Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles

Andrea Maiorano, Pierre Martre, Senthold Asseng, Frank Ewert, Christoph Müller, Reimund P. Rötter, Alex C. Ruane, Mikhail A. Semenov, Daniel Wallach, Enli Wang, Phillip D. Alderman, Belay T. Kassie, Christian Biernath, Bruno Basso, Davide Cammarano, Andrew J. Challinor, Jordi Doltra, Benjamin Dumont, Ehsan Eyshi Rezaei, Sebastian GaylerKurt Christian Kersebaum, Bruce A. Kimball, Ann Kristin Koehler, Bing Liu, Garry J. O'Leary, Jørgen E. Olesen, Michael J Ottman, Eckart Priesack, Matthew Reynolds, Pierre Stratonovitch, Thilo Streck, Peter J. Thorburn, Katharina Waha, Gerard W. Wall, Jeffrey W. White, Zhigan Zhao, Yan Zhu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

43 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

To improve climate change impact estimates and to quantify their uncertainty, multi-model ensembles (MMEs) have been suggested. Model improvements can improve the accuracy of simulations and reduce the uncertainty of climate change impact assessments. Furthermore, they can reduce the number of models needed in a MME. Herein, 15 wheat growth models of a larger MME were improved through re-parameterization and/or incorporating or modifying heat stress effects on phenology, leaf growth and senescence, biomass growth, and grain number and size using detailed field experimental data from the USDA Hot Serial Cereal experiment (calibration data set). Simulation results from before and after model improvement were then evaluated with independent field experiments from a CIMMYT world-wide field trial network (evaluation data set). Model improvements decreased the variation (10th to 90th model ensemble percentile range) of grain yields simulated by the MME on average by 39% in the calibration data set and by 26% in the independent evaluation data set for crops grown in mean seasonal temperatures >24 °C. MME mean squared error in simulating grain yield decreased by 37%. A reduction in MME uncertainty range by 27% increased MME prediction skills by 47%. Results suggest that the mean level of variation observed in field experiments and used as a benchmark can be reached with half the number of models in the MME. Improving crop models is therefore important to increase the certainty of model-based impact assessments and allow more practical, i.e. smaller MMEs to be used effectively.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)5-20
Number of pages16
JournalField Crops Research
Volume202
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 15 2017

Fingerprint

crop models
uncertainty
crop
temperature
calibration
grain yield
climate change
model uncertainty
USDA
growth models
heat stress
phenology
senescence
field experimentation

Keywords

  • High temperature
  • Impact uncertainty
  • Model improvement
  • Multi-model ensemble
  • Wheat crop model

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agronomy and Crop Science
  • Soil Science

Cite this

Maiorano, A., Martre, P., Asseng, S., Ewert, F., Müller, C., Rötter, R. P., ... Zhu, Y. (2017). Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles. Field Crops Research, 202, 5-20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2016.05.001

Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles. / Maiorano, Andrea; Martre, Pierre; Asseng, Senthold; Ewert, Frank; Müller, Christoph; Rötter, Reimund P.; Ruane, Alex C.; Semenov, Mikhail A.; Wallach, Daniel; Wang, Enli; Alderman, Phillip D.; Kassie, Belay T.; Biernath, Christian; Basso, Bruno; Cammarano, Davide; Challinor, Andrew J.; Doltra, Jordi; Dumont, Benjamin; Rezaei, Ehsan Eyshi; Gayler, Sebastian; Kersebaum, Kurt Christian; Kimball, Bruce A.; Koehler, Ann Kristin; Liu, Bing; O'Leary, Garry J.; Olesen, Jørgen E.; Ottman, Michael J; Priesack, Eckart; Reynolds, Matthew; Stratonovitch, Pierre; Streck, Thilo; Thorburn, Peter J.; Waha, Katharina; Wall, Gerard W.; White, Jeffrey W.; Zhao, Zhigan; Zhu, Yan.

In: Field Crops Research, Vol. 202, 15.02.2017, p. 5-20.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Maiorano, A, Martre, P, Asseng, S, Ewert, F, Müller, C, Rötter, RP, Ruane, AC, Semenov, MA, Wallach, D, Wang, E, Alderman, PD, Kassie, BT, Biernath, C, Basso, B, Cammarano, D, Challinor, AJ, Doltra, J, Dumont, B, Rezaei, EE, Gayler, S, Kersebaum, KC, Kimball, BA, Koehler, AK, Liu, B, O'Leary, GJ, Olesen, JE, Ottman, MJ, Priesack, E, Reynolds, M, Stratonovitch, P, Streck, T, Thorburn, PJ, Waha, K, Wall, GW, White, JW, Zhao, Z & Zhu, Y 2017, 'Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles', Field Crops Research, vol. 202, pp. 5-20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2016.05.001
Maiorano, Andrea ; Martre, Pierre ; Asseng, Senthold ; Ewert, Frank ; Müller, Christoph ; Rötter, Reimund P. ; Ruane, Alex C. ; Semenov, Mikhail A. ; Wallach, Daniel ; Wang, Enli ; Alderman, Phillip D. ; Kassie, Belay T. ; Biernath, Christian ; Basso, Bruno ; Cammarano, Davide ; Challinor, Andrew J. ; Doltra, Jordi ; Dumont, Benjamin ; Rezaei, Ehsan Eyshi ; Gayler, Sebastian ; Kersebaum, Kurt Christian ; Kimball, Bruce A. ; Koehler, Ann Kristin ; Liu, Bing ; O'Leary, Garry J. ; Olesen, Jørgen E. ; Ottman, Michael J ; Priesack, Eckart ; Reynolds, Matthew ; Stratonovitch, Pierre ; Streck, Thilo ; Thorburn, Peter J. ; Waha, Katharina ; Wall, Gerard W. ; White, Jeffrey W. ; Zhao, Zhigan ; Zhu, Yan. / Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles. In: Field Crops Research. 2017 ; Vol. 202. pp. 5-20.
@article{9f18c67ea44f4008b6b9d688382a6057,
title = "Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles",
abstract = "To improve climate change impact estimates and to quantify their uncertainty, multi-model ensembles (MMEs) have been suggested. Model improvements can improve the accuracy of simulations and reduce the uncertainty of climate change impact assessments. Furthermore, they can reduce the number of models needed in a MME. Herein, 15 wheat growth models of a larger MME were improved through re-parameterization and/or incorporating or modifying heat stress effects on phenology, leaf growth and senescence, biomass growth, and grain number and size using detailed field experimental data from the USDA Hot Serial Cereal experiment (calibration data set). Simulation results from before and after model improvement were then evaluated with independent field experiments from a CIMMYT world-wide field trial network (evaluation data set). Model improvements decreased the variation (10th to 90th model ensemble percentile range) of grain yields simulated by the MME on average by 39{\%} in the calibration data set and by 26{\%} in the independent evaluation data set for crops grown in mean seasonal temperatures >24 °C. MME mean squared error in simulating grain yield decreased by 37{\%}. A reduction in MME uncertainty range by 27{\%} increased MME prediction skills by 47{\%}. Results suggest that the mean level of variation observed in field experiments and used as a benchmark can be reached with half the number of models in the MME. Improving crop models is therefore important to increase the certainty of model-based impact assessments and allow more practical, i.e. smaller MMEs to be used effectively.",
keywords = "High temperature, Impact uncertainty, Model improvement, Multi-model ensemble, Wheat crop model",
author = "Andrea Maiorano and Pierre Martre and Senthold Asseng and Frank Ewert and Christoph M{\"u}ller and R{\"o}tter, {Reimund P.} and Ruane, {Alex C.} and Semenov, {Mikhail A.} and Daniel Wallach and Enli Wang and Alderman, {Phillip D.} and Kassie, {Belay T.} and Christian Biernath and Bruno Basso and Davide Cammarano and Challinor, {Andrew J.} and Jordi Doltra and Benjamin Dumont and Rezaei, {Ehsan Eyshi} and Sebastian Gayler and Kersebaum, {Kurt Christian} and Kimball, {Bruce A.} and Koehler, {Ann Kristin} and Bing Liu and O'Leary, {Garry J.} and Olesen, {J{\o}rgen E.} and Ottman, {Michael J} and Eckart Priesack and Matthew Reynolds and Pierre Stratonovitch and Thilo Streck and Thorburn, {Peter J.} and Katharina Waha and Wall, {Gerard W.} and White, {Jeffrey W.} and Zhigan Zhao and Yan Zhu",
year = "2017",
month = "2",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.fcr.2016.05.001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "202",
pages = "5--20",
journal = "Field Crops Research",
issn = "0378-4290",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Crop model improvement reduces the uncertainty of the response to temperature of multi-model ensembles

AU - Maiorano, Andrea

AU - Martre, Pierre

AU - Asseng, Senthold

AU - Ewert, Frank

AU - Müller, Christoph

AU - Rötter, Reimund P.

AU - Ruane, Alex C.

AU - Semenov, Mikhail A.

AU - Wallach, Daniel

AU - Wang, Enli

AU - Alderman, Phillip D.

AU - Kassie, Belay T.

AU - Biernath, Christian

AU - Basso, Bruno

AU - Cammarano, Davide

AU - Challinor, Andrew J.

AU - Doltra, Jordi

AU - Dumont, Benjamin

AU - Rezaei, Ehsan Eyshi

AU - Gayler, Sebastian

AU - Kersebaum, Kurt Christian

AU - Kimball, Bruce A.

AU - Koehler, Ann Kristin

AU - Liu, Bing

AU - O'Leary, Garry J.

AU - Olesen, Jørgen E.

AU - Ottman, Michael J

AU - Priesack, Eckart

AU - Reynolds, Matthew

AU - Stratonovitch, Pierre

AU - Streck, Thilo

AU - Thorburn, Peter J.

AU - Waha, Katharina

AU - Wall, Gerard W.

AU - White, Jeffrey W.

AU - Zhao, Zhigan

AU - Zhu, Yan

PY - 2017/2/15

Y1 - 2017/2/15

N2 - To improve climate change impact estimates and to quantify their uncertainty, multi-model ensembles (MMEs) have been suggested. Model improvements can improve the accuracy of simulations and reduce the uncertainty of climate change impact assessments. Furthermore, they can reduce the number of models needed in a MME. Herein, 15 wheat growth models of a larger MME were improved through re-parameterization and/or incorporating or modifying heat stress effects on phenology, leaf growth and senescence, biomass growth, and grain number and size using detailed field experimental data from the USDA Hot Serial Cereal experiment (calibration data set). Simulation results from before and after model improvement were then evaluated with independent field experiments from a CIMMYT world-wide field trial network (evaluation data set). Model improvements decreased the variation (10th to 90th model ensemble percentile range) of grain yields simulated by the MME on average by 39% in the calibration data set and by 26% in the independent evaluation data set for crops grown in mean seasonal temperatures >24 °C. MME mean squared error in simulating grain yield decreased by 37%. A reduction in MME uncertainty range by 27% increased MME prediction skills by 47%. Results suggest that the mean level of variation observed in field experiments and used as a benchmark can be reached with half the number of models in the MME. Improving crop models is therefore important to increase the certainty of model-based impact assessments and allow more practical, i.e. smaller MMEs to be used effectively.

AB - To improve climate change impact estimates and to quantify their uncertainty, multi-model ensembles (MMEs) have been suggested. Model improvements can improve the accuracy of simulations and reduce the uncertainty of climate change impact assessments. Furthermore, they can reduce the number of models needed in a MME. Herein, 15 wheat growth models of a larger MME were improved through re-parameterization and/or incorporating or modifying heat stress effects on phenology, leaf growth and senescence, biomass growth, and grain number and size using detailed field experimental data from the USDA Hot Serial Cereal experiment (calibration data set). Simulation results from before and after model improvement were then evaluated with independent field experiments from a CIMMYT world-wide field trial network (evaluation data set). Model improvements decreased the variation (10th to 90th model ensemble percentile range) of grain yields simulated by the MME on average by 39% in the calibration data set and by 26% in the independent evaluation data set for crops grown in mean seasonal temperatures >24 °C. MME mean squared error in simulating grain yield decreased by 37%. A reduction in MME uncertainty range by 27% increased MME prediction skills by 47%. Results suggest that the mean level of variation observed in field experiments and used as a benchmark can be reached with half the number of models in the MME. Improving crop models is therefore important to increase the certainty of model-based impact assessments and allow more practical, i.e. smaller MMEs to be used effectively.

KW - High temperature

KW - Impact uncertainty

KW - Model improvement

KW - Multi-model ensemble

KW - Wheat crop model

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84971612306&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84971612306&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.fcr.2016.05.001

DO - 10.1016/j.fcr.2016.05.001

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84971612306

VL - 202

SP - 5

EP - 20

JO - Field Crops Research

JF - Field Crops Research

SN - 0378-4290

ER -