Factors affecting the molecular structure and mean residence time of occluded organics in a lithosequence of soils under ponderosa pine

Katherine Heckman, Heather Throckmorton, Christopher Clingensmith, Francisco Javier González Vila, William R. Horwath, Heike Knicker, Craig Rasmussen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Occluded, or intra-aggregate, soil organic matter (SOM) comprises a significant portion of the total C pool in forest soils and often has very long mean residence times (MRTs). However, occluded C characteristics vary widely among soils and the genesis and composition of the occluded organic matter pool are not well understood. This work sought to define the major controls on the composition and MRT of occluded SOM in western U.S. conifer forest soils with specific focus on the influence of soil mineral assemblage and aggregate stability. We sampled soils from a lithosequence of four parent materials (rhyolite, granite, basalt, and dolostone) under Pinus ponderosa. Three pedons were excavated to the depth of refusal at each site and sampled by genetic horizon. After density separation at 1.8gcm-3 into free/light, occluded and mineral fractions, the chemical nature and mean residence time of organics in each fraction were compared. SOM chemistry was explored through the use of stable isotope analyses, 13C NMR, and pyrolysis GC/MS. Soil charcoal content estimates were based on 13C NMR analyses. Estimates of SOM MRT were based on steady-state modeling of SOM radiocarbon abundance measurements. Across all soils, the occluded fraction was 0.5-5 times enriched in charcoal in comparison to the bulk soil and had a substantially longer MRT than either the mineral fraction or the free/light fraction. These results suggest that charcoal from periodic burning is the primary source of occluded organics in these soils, and that the structural properties of charcoal promote its aggregation and long-term preservation. Surprisingly, aggregate stability, as measured through ultrasonic dispersion, was not correlated with occluded SOM abundance or MRT, perhaps raising questions of how well laboratory measurements of aggregate stability capture the dynamics of aggregate turnover under field conditions. Examination of the molecular characteristics of the occluded fraction was more conclusive. Occluded fraction composition did not change substantially with soil mineral assemblage, but was increasingly enriched in charcoal with depth relative to bulk SOM. Enrichment levels of 13C and 15N suggested a similar degree of microbial processing for the free/light and occluded fractions, and molecular structure of occluded and free/light fractions were also similar aside from charcoal enrichment in the occluded fraction. Results highlight the importance of both fire and aggregate formation to the long-term preservation of organics in western U.S. conifer forests which experience periodic burning, and suggest that the composition of occluded SOM in these soils is dependent on fire and the selective occlusion of charcoal.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-11
Number of pages11
JournalSoil Biology and Biochemistry
Volume77
DOIs
StatePublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Pinus ponderosa
Molecular Structure
organic soils
chemical structure
residence time
soil organic matter
charcoal
Soil
Charcoal
soil
aggregate stability
mineral
soil aggregates
forest soils
forest soil
coniferous forests
coniferous tree
nuclear magnetic resonance
Minerals
dolomitic limestone

Keywords

  • Black carbon
  • Density fractionation
  • Forest soil
  • Occluded organic matter
  • Soil organic matter

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Soil Science
  • Microbiology

Cite this

Factors affecting the molecular structure and mean residence time of occluded organics in a lithosequence of soils under ponderosa pine. / Heckman, Katherine; Throckmorton, Heather; Clingensmith, Christopher; González Vila, Francisco Javier; Horwath, William R.; Knicker, Heike; Rasmussen, Craig.

In: Soil Biology and Biochemistry, Vol. 77, 2014, p. 1-11.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Heckman, Katherine ; Throckmorton, Heather ; Clingensmith, Christopher ; González Vila, Francisco Javier ; Horwath, William R. ; Knicker, Heike ; Rasmussen, Craig. / Factors affecting the molecular structure and mean residence time of occluded organics in a lithosequence of soils under ponderosa pine. In: Soil Biology and Biochemistry. 2014 ; Vol. 77. pp. 1-11.
@article{73acc7c2a99848458ce606c20adeb362,
title = "Factors affecting the molecular structure and mean residence time of occluded organics in a lithosequence of soils under ponderosa pine",
abstract = "Occluded, or intra-aggregate, soil organic matter (SOM) comprises a significant portion of the total C pool in forest soils and often has very long mean residence times (MRTs). However, occluded C characteristics vary widely among soils and the genesis and composition of the occluded organic matter pool are not well understood. This work sought to define the major controls on the composition and MRT of occluded SOM in western U.S. conifer forest soils with specific focus on the influence of soil mineral assemblage and aggregate stability. We sampled soils from a lithosequence of four parent materials (rhyolite, granite, basalt, and dolostone) under Pinus ponderosa. Three pedons were excavated to the depth of refusal at each site and sampled by genetic horizon. After density separation at 1.8gcm-3 into free/light, occluded and mineral fractions, the chemical nature and mean residence time of organics in each fraction were compared. SOM chemistry was explored through the use of stable isotope analyses, 13C NMR, and pyrolysis GC/MS. Soil charcoal content estimates were based on 13C NMR analyses. Estimates of SOM MRT were based on steady-state modeling of SOM radiocarbon abundance measurements. Across all soils, the occluded fraction was 0.5-5 times enriched in charcoal in comparison to the bulk soil and had a substantially longer MRT than either the mineral fraction or the free/light fraction. These results suggest that charcoal from periodic burning is the primary source of occluded organics in these soils, and that the structural properties of charcoal promote its aggregation and long-term preservation. Surprisingly, aggregate stability, as measured through ultrasonic dispersion, was not correlated with occluded SOM abundance or MRT, perhaps raising questions of how well laboratory measurements of aggregate stability capture the dynamics of aggregate turnover under field conditions. Examination of the molecular characteristics of the occluded fraction was more conclusive. Occluded fraction composition did not change substantially with soil mineral assemblage, but was increasingly enriched in charcoal with depth relative to bulk SOM. Enrichment levels of 13C and 15N suggested a similar degree of microbial processing for the free/light and occluded fractions, and molecular structure of occluded and free/light fractions were also similar aside from charcoal enrichment in the occluded fraction. Results highlight the importance of both fire and aggregate formation to the long-term preservation of organics in western U.S. conifer forests which experience periodic burning, and suggest that the composition of occluded SOM in these soils is dependent on fire and the selective occlusion of charcoal.",
keywords = "Black carbon, Density fractionation, Forest soil, Occluded organic matter, Soil organic matter",
author = "Katherine Heckman and Heather Throckmorton and Christopher Clingensmith and {Gonz{\'a}lez Vila}, {Francisco Javier} and Horwath, {William R.} and Heike Knicker and Craig Rasmussen",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1016/j.soilbio.2014.05.028",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "77",
pages = "1--11",
journal = "Soil Biology and Biochemistry",
issn = "0038-0717",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Factors affecting the molecular structure and mean residence time of occluded organics in a lithosequence of soils under ponderosa pine

AU - Heckman, Katherine

AU - Throckmorton, Heather

AU - Clingensmith, Christopher

AU - González Vila, Francisco Javier

AU - Horwath, William R.

AU - Knicker, Heike

AU - Rasmussen, Craig

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Occluded, or intra-aggregate, soil organic matter (SOM) comprises a significant portion of the total C pool in forest soils and often has very long mean residence times (MRTs). However, occluded C characteristics vary widely among soils and the genesis and composition of the occluded organic matter pool are not well understood. This work sought to define the major controls on the composition and MRT of occluded SOM in western U.S. conifer forest soils with specific focus on the influence of soil mineral assemblage and aggregate stability. We sampled soils from a lithosequence of four parent materials (rhyolite, granite, basalt, and dolostone) under Pinus ponderosa. Three pedons were excavated to the depth of refusal at each site and sampled by genetic horizon. After density separation at 1.8gcm-3 into free/light, occluded and mineral fractions, the chemical nature and mean residence time of organics in each fraction were compared. SOM chemistry was explored through the use of stable isotope analyses, 13C NMR, and pyrolysis GC/MS. Soil charcoal content estimates were based on 13C NMR analyses. Estimates of SOM MRT were based on steady-state modeling of SOM radiocarbon abundance measurements. Across all soils, the occluded fraction was 0.5-5 times enriched in charcoal in comparison to the bulk soil and had a substantially longer MRT than either the mineral fraction or the free/light fraction. These results suggest that charcoal from periodic burning is the primary source of occluded organics in these soils, and that the structural properties of charcoal promote its aggregation and long-term preservation. Surprisingly, aggregate stability, as measured through ultrasonic dispersion, was not correlated with occluded SOM abundance or MRT, perhaps raising questions of how well laboratory measurements of aggregate stability capture the dynamics of aggregate turnover under field conditions. Examination of the molecular characteristics of the occluded fraction was more conclusive. Occluded fraction composition did not change substantially with soil mineral assemblage, but was increasingly enriched in charcoal with depth relative to bulk SOM. Enrichment levels of 13C and 15N suggested a similar degree of microbial processing for the free/light and occluded fractions, and molecular structure of occluded and free/light fractions were also similar aside from charcoal enrichment in the occluded fraction. Results highlight the importance of both fire and aggregate formation to the long-term preservation of organics in western U.S. conifer forests which experience periodic burning, and suggest that the composition of occluded SOM in these soils is dependent on fire and the selective occlusion of charcoal.

AB - Occluded, or intra-aggregate, soil organic matter (SOM) comprises a significant portion of the total C pool in forest soils and often has very long mean residence times (MRTs). However, occluded C characteristics vary widely among soils and the genesis and composition of the occluded organic matter pool are not well understood. This work sought to define the major controls on the composition and MRT of occluded SOM in western U.S. conifer forest soils with specific focus on the influence of soil mineral assemblage and aggregate stability. We sampled soils from a lithosequence of four parent materials (rhyolite, granite, basalt, and dolostone) under Pinus ponderosa. Three pedons were excavated to the depth of refusal at each site and sampled by genetic horizon. After density separation at 1.8gcm-3 into free/light, occluded and mineral fractions, the chemical nature and mean residence time of organics in each fraction were compared. SOM chemistry was explored through the use of stable isotope analyses, 13C NMR, and pyrolysis GC/MS. Soil charcoal content estimates were based on 13C NMR analyses. Estimates of SOM MRT were based on steady-state modeling of SOM radiocarbon abundance measurements. Across all soils, the occluded fraction was 0.5-5 times enriched in charcoal in comparison to the bulk soil and had a substantially longer MRT than either the mineral fraction or the free/light fraction. These results suggest that charcoal from periodic burning is the primary source of occluded organics in these soils, and that the structural properties of charcoal promote its aggregation and long-term preservation. Surprisingly, aggregate stability, as measured through ultrasonic dispersion, was not correlated with occluded SOM abundance or MRT, perhaps raising questions of how well laboratory measurements of aggregate stability capture the dynamics of aggregate turnover under field conditions. Examination of the molecular characteristics of the occluded fraction was more conclusive. Occluded fraction composition did not change substantially with soil mineral assemblage, but was increasingly enriched in charcoal with depth relative to bulk SOM. Enrichment levels of 13C and 15N suggested a similar degree of microbial processing for the free/light and occluded fractions, and molecular structure of occluded and free/light fractions were also similar aside from charcoal enrichment in the occluded fraction. Results highlight the importance of both fire and aggregate formation to the long-term preservation of organics in western U.S. conifer forests which experience periodic burning, and suggest that the composition of occluded SOM in these soils is dependent on fire and the selective occlusion of charcoal.

KW - Black carbon

KW - Density fractionation

KW - Forest soil

KW - Occluded organic matter

KW - Soil organic matter

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84902584175&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84902584175&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.soilbio.2014.05.028

DO - 10.1016/j.soilbio.2014.05.028

M3 - Article

VL - 77

SP - 1

EP - 11

JO - Soil Biology and Biochemistry

JF - Soil Biology and Biochemistry

SN - 0038-0717

ER -