds in mustard plants. Therefore, it is an appealing model for dissecting the early stages of host specialization. Because mustard oils actually form in the bodies of S. nigrita, we hypothesized that in lieu of a specialized detoxification mechanism, S. nigrita may mitigate exposure to high GLS levels within plant tissues using behavioral avoidance. Here, we report that jasmonic acid (JA) treatment increased GLS biosynthesis in bittercress, repelled adult female flies, and reduced larval growth. S. nigrita larval damage also induced foliar GLS, especially in apical leaves, which correspondingly displayed the least S. nigrita damage in controlled feeding trials and field surveys. Paradoxically, flies preferred to feed and oviposit on GLS-producing Arabidopsis thaliana despite larvae performing worse in these plants versus non-GLS-producing mutants. GLS may be feeding cues for S. nigrita despite their deterrent and defensive properties, which underscores the diverse relationship a mustard specialist has with its host when lacking a specialized means of mustard oil detoxification.

KW - Drosophila

KW - Glucosinolate

KW - Inducible defense

KW - Jasmonic acid

KW - Oviposition

KW - Preference-performance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84963800015&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84963800015&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/ece3.2082

DO - 10.1002/ece3.2082

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84963800015

JO - Ecology and Evolution

JF - Ecology and Evolution

SN - 2045-7758

ER -