Competition suppresses shrubs during early, but not late, stages of arid grassland–shrubland state transition

Nathan A. Pierce, Steve Archer, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Transitions from grass to woody plant dominance, widely reported in arid systems, are typically attributed to changes in disturbance regimes in combination with abiotic feedbacks, whereas biotic mechanisms such as competition and facilitation are often overlooked. Yet, research in semi-arid and subhumid savannas indicates that biotic interactions are important drivers in systems at risk for state transition. We sought to bridge this divide by experimentally manipulating grass-on-shrub and shrub-on-shrub interactions in early and late stages of grassland–shrubland state transition, respectively, and to assess the extent to which these interactions might influence arid land state transition dynamics. Target Prosopis glandulosa shrubs had surrounding grasses or conspecific neighbours left intact or killed with foliar herbicide, and metrics of plant performance were monitored over multiple years for shrubs with and without grass or shrub neighbours. Productivity of small shrubs was enhanced by grass removal in years with above-average precipitation, a result not evident in larger shrubs or during dry years. Proxy evidence based on nearest neighbour metrics suggested shrub–shrub competition was at play, but our experimental manipulations revealed no such influence. Competition from grasses appears to attenuate the rate at which shrubs achieve the size necessary to modify the physical environment in self-reinforcing ways, but only during the early stages of shrub encroachment. Our results further suggest that at late stages of grassland-to-shrubland state transitions, shrub–shrub competition will not slow the rate of shrub expansion, and suggest that maximum shrub cover is regulated by something other than density-dependent mechanisms. We conclude that grass effects on shrubs should be included in assessments of desert grassland state transition probabilities and rates, and that desertification models in arid ecosystems that traditionally focus on disturbance and abiotic feedbacks should be broadened to incorporate spatial and temporal variations in competitive effects. A plain language summary is available for this article.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalFunctional Ecology
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

shrub
shrubs
grass
grasses
grasslands
grassland
Prosopis glandulosa
disturbance
desertification
facilitation
shrubland
woody plant
woody plants
arid lands
shrublands
savanna
savannas
temporal variation
spatial variation
herbicide

Keywords

  • Chihuahuan Desert
  • competition
  • grassland
  • shrubland
  • state transition
  • woody plant encroachment

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Competition suppresses shrubs during early, but not late, stages of arid grassland–shrubland state transition. / Pierce, Nathan A.; Archer, Steve; Bestelmeyer, Brandon T.

In: Functional Ecology, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{5fd0a275c3514c18a438e40ab5d6b420,
title = "Competition suppresses shrubs during early, but not late, stages of arid grassland–shrubland state transition",
abstract = "Transitions from grass to woody plant dominance, widely reported in arid systems, are typically attributed to changes in disturbance regimes in combination with abiotic feedbacks, whereas biotic mechanisms such as competition and facilitation are often overlooked. Yet, research in semi-arid and subhumid savannas indicates that biotic interactions are important drivers in systems at risk for state transition. We sought to bridge this divide by experimentally manipulating grass-on-shrub and shrub-on-shrub interactions in early and late stages of grassland–shrubland state transition, respectively, and to assess the extent to which these interactions might influence arid land state transition dynamics. Target Prosopis glandulosa shrubs had surrounding grasses or conspecific neighbours left intact or killed with foliar herbicide, and metrics of plant performance were monitored over multiple years for shrubs with and without grass or shrub neighbours. Productivity of small shrubs was enhanced by grass removal in years with above-average precipitation, a result not evident in larger shrubs or during dry years. Proxy evidence based on nearest neighbour metrics suggested shrub–shrub competition was at play, but our experimental manipulations revealed no such influence. Competition from grasses appears to attenuate the rate at which shrubs achieve the size necessary to modify the physical environment in self-reinforcing ways, but only during the early stages of shrub encroachment. Our results further suggest that at late stages of grassland-to-shrubland state transitions, shrub–shrub competition will not slow the rate of shrub expansion, and suggest that maximum shrub cover is regulated by something other than density-dependent mechanisms. We conclude that grass effects on shrubs should be included in assessments of desert grassland state transition probabilities and rates, and that desertification models in arid ecosystems that traditionally focus on disturbance and abiotic feedbacks should be broadened to incorporate spatial and temporal variations in competitive effects. A plain language summary is available for this article.",
keywords = "Chihuahuan Desert, competition, grassland, shrubland, state transition, woody plant encroachment",
author = "Pierce, {Nathan A.} and Steve Archer and Bestelmeyer, {Brandon T.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/1365-2435.13336",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Functional Ecology",
issn = "0269-8463",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Competition suppresses shrubs during early, but not late, stages of arid grassland–shrubland state transition

AU - Pierce, Nathan A.

AU - Archer, Steve

AU - Bestelmeyer, Brandon T.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Transitions from grass to woody plant dominance, widely reported in arid systems, are typically attributed to changes in disturbance regimes in combination with abiotic feedbacks, whereas biotic mechanisms such as competition and facilitation are often overlooked. Yet, research in semi-arid and subhumid savannas indicates that biotic interactions are important drivers in systems at risk for state transition. We sought to bridge this divide by experimentally manipulating grass-on-shrub and shrub-on-shrub interactions in early and late stages of grassland–shrubland state transition, respectively, and to assess the extent to which these interactions might influence arid land state transition dynamics. Target Prosopis glandulosa shrubs had surrounding grasses or conspecific neighbours left intact or killed with foliar herbicide, and metrics of plant performance were monitored over multiple years for shrubs with and without grass or shrub neighbours. Productivity of small shrubs was enhanced by grass removal in years with above-average precipitation, a result not evident in larger shrubs or during dry years. Proxy evidence based on nearest neighbour metrics suggested shrub–shrub competition was at play, but our experimental manipulations revealed no such influence. Competition from grasses appears to attenuate the rate at which shrubs achieve the size necessary to modify the physical environment in self-reinforcing ways, but only during the early stages of shrub encroachment. Our results further suggest that at late stages of grassland-to-shrubland state transitions, shrub–shrub competition will not slow the rate of shrub expansion, and suggest that maximum shrub cover is regulated by something other than density-dependent mechanisms. We conclude that grass effects on shrubs should be included in assessments of desert grassland state transition probabilities and rates, and that desertification models in arid ecosystems that traditionally focus on disturbance and abiotic feedbacks should be broadened to incorporate spatial and temporal variations in competitive effects. A plain language summary is available for this article.

AB - Transitions from grass to woody plant dominance, widely reported in arid systems, are typically attributed to changes in disturbance regimes in combination with abiotic feedbacks, whereas biotic mechanisms such as competition and facilitation are often overlooked. Yet, research in semi-arid and subhumid savannas indicates that biotic interactions are important drivers in systems at risk for state transition. We sought to bridge this divide by experimentally manipulating grass-on-shrub and shrub-on-shrub interactions in early and late stages of grassland–shrubland state transition, respectively, and to assess the extent to which these interactions might influence arid land state transition dynamics. Target Prosopis glandulosa shrubs had surrounding grasses or conspecific neighbours left intact or killed with foliar herbicide, and metrics of plant performance were monitored over multiple years for shrubs with and without grass or shrub neighbours. Productivity of small shrubs was enhanced by grass removal in years with above-average precipitation, a result not evident in larger shrubs or during dry years. Proxy evidence based on nearest neighbour metrics suggested shrub–shrub competition was at play, but our experimental manipulations revealed no such influence. Competition from grasses appears to attenuate the rate at which shrubs achieve the size necessary to modify the physical environment in self-reinforcing ways, but only during the early stages of shrub encroachment. Our results further suggest that at late stages of grassland-to-shrubland state transitions, shrub–shrub competition will not slow the rate of shrub expansion, and suggest that maximum shrub cover is regulated by something other than density-dependent mechanisms. We conclude that grass effects on shrubs should be included in assessments of desert grassland state transition probabilities and rates, and that desertification models in arid ecosystems that traditionally focus on disturbance and abiotic feedbacks should be broadened to incorporate spatial and temporal variations in competitive effects. A plain language summary is available for this article.

KW - Chihuahuan Desert

KW - competition

KW - grassland

KW - shrubland

KW - state transition

KW - woody plant encroachment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85065026905&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85065026905&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/1365-2435.13336

DO - 10.1111/1365-2435.13336

M3 - Article

JO - Functional Ecology

JF - Functional Ecology

SN - 0269-8463

ER -