Constraints on Jupiters stratospheric HCl abundance and chlorine cycle from Herschel/HIFI

N. A. Teanby, Adam Showman, L. N. Fletcher, P. G.J. Irwin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Detection of HCl on Jupiter would provide insight into the chlorine cycle and external elemental fluxes on giant planets, yet so far has not been possible. Here we present the most sensitive search for Jupiters stratospheric HCl to date using observations of the 625.907 and 1876.221 GHz spectral lines with Herschels HIFI instrument. HCl was not detected, but we determined the most stringent upper limits so far, improving on previous studies by two orders of magnitude. If HCl is assumed to be uniformly mixed, with a constant volume mixing ratio above the 1 mbar pressure level and has zero abundance below, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.061 ppb; in contrast, if we assume uniform mixing above the 1 mbar level and allow a non-zero but downward-decreasing abundance from 1 mbar to the troposphere based on eddy diffusion, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.027 ppb. This is below the abundance expected for a solar composition cometary source and implies that upper stratospheric HCl loss processes are required for consistency with observations of the external oxygen flux. We investigated loss via aerosol scavenging using a simple diffusion model and conclude that it could be a very effective mechanism for HCl removal. Transient scavenging by stratospheric NH3 from impacts is another potentially important loss mechanism. This suggests that it is extremely unlikely that HCl is present in sufficient quantities to be detectable in the near future. An alternative explanation for our very low upper limits could be that HCl is sub-solar in comets or that cometary chlorine exists in inactive reservoirs that are not readily converted to HCl during the impact process.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)250-261
Number of pages12
JournalPlanetary and Space Science
Volume103
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 15 2014

Fingerprint

Jupiter (planet)
Jupiter
chlorine
cycles
scavenging
mixing ratio
comet
turbulent diffusion
troposphere
eddy
planet
mixing ratios
comets
aerosol
line spectra
planets
aerosols
oxygen
loss

Keywords

  • Atmosphere
  • Composition
  • Herschel
  • Jupiter
  • Sub-millimetre

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Constraints on Jupiters stratospheric HCl abundance and chlorine cycle from Herschel/HIFI. / Teanby, N. A.; Showman, Adam; Fletcher, L. N.; Irwin, P. G.J.

In: Planetary and Space Science, Vol. 103, 15.11.2014, p. 250-261.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Teanby, N. A. ; Showman, Adam ; Fletcher, L. N. ; Irwin, P. G.J. / Constraints on Jupiters stratospheric HCl abundance and chlorine cycle from Herschel/HIFI. In: Planetary and Space Science. 2014 ; Vol. 103. pp. 250-261.
@article{03392d9f318c4d4bad388c2b3c25969a,
title = "Constraints on Jupiters stratospheric HCl abundance and chlorine cycle from Herschel/HIFI",
abstract = "Detection of HCl on Jupiter would provide insight into the chlorine cycle and external elemental fluxes on giant planets, yet so far has not been possible. Here we present the most sensitive search for Jupiters stratospheric HCl to date using observations of the 625.907 and 1876.221 GHz spectral lines with Herschels HIFI instrument. HCl was not detected, but we determined the most stringent upper limits so far, improving on previous studies by two orders of magnitude. If HCl is assumed to be uniformly mixed, with a constant volume mixing ratio above the 1 mbar pressure level and has zero abundance below, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.061 ppb; in contrast, if we assume uniform mixing above the 1 mbar level and allow a non-zero but downward-decreasing abundance from 1 mbar to the troposphere based on eddy diffusion, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.027 ppb. This is below the abundance expected for a solar composition cometary source and implies that upper stratospheric HCl loss processes are required for consistency with observations of the external oxygen flux. We investigated loss via aerosol scavenging using a simple diffusion model and conclude that it could be a very effective mechanism for HCl removal. Transient scavenging by stratospheric NH3 from impacts is another potentially important loss mechanism. This suggests that it is extremely unlikely that HCl is present in sufficient quantities to be detectable in the near future. An alternative explanation for our very low upper limits could be that HCl is sub-solar in comets or that cometary chlorine exists in inactive reservoirs that are not readily converted to HCl during the impact process.",
keywords = "Atmosphere, Composition, Herschel, Jupiter, Sub-millimetre",
author = "Teanby, {N. A.} and Adam Showman and Fletcher, {L. N.} and Irwin, {P. G.J.}",
year = "2014",
month = "11",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.pss.2014.07.015",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "103",
pages = "250--261",
journal = "Planetary and Space Science",
issn = "0032-0633",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Constraints on Jupiters stratospheric HCl abundance and chlorine cycle from Herschel/HIFI

AU - Teanby, N. A.

AU - Showman, Adam

AU - Fletcher, L. N.

AU - Irwin, P. G.J.

PY - 2014/11/15

Y1 - 2014/11/15

N2 - Detection of HCl on Jupiter would provide insight into the chlorine cycle and external elemental fluxes on giant planets, yet so far has not been possible. Here we present the most sensitive search for Jupiters stratospheric HCl to date using observations of the 625.907 and 1876.221 GHz spectral lines with Herschels HIFI instrument. HCl was not detected, but we determined the most stringent upper limits so far, improving on previous studies by two orders of magnitude. If HCl is assumed to be uniformly mixed, with a constant volume mixing ratio above the 1 mbar pressure level and has zero abundance below, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.061 ppb; in contrast, if we assume uniform mixing above the 1 mbar level and allow a non-zero but downward-decreasing abundance from 1 mbar to the troposphere based on eddy diffusion, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.027 ppb. This is below the abundance expected for a solar composition cometary source and implies that upper stratospheric HCl loss processes are required for consistency with observations of the external oxygen flux. We investigated loss via aerosol scavenging using a simple diffusion model and conclude that it could be a very effective mechanism for HCl removal. Transient scavenging by stratospheric NH3 from impacts is another potentially important loss mechanism. This suggests that it is extremely unlikely that HCl is present in sufficient quantities to be detectable in the near future. An alternative explanation for our very low upper limits could be that HCl is sub-solar in comets or that cometary chlorine exists in inactive reservoirs that are not readily converted to HCl during the impact process.

AB - Detection of HCl on Jupiter would provide insight into the chlorine cycle and external elemental fluxes on giant planets, yet so far has not been possible. Here we present the most sensitive search for Jupiters stratospheric HCl to date using observations of the 625.907 and 1876.221 GHz spectral lines with Herschels HIFI instrument. HCl was not detected, but we determined the most stringent upper limits so far, improving on previous studies by two orders of magnitude. If HCl is assumed to be uniformly mixed, with a constant volume mixing ratio above the 1 mbar pressure level and has zero abundance below, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.061 ppb; in contrast, if we assume uniform mixing above the 1 mbar level and allow a non-zero but downward-decreasing abundance from 1 mbar to the troposphere based on eddy diffusion, we obtain a 3-σ upper limit of 0.027 ppb. This is below the abundance expected for a solar composition cometary source and implies that upper stratospheric HCl loss processes are required for consistency with observations of the external oxygen flux. We investigated loss via aerosol scavenging using a simple diffusion model and conclude that it could be a very effective mechanism for HCl removal. Transient scavenging by stratospheric NH3 from impacts is another potentially important loss mechanism. This suggests that it is extremely unlikely that HCl is present in sufficient quantities to be detectable in the near future. An alternative explanation for our very low upper limits could be that HCl is sub-solar in comets or that cometary chlorine exists in inactive reservoirs that are not readily converted to HCl during the impact process.

KW - Atmosphere

KW - Composition

KW - Herschel

KW - Jupiter

KW - Sub-millimetre

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85028091987&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85028091987&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.pss.2014.07.015

DO - 10.1016/j.pss.2014.07.015

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85028091987

VL - 103

SP - 250

EP - 261

JO - Planetary and Space Science

JF - Planetary and Space Science

SN - 0032-0633

ER -