Environmental forcing and the competitive dynamics of a guild of cactus-tending ant mutualists

William F. Morris, William G. Wilson, Judith L Bronstein, Joshua H. Ness

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In generalized, multispecies mutualisms, competition among members of one guild can influence the net benefits that each species in the other guild receives. Hence seasonal factors that affect the dynamics of competition can also affect net benefits, especially if the benefit or cost of mutualism also varies seasonally. In the Sonoran Desert, two common species of generalist ants compete for access to extrafloral nectaries on the fishhook barrel cactus Ferocactus wislizeni, but their relative abundances vary seasonally; one ant dominates more cacti in winter/spring, and the other in summer/autumn. Recently, a third ant species, which also varies in abundance seasonally, has appeared at our study sites and is competing with resident ants for access to cactus nectaries. This empirical system motivated us to examine a metapopulation model of competition for patches in an open system with periodic forcing. We use the model to: (1) illustrate three ways in which competing species may differ in their sensitivities to environmental conditions that are consistent with seasonally displaced patterns of abundance; (2) ask under what conditions the invasion of a third competitor into a two-species system could alter the sensitivity of the system to environmental forcing at low vs. high frequency; and (3) show how differences among competitors in the pattern of seasonal forcing alone can dramatically alter the outcome of a competitor invasion. We discuss implications of these results for the ways in which seasonal variation among competing mutualists, and the benefits and costs of mutualism, may affect the functioning of generalized, facultative mutualisms.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)3190-3199
Number of pages10
JournalEcology
Volume86
Issue number12
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2005

Fingerprint

cactus
guild
ant
Formicidae
nectaries
mutualism
nectary
Ferocactus wislizeni
Sonoran Desert
metapopulation
cost
generalist
seasonal variation
autumn
relative abundance
desert
environmental factors
environmental conditions
winter
summer

Keywords

  • Ant-plant mutualism
  • Coherence number
  • Competition
  • Environmental forcing
  • Ferocactus wislizeni
  • Metapopulation
  • Resonance
  • Seasonality
  • Transfer function

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Environmental forcing and the competitive dynamics of a guild of cactus-tending ant mutualists. / Morris, William F.; Wilson, William G.; Bronstein, Judith L; Ness, Joshua H.

In: Ecology, Vol. 86, No. 12, 12.2005, p. 3190-3199.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Morris, William F. ; Wilson, William G. ; Bronstein, Judith L ; Ness, Joshua H. / Environmental forcing and the competitive dynamics of a guild of cactus-tending ant mutualists. In: Ecology. 2005 ; Vol. 86, No. 12. pp. 3190-3199.
@article{a789cfbc65f541f2a2e77daa1f7856fa,
title = "Environmental forcing and the competitive dynamics of a guild of cactus-tending ant mutualists",
abstract = "In generalized, multispecies mutualisms, competition among members of one guild can influence the net benefits that each species in the other guild receives. Hence seasonal factors that affect the dynamics of competition can also affect net benefits, especially if the benefit or cost of mutualism also varies seasonally. In the Sonoran Desert, two common species of generalist ants compete for access to extrafloral nectaries on the fishhook barrel cactus Ferocactus wislizeni, but their relative abundances vary seasonally; one ant dominates more cacti in winter/spring, and the other in summer/autumn. Recently, a third ant species, which also varies in abundance seasonally, has appeared at our study sites and is competing with resident ants for access to cactus nectaries. This empirical system motivated us to examine a metapopulation model of competition for patches in an open system with periodic forcing. We use the model to: (1) illustrate three ways in which competing species may differ in their sensitivities to environmental conditions that are consistent with seasonally displaced patterns of abundance; (2) ask under what conditions the invasion of a third competitor into a two-species system could alter the sensitivity of the system to environmental forcing at low vs. high frequency; and (3) show how differences among competitors in the pattern of seasonal forcing alone can dramatically alter the outcome of a competitor invasion. We discuss implications of these results for the ways in which seasonal variation among competing mutualists, and the benefits and costs of mutualism, may affect the functioning of generalized, facultative mutualisms.",
keywords = "Ant-plant mutualism, Coherence number, Competition, Environmental forcing, Ferocactus wislizeni, Metapopulation, Resonance, Seasonality, Transfer function",
author = "Morris, {William F.} and Wilson, {William G.} and Bronstein, {Judith L} and Ness, {Joshua H.}",
year = "2005",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1890/05-0465",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "86",
pages = "3190--3199",
journal = "Ecology",
issn = "0012-9658",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Environmental forcing and the competitive dynamics of a guild of cactus-tending ant mutualists

AU - Morris, William F.

AU - Wilson, William G.

AU - Bronstein, Judith L

AU - Ness, Joshua H.

PY - 2005/12

Y1 - 2005/12

N2 - In generalized, multispecies mutualisms, competition among members of one guild can influence the net benefits that each species in the other guild receives. Hence seasonal factors that affect the dynamics of competition can also affect net benefits, especially if the benefit or cost of mutualism also varies seasonally. In the Sonoran Desert, two common species of generalist ants compete for access to extrafloral nectaries on the fishhook barrel cactus Ferocactus wislizeni, but their relative abundances vary seasonally; one ant dominates more cacti in winter/spring, and the other in summer/autumn. Recently, a third ant species, which also varies in abundance seasonally, has appeared at our study sites and is competing with resident ants for access to cactus nectaries. This empirical system motivated us to examine a metapopulation model of competition for patches in an open system with periodic forcing. We use the model to: (1) illustrate three ways in which competing species may differ in their sensitivities to environmental conditions that are consistent with seasonally displaced patterns of abundance; (2) ask under what conditions the invasion of a third competitor into a two-species system could alter the sensitivity of the system to environmental forcing at low vs. high frequency; and (3) show how differences among competitors in the pattern of seasonal forcing alone can dramatically alter the outcome of a competitor invasion. We discuss implications of these results for the ways in which seasonal variation among competing mutualists, and the benefits and costs of mutualism, may affect the functioning of generalized, facultative mutualisms.

AB - In generalized, multispecies mutualisms, competition among members of one guild can influence the net benefits that each species in the other guild receives. Hence seasonal factors that affect the dynamics of competition can also affect net benefits, especially if the benefit or cost of mutualism also varies seasonally. In the Sonoran Desert, two common species of generalist ants compete for access to extrafloral nectaries on the fishhook barrel cactus Ferocactus wislizeni, but their relative abundances vary seasonally; one ant dominates more cacti in winter/spring, and the other in summer/autumn. Recently, a third ant species, which also varies in abundance seasonally, has appeared at our study sites and is competing with resident ants for access to cactus nectaries. This empirical system motivated us to examine a metapopulation model of competition for patches in an open system with periodic forcing. We use the model to: (1) illustrate three ways in which competing species may differ in their sensitivities to environmental conditions that are consistent with seasonally displaced patterns of abundance; (2) ask under what conditions the invasion of a third competitor into a two-species system could alter the sensitivity of the system to environmental forcing at low vs. high frequency; and (3) show how differences among competitors in the pattern of seasonal forcing alone can dramatically alter the outcome of a competitor invasion. We discuss implications of these results for the ways in which seasonal variation among competing mutualists, and the benefits and costs of mutualism, may affect the functioning of generalized, facultative mutualisms.

KW - Ant-plant mutualism

KW - Coherence number

KW - Competition

KW - Environmental forcing

KW - Ferocactus wislizeni

KW - Metapopulation

KW - Resonance

KW - Seasonality

KW - Transfer function

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=30644469164&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=30644469164&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1890/05-0465

DO - 10.1890/05-0465

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:30644469164

VL - 86

SP - 3190

EP - 3199

JO - Ecology

JF - Ecology

SN - 0012-9658

IS - 12

ER -