Earth surface modeling for education: How effective is it? Four semesters of classroom tests with WILSIM-GC

Wei Luo, Thomas J. Smith, Kyle Whalley, Andrew Darling, Carol Ormand, Wei Chen Hung, Jui Ling Chiang, Jon Pelletier, Kirk Duffin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper presents results from a randomized experimental design replicated over four semesters that compared students’ performance in understanding landform evolution processes as measured by the pretest to posttest score growth between two treatment methods: an online interactive simulation tool and a paper-based exercise. While both methods were shown to be effective at enhancing students’ learning of the landform concepts and processes, there was no statistically significant difference in score growth between the two instructional methods. However, the attitudinal survey indicated that students consistently favored the simulation approach over the paper-based exercise. With the simulation method, female students showed greater score growth than males, especially for test items requiring higher level thinking. This indicates that the visually rich interactive simulation tool may be integrated to better support female students’ learning in geoscience. Science major students generally outperformed non-science major students in terms of score growth, which suggests that background knowledge played an important role in realizing the potential of computer modeling in enhancing students’ learning. Sufficient scaffolding is necessary to maximize the effect of interactive earth surface modeling in geoscience education.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalBritish Journal of Educational Technology
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

semester
classroom
education
simulation
student
female student
learning
science
performance

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

Earth surface modeling for education : How effective is it? Four semesters of classroom tests with WILSIM-GC. / Luo, Wei; Smith, Thomas J.; Whalley, Kyle; Darling, Andrew; Ormand, Carol; Hung, Wei Chen; Chiang, Jui Ling; Pelletier, Jon; Duffin, Kirk.

In: British Journal of Educational Technology, 01.01.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Luo, Wei ; Smith, Thomas J. ; Whalley, Kyle ; Darling, Andrew ; Ormand, Carol ; Hung, Wei Chen ; Chiang, Jui Ling ; Pelletier, Jon ; Duffin, Kirk. / Earth surface modeling for education : How effective is it? Four semesters of classroom tests with WILSIM-GC. In: British Journal of Educational Technology. 2018.
@article{70cf433ffaf1431a81075cee9a383a25,
title = "Earth surface modeling for education: How effective is it? Four semesters of classroom tests with WILSIM-GC",
abstract = "This paper presents results from a randomized experimental design replicated over four semesters that compared students’ performance in understanding landform evolution processes as measured by the pretest to posttest score growth between two treatment methods: an online interactive simulation tool and a paper-based exercise. While both methods were shown to be effective at enhancing students’ learning of the landform concepts and processes, there was no statistically significant difference in score growth between the two instructional methods. However, the attitudinal survey indicated that students consistently favored the simulation approach over the paper-based exercise. With the simulation method, female students showed greater score growth than males, especially for test items requiring higher level thinking. This indicates that the visually rich interactive simulation tool may be integrated to better support female students’ learning in geoscience. Science major students generally outperformed non-science major students in terms of score growth, which suggests that background knowledge played an important role in realizing the potential of computer modeling in enhancing students’ learning. Sufficient scaffolding is necessary to maximize the effect of interactive earth surface modeling in geoscience education.",
author = "Wei Luo and Smith, {Thomas J.} and Kyle Whalley and Andrew Darling and Carol Ormand and Hung, {Wei Chen} and Chiang, {Jui Ling} and Jon Pelletier and Kirk Duffin",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/bjet.12653",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "British Journal of Educational Technology",
issn = "0007-1013",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Earth surface modeling for education

T2 - How effective is it? Four semesters of classroom tests with WILSIM-GC

AU - Luo, Wei

AU - Smith, Thomas J.

AU - Whalley, Kyle

AU - Darling, Andrew

AU - Ormand, Carol

AU - Hung, Wei Chen

AU - Chiang, Jui Ling

AU - Pelletier, Jon

AU - Duffin, Kirk

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - This paper presents results from a randomized experimental design replicated over four semesters that compared students’ performance in understanding landform evolution processes as measured by the pretest to posttest score growth between two treatment methods: an online interactive simulation tool and a paper-based exercise. While both methods were shown to be effective at enhancing students’ learning of the landform concepts and processes, there was no statistically significant difference in score growth between the two instructional methods. However, the attitudinal survey indicated that students consistently favored the simulation approach over the paper-based exercise. With the simulation method, female students showed greater score growth than males, especially for test items requiring higher level thinking. This indicates that the visually rich interactive simulation tool may be integrated to better support female students’ learning in geoscience. Science major students generally outperformed non-science major students in terms of score growth, which suggests that background knowledge played an important role in realizing the potential of computer modeling in enhancing students’ learning. Sufficient scaffolding is necessary to maximize the effect of interactive earth surface modeling in geoscience education.

AB - This paper presents results from a randomized experimental design replicated over four semesters that compared students’ performance in understanding landform evolution processes as measured by the pretest to posttest score growth between two treatment methods: an online interactive simulation tool and a paper-based exercise. While both methods were shown to be effective at enhancing students’ learning of the landform concepts and processes, there was no statistically significant difference in score growth between the two instructional methods. However, the attitudinal survey indicated that students consistently favored the simulation approach over the paper-based exercise. With the simulation method, female students showed greater score growth than males, especially for test items requiring higher level thinking. This indicates that the visually rich interactive simulation tool may be integrated to better support female students’ learning in geoscience. Science major students generally outperformed non-science major students in terms of score growth, which suggests that background knowledge played an important role in realizing the potential of computer modeling in enhancing students’ learning. Sufficient scaffolding is necessary to maximize the effect of interactive earth surface modeling in geoscience education.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85053204664&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85053204664&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/bjet.12653

DO - 10.1111/bjet.12653

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85053204664

JO - British Journal of Educational Technology

JF - British Journal of Educational Technology

SN - 0007-1013

ER -