Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems

Joanna I. House, Steve Archer, David D Breshears, Robert J. Scholes, M. B. Coughenour, M. B. Dodd, J. Gignoux, D. O. Hall, N. P. Hanan, R. Joffre, X. Le Roux, J. A. Ludwig, J. C. Menaut, R. Montes, W. J. Parton, J. J. San Jose, J. C. Scanlan, J. M O Scurlock, G. Simioni, B. Thorrold

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

233 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Aims: To identify approaches to improve our understanding of, and predictive capability for, mixed tree-grass systems. Elucidation of the interactions, dynamics and determinants, and identification of robust generalizations that can be broadly applied to tree-grass systems would benefit ecological theory, modelling and land management. Methods: A series of workshops brought together scientific expertise to review theory, data availability, modelling approaches and key questions. Location: Ecosystems characterized by mixtures of herbaceous and woody plant life-forms, often termed 'savannas', range from open grasslands with few woody plants, to woodlands or forests with a grass layer. These ecosystems represent a substantial portion of the terrestrial biosphere, an important wildlife habitat, and a major resource for provision of livestock, fuel wood and other products. Results: Although many concepts and principles developed for grassland and forest systems are relevant to these dual life-form communities, the novel, complex, nonlinear behaviour of mixed tree-grass systems cannot be accounted for by simply studying or modelling woody and herbaceous components independently. A more robust understanding requires addressing three fundamental conundrums: (1) The 'treeness' conundrum. What controls the relative abundance of woody and herbaceous plants for a given set of conditions at given site? (2) The coexistence conundrum. How do the life-forms interact with each other? Is a given woody-herbaceous ratio dynamically stable and persistent under a particular set of conditions? (3) The net primary productivity (NPP) conundrum. How does NPP of the woody vegetation, the herbaceous vegetation, and the total ecosystem (woody + herbaceous) change with changes in the tree-grass ratio? Tests of the theory and conceptual models of determinants of mixed woody-herbaceous systems have been largely site- or region-specific and have seldom been broadly or quantitatively evaluated. Cross-site syntheses based on data and modelling are required to address the conundrums and identify emerging patterns, yet, there are very few data sets for which either biomass or NPP have been quantified for both the woody and the herbaceous components of tree-grass systems. Furthermore, there are few cross-site comparisons spanning the diverse array of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Hence, initial synthesis studies should focus on compiling and standardizing a global data base which could be (1) explored to ascertain if robust generalizations and consistent patterns exist; and (2) used to evaluate the performance of savanna simulation models over a range of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Savanna structure and productivity are the result of complex and dynamic interactions between climate, soils and disturbances, notably fire and herbivory. Such factors are difficult to isolate or experimentally manipulate in order to evaluate their impacts at spatial and temporal scales appropriate for assessing ecosystem dynamics. These factors can, however, be evaluated with simulation models. Existing savanna models vary markedly with respect to their conceptual approach, their data requirements and the extent to which they incorporate mechanistic processes. Model intercomparisons can elucidate those approaches most suitable for various research questions and management applications. Conclusion: Theoretical and conceptual advances could be achieved by considering a broad continuum of grass-shrub-tree combinations using data meta-analysis techniques and modelling.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1763-1777
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Biogeography
Volume30
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 2003

Fingerprint

herbaceous plants
woody plants
herb
grass
grasses
savanna
productivity
woody plant
savannas
primary productivity
modeling
simulation model
ecosystems
ecosystem
determinants
grassland
simulation models
biosphere
grasslands
ecological theory

Keywords

  • Coexistence
  • Competition
  • Facilitation
  • Grassland
  • Modelling
  • Primary production
  • Rangeland
  • Savanna
  • Shrubland
  • Tree-grass ratios

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology
  • Geography, Planning and Development

Cite this

House, J. I., Archer, S., Breshears, D. D., Scholes, R. J., Coughenour, M. B., Dodd, M. B., ... Thorrold, B. (2003). Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems. Journal of Biogeography, 30(11), 1763-1777. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2699.2003.00873.x

Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems. / House, Joanna I.; Archer, Steve; Breshears, David D; Scholes, Robert J.; Coughenour, M. B.; Dodd, M. B.; Gignoux, J.; Hall, D. O.; Hanan, N. P.; Joffre, R.; Le Roux, X.; Ludwig, J. A.; Menaut, J. C.; Montes, R.; Parton, W. J.; San Jose, J. J.; Scanlan, J. C.; Scurlock, J. M O; Simioni, G.; Thorrold, B.

In: Journal of Biogeography, Vol. 30, No. 11, 11.2003, p. 1763-1777.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

House, JI, Archer, S, Breshears, DD, Scholes, RJ, Coughenour, MB, Dodd, MB, Gignoux, J, Hall, DO, Hanan, NP, Joffre, R, Le Roux, X, Ludwig, JA, Menaut, JC, Montes, R, Parton, WJ, San Jose, JJ, Scanlan, JC, Scurlock, JMO, Simioni, G & Thorrold, B 2003, 'Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems', Journal of Biogeography, vol. 30, no. 11, pp. 1763-1777. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2699.2003.00873.x
House, Joanna I. ; Archer, Steve ; Breshears, David D ; Scholes, Robert J. ; Coughenour, M. B. ; Dodd, M. B. ; Gignoux, J. ; Hall, D. O. ; Hanan, N. P. ; Joffre, R. ; Le Roux, X. ; Ludwig, J. A. ; Menaut, J. C. ; Montes, R. ; Parton, W. J. ; San Jose, J. J. ; Scanlan, J. C. ; Scurlock, J. M O ; Simioni, G. ; Thorrold, B. / Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems. In: Journal of Biogeography. 2003 ; Vol. 30, No. 11. pp. 1763-1777.
@article{4fcda3acf5a844938dbda5f841359683,
title = "Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems",
abstract = "Aims: To identify approaches to improve our understanding of, and predictive capability for, mixed tree-grass systems. Elucidation of the interactions, dynamics and determinants, and identification of robust generalizations that can be broadly applied to tree-grass systems would benefit ecological theory, modelling and land management. Methods: A series of workshops brought together scientific expertise to review theory, data availability, modelling approaches and key questions. Location: Ecosystems characterized by mixtures of herbaceous and woody plant life-forms, often termed 'savannas', range from open grasslands with few woody plants, to woodlands or forests with a grass layer. These ecosystems represent a substantial portion of the terrestrial biosphere, an important wildlife habitat, and a major resource for provision of livestock, fuel wood and other products. Results: Although many concepts and principles developed for grassland and forest systems are relevant to these dual life-form communities, the novel, complex, nonlinear behaviour of mixed tree-grass systems cannot be accounted for by simply studying or modelling woody and herbaceous components independently. A more robust understanding requires addressing three fundamental conundrums: (1) The 'treeness' conundrum. What controls the relative abundance of woody and herbaceous plants for a given set of conditions at given site? (2) The coexistence conundrum. How do the life-forms interact with each other? Is a given woody-herbaceous ratio dynamically stable and persistent under a particular set of conditions? (3) The net primary productivity (NPP) conundrum. How does NPP of the woody vegetation, the herbaceous vegetation, and the total ecosystem (woody + herbaceous) change with changes in the tree-grass ratio? Tests of the theory and conceptual models of determinants of mixed woody-herbaceous systems have been largely site- or region-specific and have seldom been broadly or quantitatively evaluated. Cross-site syntheses based on data and modelling are required to address the conundrums and identify emerging patterns, yet, there are very few data sets for which either biomass or NPP have been quantified for both the woody and the herbaceous components of tree-grass systems. Furthermore, there are few cross-site comparisons spanning the diverse array of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Hence, initial synthesis studies should focus on compiling and standardizing a global data base which could be (1) explored to ascertain if robust generalizations and consistent patterns exist; and (2) used to evaluate the performance of savanna simulation models over a range of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Savanna structure and productivity are the result of complex and dynamic interactions between climate, soils and disturbances, notably fire and herbivory. Such factors are difficult to isolate or experimentally manipulate in order to evaluate their impacts at spatial and temporal scales appropriate for assessing ecosystem dynamics. These factors can, however, be evaluated with simulation models. Existing savanna models vary markedly with respect to their conceptual approach, their data requirements and the extent to which they incorporate mechanistic processes. Model intercomparisons can elucidate those approaches most suitable for various research questions and management applications. Conclusion: Theoretical and conceptual advances could be achieved by considering a broad continuum of grass-shrub-tree combinations using data meta-analysis techniques and modelling.",
keywords = "Coexistence, Competition, Facilitation, Grassland, Modelling, Primary production, Rangeland, Savanna, Shrubland, Tree-grass ratios",
author = "House, {Joanna I.} and Steve Archer and Breshears, {David D} and Scholes, {Robert J.} and Coughenour, {M. B.} and Dodd, {M. B.} and J. Gignoux and Hall, {D. O.} and Hanan, {N. P.} and R. Joffre and {Le Roux}, X. and Ludwig, {J. A.} and Menaut, {J. C.} and R. Montes and Parton, {W. J.} and {San Jose}, {J. J.} and Scanlan, {J. C.} and Scurlock, {J. M O} and G. Simioni and B. Thorrold",
year = "2003",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1046/j.1365-2699.2003.00873.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "30",
pages = "1763--1777",
journal = "Journal of Biogeography",
issn = "0305-0270",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems

AU - House, Joanna I.

AU - Archer, Steve

AU - Breshears, David D

AU - Scholes, Robert J.

AU - Coughenour, M. B.

AU - Dodd, M. B.

AU - Gignoux, J.

AU - Hall, D. O.

AU - Hanan, N. P.

AU - Joffre, R.

AU - Le Roux, X.

AU - Ludwig, J. A.

AU - Menaut, J. C.

AU - Montes, R.

AU - Parton, W. J.

AU - San Jose, J. J.

AU - Scanlan, J. C.

AU - Scurlock, J. M O

AU - Simioni, G.

AU - Thorrold, B.

PY - 2003/11

Y1 - 2003/11

N2 - Aims: To identify approaches to improve our understanding of, and predictive capability for, mixed tree-grass systems. Elucidation of the interactions, dynamics and determinants, and identification of robust generalizations that can be broadly applied to tree-grass systems would benefit ecological theory, modelling and land management. Methods: A series of workshops brought together scientific expertise to review theory, data availability, modelling approaches and key questions. Location: Ecosystems characterized by mixtures of herbaceous and woody plant life-forms, often termed 'savannas', range from open grasslands with few woody plants, to woodlands or forests with a grass layer. These ecosystems represent a substantial portion of the terrestrial biosphere, an important wildlife habitat, and a major resource for provision of livestock, fuel wood and other products. Results: Although many concepts and principles developed for grassland and forest systems are relevant to these dual life-form communities, the novel, complex, nonlinear behaviour of mixed tree-grass systems cannot be accounted for by simply studying or modelling woody and herbaceous components independently. A more robust understanding requires addressing three fundamental conundrums: (1) The 'treeness' conundrum. What controls the relative abundance of woody and herbaceous plants for a given set of conditions at given site? (2) The coexistence conundrum. How do the life-forms interact with each other? Is a given woody-herbaceous ratio dynamically stable and persistent under a particular set of conditions? (3) The net primary productivity (NPP) conundrum. How does NPP of the woody vegetation, the herbaceous vegetation, and the total ecosystem (woody + herbaceous) change with changes in the tree-grass ratio? Tests of the theory and conceptual models of determinants of mixed woody-herbaceous systems have been largely site- or region-specific and have seldom been broadly or quantitatively evaluated. Cross-site syntheses based on data and modelling are required to address the conundrums and identify emerging patterns, yet, there are very few data sets for which either biomass or NPP have been quantified for both the woody and the herbaceous components of tree-grass systems. Furthermore, there are few cross-site comparisons spanning the diverse array of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Hence, initial synthesis studies should focus on compiling and standardizing a global data base which could be (1) explored to ascertain if robust generalizations and consistent patterns exist; and (2) used to evaluate the performance of savanna simulation models over a range of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Savanna structure and productivity are the result of complex and dynamic interactions between climate, soils and disturbances, notably fire and herbivory. Such factors are difficult to isolate or experimentally manipulate in order to evaluate their impacts at spatial and temporal scales appropriate for assessing ecosystem dynamics. These factors can, however, be evaluated with simulation models. Existing savanna models vary markedly with respect to their conceptual approach, their data requirements and the extent to which they incorporate mechanistic processes. Model intercomparisons can elucidate those approaches most suitable for various research questions and management applications. Conclusion: Theoretical and conceptual advances could be achieved by considering a broad continuum of grass-shrub-tree combinations using data meta-analysis techniques and modelling.

AB - Aims: To identify approaches to improve our understanding of, and predictive capability for, mixed tree-grass systems. Elucidation of the interactions, dynamics and determinants, and identification of robust generalizations that can be broadly applied to tree-grass systems would benefit ecological theory, modelling and land management. Methods: A series of workshops brought together scientific expertise to review theory, data availability, modelling approaches and key questions. Location: Ecosystems characterized by mixtures of herbaceous and woody plant life-forms, often termed 'savannas', range from open grasslands with few woody plants, to woodlands or forests with a grass layer. These ecosystems represent a substantial portion of the terrestrial biosphere, an important wildlife habitat, and a major resource for provision of livestock, fuel wood and other products. Results: Although many concepts and principles developed for grassland and forest systems are relevant to these dual life-form communities, the novel, complex, nonlinear behaviour of mixed tree-grass systems cannot be accounted for by simply studying or modelling woody and herbaceous components independently. A more robust understanding requires addressing three fundamental conundrums: (1) The 'treeness' conundrum. What controls the relative abundance of woody and herbaceous plants for a given set of conditions at given site? (2) The coexistence conundrum. How do the life-forms interact with each other? Is a given woody-herbaceous ratio dynamically stable and persistent under a particular set of conditions? (3) The net primary productivity (NPP) conundrum. How does NPP of the woody vegetation, the herbaceous vegetation, and the total ecosystem (woody + herbaceous) change with changes in the tree-grass ratio? Tests of the theory and conceptual models of determinants of mixed woody-herbaceous systems have been largely site- or region-specific and have seldom been broadly or quantitatively evaluated. Cross-site syntheses based on data and modelling are required to address the conundrums and identify emerging patterns, yet, there are very few data sets for which either biomass or NPP have been quantified for both the woody and the herbaceous components of tree-grass systems. Furthermore, there are few cross-site comparisons spanning the diverse array of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Hence, initial synthesis studies should focus on compiling and standardizing a global data base which could be (1) explored to ascertain if robust generalizations and consistent patterns exist; and (2) used to evaluate the performance of savanna simulation models over a range of woody-herbaceous mixtures. Savanna structure and productivity are the result of complex and dynamic interactions between climate, soils and disturbances, notably fire and herbivory. Such factors are difficult to isolate or experimentally manipulate in order to evaluate their impacts at spatial and temporal scales appropriate for assessing ecosystem dynamics. These factors can, however, be evaluated with simulation models. Existing savanna models vary markedly with respect to their conceptual approach, their data requirements and the extent to which they incorporate mechanistic processes. Model intercomparisons can elucidate those approaches most suitable for various research questions and management applications. Conclusion: Theoretical and conceptual advances could be achieved by considering a broad continuum of grass-shrub-tree combinations using data meta-analysis techniques and modelling.

KW - Coexistence

KW - Competition

KW - Facilitation

KW - Grassland

KW - Modelling

KW - Primary production

KW - Rangeland

KW - Savanna

KW - Shrubland

KW - Tree-grass ratios

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0242573321&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0242573321&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1046/j.1365-2699.2003.00873.x

DO - 10.1046/j.1365-2699.2003.00873.x

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0242573321

VL - 30

SP - 1763

EP - 1777

JO - Journal of Biogeography

JF - Journal of Biogeography

SN - 0305-0270

IS - 11

ER -