Facemask use for community protection from air pollution disasters: An ethical overview and framework to guide agency decision making

Fiona McDonald, Claire J. Horwell, Richard Wecker, Lena Dominelli, Miranda Loh, Robie Kamanyire, Ciro Ugarte

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Abstract

Disasters involving severe air pollution episodes create a pressing public health issue. During such emergencies, there may be pressure on agencies to provide solutions to protect affected communities. One possible intervention to reduce exposure during such crises is facemasks. Ethical values need to be considered as part of any decision-making process to assess whether to provide advice on, recommend and/or distribute any public health intervention. In this paper, we use principles from public health ethics to analyse the critical ethical issues that relate to agencies providing advice on, recommending and/or distributing facemasks in air pollution disasters, given a lack of evidence of both the specific risk of some polluting events or the effectiveness of facemasks in community settings. The need for reflection on the ethical issues raised by the possible recommendation/use of facemasks to mitigate potential health issues arising from air pollution disasters is critical as communities progressively seek personal interventions to manage perceived and actual risks. This paper develops an ethical decision-making framework to assist agency deliberations. We argue that clarity around decision-making by agencies, after using this framework, may help increase trust about the intervention and solidarity within and between populations affected by these disasters and the agencies who support public health or provide assistance during disasters.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number101376
JournalInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
Volume43
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 2020

Fingerprint

air pollution
Air pollution
Disasters
Public health
disaster
atmospheric pollution
Decision making
decision making
public health
community
ethics
deliberation
decision-making process
solidarity
assistance
moral philosophy
Health
event
lack
health

Keywords

  • Air pollution
  • Air pollution disasters
  • Disaster response
  • Ethical Decision-making framework
  • Facemasks
  • Public health ethics

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geotechnical Engineering and Engineering Geology
  • Safety Research
  • Geology

Cite this

Facemask use for community protection from air pollution disasters : An ethical overview and framework to guide agency decision making. / McDonald, Fiona; Horwell, Claire J.; Wecker, Richard; Dominelli, Lena; Loh, Miranda; Kamanyire, Robie; Ugarte, Ciro.

In: International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, Vol. 43, 101376, 02.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

McDonald, Fiona ; Horwell, Claire J. ; Wecker, Richard ; Dominelli, Lena ; Loh, Miranda ; Kamanyire, Robie ; Ugarte, Ciro. / Facemask use for community protection from air pollution disasters : An ethical overview and framework to guide agency decision making. In: International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction. 2020 ; Vol. 43.
@article{0d49978a67a14dcdac2160ddc57c9978,
title = "Facemask use for community protection from air pollution disasters: An ethical overview and framework to guide agency decision making",
abstract = "Disasters involving severe air pollution episodes create a pressing public health issue. During such emergencies, there may be pressure on agencies to provide solutions to protect affected communities. One possible intervention to reduce exposure during such crises is facemasks. Ethical values need to be considered as part of any decision-making process to assess whether to provide advice on, recommend and/or distribute any public health intervention. In this paper, we use principles from public health ethics to analyse the critical ethical issues that relate to agencies providing advice on, recommending and/or distributing facemasks in air pollution disasters, given a lack of evidence of both the specific risk of some polluting events or the effectiveness of facemasks in community settings. The need for reflection on the ethical issues raised by the possible recommendation/use of facemasks to mitigate potential health issues arising from air pollution disasters is critical as communities progressively seek personal interventions to manage perceived and actual risks. This paper develops an ethical decision-making framework to assist agency deliberations. We argue that clarity around decision-making by agencies, after using this framework, may help increase trust about the intervention and solidarity within and between populations affected by these disasters and the agencies who support public health or provide assistance during disasters.",
keywords = "Air pollution, Air pollution disasters, Disaster response, Ethical Decision-making framework, Facemasks, Public health ethics",
author = "Fiona McDonald and Horwell, {Claire J.} and Richard Wecker and Lena Dominelli and Miranda Loh and Robie Kamanyire and Ciro Ugarte",
year = "2020",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1016/j.ijdrr.2019.101376",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "43",
journal = "International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction",
issn = "2212-4209",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Facemask use for community protection from air pollution disasters

T2 - An ethical overview and framework to guide agency decision making

AU - McDonald, Fiona

AU - Horwell, Claire J.

AU - Wecker, Richard

AU - Dominelli, Lena

AU - Loh, Miranda

AU - Kamanyire, Robie

AU - Ugarte, Ciro

PY - 2020/2

Y1 - 2020/2

N2 - Disasters involving severe air pollution episodes create a pressing public health issue. During such emergencies, there may be pressure on agencies to provide solutions to protect affected communities. One possible intervention to reduce exposure during such crises is facemasks. Ethical values need to be considered as part of any decision-making process to assess whether to provide advice on, recommend and/or distribute any public health intervention. In this paper, we use principles from public health ethics to analyse the critical ethical issues that relate to agencies providing advice on, recommending and/or distributing facemasks in air pollution disasters, given a lack of evidence of both the specific risk of some polluting events or the effectiveness of facemasks in community settings. The need for reflection on the ethical issues raised by the possible recommendation/use of facemasks to mitigate potential health issues arising from air pollution disasters is critical as communities progressively seek personal interventions to manage perceived and actual risks. This paper develops an ethical decision-making framework to assist agency deliberations. We argue that clarity around decision-making by agencies, after using this framework, may help increase trust about the intervention and solidarity within and between populations affected by these disasters and the agencies who support public health or provide assistance during disasters.

AB - Disasters involving severe air pollution episodes create a pressing public health issue. During such emergencies, there may be pressure on agencies to provide solutions to protect affected communities. One possible intervention to reduce exposure during such crises is facemasks. Ethical values need to be considered as part of any decision-making process to assess whether to provide advice on, recommend and/or distribute any public health intervention. In this paper, we use principles from public health ethics to analyse the critical ethical issues that relate to agencies providing advice on, recommending and/or distributing facemasks in air pollution disasters, given a lack of evidence of both the specific risk of some polluting events or the effectiveness of facemasks in community settings. The need for reflection on the ethical issues raised by the possible recommendation/use of facemasks to mitigate potential health issues arising from air pollution disasters is critical as communities progressively seek personal interventions to manage perceived and actual risks. This paper develops an ethical decision-making framework to assist agency deliberations. We argue that clarity around decision-making by agencies, after using this framework, may help increase trust about the intervention and solidarity within and between populations affected by these disasters and the agencies who support public health or provide assistance during disasters.

KW - Air pollution

KW - Air pollution disasters

KW - Disaster response

KW - Ethical Decision-making framework

KW - Facemasks

KW - Public health ethics

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074560160&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85074560160&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ijdrr.2019.101376

DO - 10.1016/j.ijdrr.2019.101376

M3 - Review article

AN - SCOPUS:85074560160

VL - 43

JO - International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction

JF - International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction

SN - 2212-4209

M1 - 101376

ER -