Chloroplast sequence variation and the efficacy of peptide nucleic acids for blocking host amplification in plant microbiome studies

Connor R. Fitzpatrick, Patricia Lu-Irving, Julia Copeland, David S. Guttman, Pauline W. Wang, David A Baltrus, Katrina M Dlugosch, Marc T.J. Johnson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: The ability to efficiently characterize microbial communities from host individuals can be limited by co-amplification of host organellar sequences (mitochondrial and/or plastid), which share a common ancestor and thus sequence similarity with extant bacterial lineages. One promising approach is the use of sequence-specific peptide nucleic acid (PNA) clamps, which bind to, and block amplification of, host-derived DNA. Universal PNA clamps have been proposed to block host plant-derived mitochondrial (mPNA) and plastid (pPNA) sequences at the V4 16S rRNA locus, but their efficacy across a wide range of host plant species has not been experimentally tested. Results: Using the universal PNA clamps, we amplified and sequenced root microbial communities from replicate individuals of 32 plant species with a most recent common ancestor inferred at 140 MYA. We found the average rate of host plastid contamination across plant species was 23%, however, particular lineages exhibited much higher rates (62-94%), with the highest levels of contamination occurring in the Asteraceae. We investigated chloroplast sequence variation at the V4 locus across 500 land plant species (Embryophyta) and found six lineages with mismatches between plastid and the universal pPNA sequence, including all species within the Asteraceae. Using a modified pPNA for the Asteraceae sequence, we found (1) host contamination in Asteraceae species was reduced from 65 to 23%; and (2) host contamination in non-Asteraceae species was increased from 12 to 69%. These results demonstrate that even single nucleotide mismatches can lead to drastic reductions in pPNA efficacy in blocking host amplification. Importantly, we found that pPNA type (universal or modified) had no effect on the detection of individual bacterial taxa, or estimates of within and between sample bacterial diversity, suggesting that our modification did not introduce bias against particular bacterial lineages. Conclusions: When high similarity exists between host organellar DNA and PCR target sequences, PNA clamps are an important molecular tool to reduce host contamination during amplification. Here, we provide a validated framework to modify universal PNA clamps to accommodate host variation in organellar sequences.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number144
JournalMicrobiome
Volume6
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 18 2018

Fingerprint

Peptide Nucleic Acids
Microbiota
Chloroplasts
Asteraceae
Plastids
Embryophyta
DNA
Nucleotides
Polymerase Chain Reaction

Keywords

  • 16S amplicon sequencing
  • Asteraceae
  • Host contamination
  • Plastid variation
  • PNA clamp

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Microbiology
  • Microbiology (medical)

Cite this

Chloroplast sequence variation and the efficacy of peptide nucleic acids for blocking host amplification in plant microbiome studies. / Fitzpatrick, Connor R.; Lu-Irving, Patricia; Copeland, Julia; Guttman, David S.; Wang, Pauline W.; Baltrus, David A; Dlugosch, Katrina M; Johnson, Marc T.J.

In: Microbiome, Vol. 6, No. 1, 144, 18.08.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fitzpatrick, Connor R. ; Lu-Irving, Patricia ; Copeland, Julia ; Guttman, David S. ; Wang, Pauline W. ; Baltrus, David A ; Dlugosch, Katrina M ; Johnson, Marc T.J. / Chloroplast sequence variation and the efficacy of peptide nucleic acids for blocking host amplification in plant microbiome studies. In: Microbiome. 2018 ; Vol. 6, No. 1.
@article{54c250bfcadf4a6cb810767caf6b64fd,
title = "Chloroplast sequence variation and the efficacy of peptide nucleic acids for blocking host amplification in plant microbiome studies",
abstract = "Background: The ability to efficiently characterize microbial communities from host individuals can be limited by co-amplification of host organellar sequences (mitochondrial and/or plastid), which share a common ancestor and thus sequence similarity with extant bacterial lineages. One promising approach is the use of sequence-specific peptide nucleic acid (PNA) clamps, which bind to, and block amplification of, host-derived DNA. Universal PNA clamps have been proposed to block host plant-derived mitochondrial (mPNA) and plastid (pPNA) sequences at the V4 16S rRNA locus, but their efficacy across a wide range of host plant species has not been experimentally tested. Results: Using the universal PNA clamps, we amplified and sequenced root microbial communities from replicate individuals of 32 plant species with a most recent common ancestor inferred at 140 MYA. We found the average rate of host plastid contamination across plant species was 23{\%}, however, particular lineages exhibited much higher rates (62-94{\%}), with the highest levels of contamination occurring in the Asteraceae. We investigated chloroplast sequence variation at the V4 locus across 500 land plant species (Embryophyta) and found six lineages with mismatches between plastid and the universal pPNA sequence, including all species within the Asteraceae. Using a modified pPNA for the Asteraceae sequence, we found (1) host contamination in Asteraceae species was reduced from 65 to 23{\%}; and (2) host contamination in non-Asteraceae species was increased from 12 to 69{\%}. These results demonstrate that even single nucleotide mismatches can lead to drastic reductions in pPNA efficacy in blocking host amplification. Importantly, we found that pPNA type (universal or modified) had no effect on the detection of individual bacterial taxa, or estimates of within and between sample bacterial diversity, suggesting that our modification did not introduce bias against particular bacterial lineages. Conclusions: When high similarity exists between host organellar DNA and PCR target sequences, PNA clamps are an important molecular tool to reduce host contamination during amplification. Here, we provide a validated framework to modify universal PNA clamps to accommodate host variation in organellar sequences.",
keywords = "16S amplicon sequencing, Asteraceae, Host contamination, Plastid variation, PNA clamp",
author = "Fitzpatrick, {Connor R.} and Patricia Lu-Irving and Julia Copeland and Guttman, {David S.} and Wang, {Pauline W.} and Baltrus, {David A} and Dlugosch, {Katrina M} and Johnson, {Marc T.J.}",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "18",
doi = "10.1186/s40168-018-0534-0",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "6",
journal = "Microbiome",
issn = "2049-2618",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Chloroplast sequence variation and the efficacy of peptide nucleic acids for blocking host amplification in plant microbiome studies

AU - Fitzpatrick, Connor R.

AU - Lu-Irving, Patricia

AU - Copeland, Julia

AU - Guttman, David S.

AU - Wang, Pauline W.

AU - Baltrus, David A

AU - Dlugosch, Katrina M

AU - Johnson, Marc T.J.

PY - 2018/8/18

Y1 - 2018/8/18

N2 - Background: The ability to efficiently characterize microbial communities from host individuals can be limited by co-amplification of host organellar sequences (mitochondrial and/or plastid), which share a common ancestor and thus sequence similarity with extant bacterial lineages. One promising approach is the use of sequence-specific peptide nucleic acid (PNA) clamps, which bind to, and block amplification of, host-derived DNA. Universal PNA clamps have been proposed to block host plant-derived mitochondrial (mPNA) and plastid (pPNA) sequences at the V4 16S rRNA locus, but their efficacy across a wide range of host plant species has not been experimentally tested. Results: Using the universal PNA clamps, we amplified and sequenced root microbial communities from replicate individuals of 32 plant species with a most recent common ancestor inferred at 140 MYA. We found the average rate of host plastid contamination across plant species was 23%, however, particular lineages exhibited much higher rates (62-94%), with the highest levels of contamination occurring in the Asteraceae. We investigated chloroplast sequence variation at the V4 locus across 500 land plant species (Embryophyta) and found six lineages with mismatches between plastid and the universal pPNA sequence, including all species within the Asteraceae. Using a modified pPNA for the Asteraceae sequence, we found (1) host contamination in Asteraceae species was reduced from 65 to 23%; and (2) host contamination in non-Asteraceae species was increased from 12 to 69%. These results demonstrate that even single nucleotide mismatches can lead to drastic reductions in pPNA efficacy in blocking host amplification. Importantly, we found that pPNA type (universal or modified) had no effect on the detection of individual bacterial taxa, or estimates of within and between sample bacterial diversity, suggesting that our modification did not introduce bias against particular bacterial lineages. Conclusions: When high similarity exists between host organellar DNA and PCR target sequences, PNA clamps are an important molecular tool to reduce host contamination during amplification. Here, we provide a validated framework to modify universal PNA clamps to accommodate host variation in organellar sequences.

AB - Background: The ability to efficiently characterize microbial communities from host individuals can be limited by co-amplification of host organellar sequences (mitochondrial and/or plastid), which share a common ancestor and thus sequence similarity with extant bacterial lineages. One promising approach is the use of sequence-specific peptide nucleic acid (PNA) clamps, which bind to, and block amplification of, host-derived DNA. Universal PNA clamps have been proposed to block host plant-derived mitochondrial (mPNA) and plastid (pPNA) sequences at the V4 16S rRNA locus, but their efficacy across a wide range of host plant species has not been experimentally tested. Results: Using the universal PNA clamps, we amplified and sequenced root microbial communities from replicate individuals of 32 plant species with a most recent common ancestor inferred at 140 MYA. We found the average rate of host plastid contamination across plant species was 23%, however, particular lineages exhibited much higher rates (62-94%), with the highest levels of contamination occurring in the Asteraceae. We investigated chloroplast sequence variation at the V4 locus across 500 land plant species (Embryophyta) and found six lineages with mismatches between plastid and the universal pPNA sequence, including all species within the Asteraceae. Using a modified pPNA for the Asteraceae sequence, we found (1) host contamination in Asteraceae species was reduced from 65 to 23%; and (2) host contamination in non-Asteraceae species was increased from 12 to 69%. These results demonstrate that even single nucleotide mismatches can lead to drastic reductions in pPNA efficacy in blocking host amplification. Importantly, we found that pPNA type (universal or modified) had no effect on the detection of individual bacterial taxa, or estimates of within and between sample bacterial diversity, suggesting that our modification did not introduce bias against particular bacterial lineages. Conclusions: When high similarity exists between host organellar DNA and PCR target sequences, PNA clamps are an important molecular tool to reduce host contamination during amplification. Here, we provide a validated framework to modify universal PNA clamps to accommodate host variation in organellar sequences.

KW - 16S amplicon sequencing

KW - Asteraceae

KW - Host contamination

KW - Plastid variation

KW - PNA clamp

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85051731027&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85051731027&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/s40168-018-0534-0

DO - 10.1186/s40168-018-0534-0

M3 - Article

C2 - 30121081

AN - SCOPUS:85051731027

VL - 6

JO - Microbiome

JF - Microbiome

SN - 2049-2618

IS - 1

M1 - 144

ER -