First light LBT AO images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.6 and 3.3 μm

New discrepancies between young planets and old brown dwarfs

Andrew J. Skemer, Philip M Hinz, Simone Esposito, Adam Burrows, Jarron Leisenring, Michael Skrutskie, Silvano Desidera, Dino Mesa, Carmelo Arcidiacono, Filippo Mannucci, Timothy J. Rodigas, Laird M Close, Donald W Mccarthy, Craig Kulesa, Guido Agapito, Daniel Apai, Javier Argomedo, Vanessa Bailey, Konstantina Boutsia, Runa Briguglio & 28 others Guido Brusa, Lorenzo Busoni, Riccardo Claudi, Joshua A Eisner, Luca Fini, Katherine B. Follette, Peter Garnavich, Raffaele Gratton, Juan Carlos Guerra, John M. Hill, William F. Hoffmann, Terry Jones, Megan Krejny, Jared Males, Elena Masciadri, Michael R. Meyer, Douglas L. Miller, Katie Morzinski, Matthew Nelson, Enrico Pinna, Alfio Puglisi, Sascha P. Quanz, Fernando Quiros-Pacheco, Armando Riccardi, Paolo Stefanini, Vidhya Vaitheeswaran, John C. Wilson, Marco Xompero

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

99 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

As the only directly imaged multiple planet system, HR 8799 provides a unique opportunity to study the physical properties of several planets in parallel. In this paper, we image all four of the HR 8799 planets at H band and 3.3μm with the new Large Binocular Telescope adaptive optics system, PISCES, and LBTI/LMIRCam. Our images offer an unprecedented view of the system, allowing us to obtain H and 3.3μm photometry of the innermost planet (for the first time) and put strong upper limits on the presence of a hypothetical fifth companion. We find that all four planets are unexpectedly bright at 3.3μm compared to the equilibrium chemistry models used for field brown dwarfs, which predict that planets should be faint at 3.3μm due to CH4 opacity. We attempt to model the planets with thick-cloudy, non-equilibrium chemistry atmospheres but find that removing CH4 to fit the 3.3μm photometry increases the predicted L′ (3.8μm) flux enough that it is inconsistent with observations. In an effort to fit the spectral energy distribution of the HR 8799 planets, we construct mixtures of cloudy atmospheres, which are intended to represent planets covered by clouds of varying opacity. In this scenario, regions with low opacity look hot and bright, while regions with high opacity look faint, similar to the patchy cloud structures on Jupiter and L/T transition brown dwarfs. Our mixed-cloud models reproduce all of the available data, but self-consistent models are still necessary to demonstrate their viability.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number14
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume753
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2012

Fingerprint

planets
planet
opacity
photometry
chemistry
young
atmospheres
atmosphere
spectral energy distribution
Jupiter (planet)
adaptive optics
viability
Jupiter
physical property
physical properties
telescopes
energy

Keywords

  • Brown dwarfs
  • Instrumentation: adaptive optics
  • Planetary systems
  • Planets and satellites: atmospheres
  • Stars: individual (HR 8799)

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics

Cite this

First light LBT AO images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.6 and 3.3 μm : New discrepancies between young planets and old brown dwarfs. / Skemer, Andrew J.; Hinz, Philip M; Esposito, Simone; Burrows, Adam; Leisenring, Jarron; Skrutskie, Michael; Desidera, Silvano; Mesa, Dino; Arcidiacono, Carmelo; Mannucci, Filippo; Rodigas, Timothy J.; Close, Laird M; Mccarthy, Donald W; Kulesa, Craig; Agapito, Guido; Apai, Daniel; Argomedo, Javier; Bailey, Vanessa; Boutsia, Konstantina; Briguglio, Runa; Brusa, Guido; Busoni, Lorenzo; Claudi, Riccardo; Eisner, Joshua A; Fini, Luca; Follette, Katherine B.; Garnavich, Peter; Gratton, Raffaele; Guerra, Juan Carlos; Hill, John M.; Hoffmann, William F.; Jones, Terry; Krejny, Megan; Males, Jared; Masciadri, Elena; Meyer, Michael R.; Miller, Douglas L.; Morzinski, Katie; Nelson, Matthew; Pinna, Enrico; Puglisi, Alfio; Quanz, Sascha P.; Quiros-Pacheco, Fernando; Riccardi, Armando; Stefanini, Paolo; Vaitheeswaran, Vidhya; Wilson, John C.; Xompero, Marco.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 753, No. 1, 14, 01.07.2012.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Skemer, AJ, Hinz, PM, Esposito, S, Burrows, A, Leisenring, J, Skrutskie, M, Desidera, S, Mesa, D, Arcidiacono, C, Mannucci, F, Rodigas, TJ, Close, LM, Mccarthy, DW, Kulesa, C, Agapito, G, Apai, D, Argomedo, J, Bailey, V, Boutsia, K, Briguglio, R, Brusa, G, Busoni, L, Claudi, R, Eisner, JA, Fini, L, Follette, KB, Garnavich, P, Gratton, R, Guerra, JC, Hill, JM, Hoffmann, WF, Jones, T, Krejny, M, Males, J, Masciadri, E, Meyer, MR, Miller, DL, Morzinski, K, Nelson, M, Pinna, E, Puglisi, A, Quanz, SP, Quiros-Pacheco, F, Riccardi, A, Stefanini, P, Vaitheeswaran, V, Wilson, JC & Xompero, M 2012, 'First light LBT AO images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.6 and 3.3 μm: New discrepancies between young planets and old brown dwarfs', Astrophysical Journal, vol. 753, no. 1, 14. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/753/1/14
Skemer, Andrew J. ; Hinz, Philip M ; Esposito, Simone ; Burrows, Adam ; Leisenring, Jarron ; Skrutskie, Michael ; Desidera, Silvano ; Mesa, Dino ; Arcidiacono, Carmelo ; Mannucci, Filippo ; Rodigas, Timothy J. ; Close, Laird M ; Mccarthy, Donald W ; Kulesa, Craig ; Agapito, Guido ; Apai, Daniel ; Argomedo, Javier ; Bailey, Vanessa ; Boutsia, Konstantina ; Briguglio, Runa ; Brusa, Guido ; Busoni, Lorenzo ; Claudi, Riccardo ; Eisner, Joshua A ; Fini, Luca ; Follette, Katherine B. ; Garnavich, Peter ; Gratton, Raffaele ; Guerra, Juan Carlos ; Hill, John M. ; Hoffmann, William F. ; Jones, Terry ; Krejny, Megan ; Males, Jared ; Masciadri, Elena ; Meyer, Michael R. ; Miller, Douglas L. ; Morzinski, Katie ; Nelson, Matthew ; Pinna, Enrico ; Puglisi, Alfio ; Quanz, Sascha P. ; Quiros-Pacheco, Fernando ; Riccardi, Armando ; Stefanini, Paolo ; Vaitheeswaran, Vidhya ; Wilson, John C. ; Xompero, Marco. / First light LBT AO images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.6 and 3.3 μm : New discrepancies between young planets and old brown dwarfs. In: Astrophysical Journal. 2012 ; Vol. 753, No. 1.
@article{408841f63c9541858670c121eafa08f0,
title = "First light LBT AO images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.6 and 3.3 μm: New discrepancies between young planets and old brown dwarfs",
abstract = "As the only directly imaged multiple planet system, HR 8799 provides a unique opportunity to study the physical properties of several planets in parallel. In this paper, we image all four of the HR 8799 planets at H band and 3.3μm with the new Large Binocular Telescope adaptive optics system, PISCES, and LBTI/LMIRCam. Our images offer an unprecedented view of the system, allowing us to obtain H and 3.3μm photometry of the innermost planet (for the first time) and put strong upper limits on the presence of a hypothetical fifth companion. We find that all four planets are unexpectedly bright at 3.3μm compared to the equilibrium chemistry models used for field brown dwarfs, which predict that planets should be faint at 3.3μm due to CH4 opacity. We attempt to model the planets with thick-cloudy, non-equilibrium chemistry atmospheres but find that removing CH4 to fit the 3.3μm photometry increases the predicted L′ (3.8μm) flux enough that it is inconsistent with observations. In an effort to fit the spectral energy distribution of the HR 8799 planets, we construct mixtures of cloudy atmospheres, which are intended to represent planets covered by clouds of varying opacity. In this scenario, regions with low opacity look hot and bright, while regions with high opacity look faint, similar to the patchy cloud structures on Jupiter and L/T transition brown dwarfs. Our mixed-cloud models reproduce all of the available data, but self-consistent models are still necessary to demonstrate their viability.",
keywords = "Brown dwarfs, Instrumentation: adaptive optics, Planetary systems, Planets and satellites: atmospheres, Stars: individual (HR 8799)",
author = "Skemer, {Andrew J.} and Hinz, {Philip M} and Simone Esposito and Adam Burrows and Jarron Leisenring and Michael Skrutskie and Silvano Desidera and Dino Mesa and Carmelo Arcidiacono and Filippo Mannucci and Rodigas, {Timothy J.} and Close, {Laird M} and Mccarthy, {Donald W} and Craig Kulesa and Guido Agapito and Daniel Apai and Javier Argomedo and Vanessa Bailey and Konstantina Boutsia and Runa Briguglio and Guido Brusa and Lorenzo Busoni and Riccardo Claudi and Eisner, {Joshua A} and Luca Fini and Follette, {Katherine B.} and Peter Garnavich and Raffaele Gratton and Guerra, {Juan Carlos} and Hill, {John M.} and Hoffmann, {William F.} and Terry Jones and Megan Krejny and Jared Males and Elena Masciadri and Meyer, {Michael R.} and Miller, {Douglas L.} and Katie Morzinski and Matthew Nelson and Enrico Pinna and Alfio Puglisi and Quanz, {Sascha P.} and Fernando Quiros-Pacheco and Armando Riccardi and Paolo Stefanini and Vidhya Vaitheeswaran and Wilson, {John C.} and Marco Xompero",
year = "2012",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1088/0004-637X/753/1/14",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "753",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - First light LBT AO images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.6 and 3.3 μm

T2 - New discrepancies between young planets and old brown dwarfs

AU - Skemer, Andrew J.

AU - Hinz, Philip M

AU - Esposito, Simone

AU - Burrows, Adam

AU - Leisenring, Jarron

AU - Skrutskie, Michael

AU - Desidera, Silvano

AU - Mesa, Dino

AU - Arcidiacono, Carmelo

AU - Mannucci, Filippo

AU - Rodigas, Timothy J.

AU - Close, Laird M

AU - Mccarthy, Donald W

AU - Kulesa, Craig

AU - Agapito, Guido

AU - Apai, Daniel

AU - Argomedo, Javier

AU - Bailey, Vanessa

AU - Boutsia, Konstantina

AU - Briguglio, Runa

AU - Brusa, Guido

AU - Busoni, Lorenzo

AU - Claudi, Riccardo

AU - Eisner, Joshua A

AU - Fini, Luca

AU - Follette, Katherine B.

AU - Garnavich, Peter

AU - Gratton, Raffaele

AU - Guerra, Juan Carlos

AU - Hill, John M.

AU - Hoffmann, William F.

AU - Jones, Terry

AU - Krejny, Megan

AU - Males, Jared

AU - Masciadri, Elena

AU - Meyer, Michael R.

AU - Miller, Douglas L.

AU - Morzinski, Katie

AU - Nelson, Matthew

AU - Pinna, Enrico

AU - Puglisi, Alfio

AU - Quanz, Sascha P.

AU - Quiros-Pacheco, Fernando

AU - Riccardi, Armando

AU - Stefanini, Paolo

AU - Vaitheeswaran, Vidhya

AU - Wilson, John C.

AU - Xompero, Marco

PY - 2012/7/1

Y1 - 2012/7/1

N2 - As the only directly imaged multiple planet system, HR 8799 provides a unique opportunity to study the physical properties of several planets in parallel. In this paper, we image all four of the HR 8799 planets at H band and 3.3μm with the new Large Binocular Telescope adaptive optics system, PISCES, and LBTI/LMIRCam. Our images offer an unprecedented view of the system, allowing us to obtain H and 3.3μm photometry of the innermost planet (for the first time) and put strong upper limits on the presence of a hypothetical fifth companion. We find that all four planets are unexpectedly bright at 3.3μm compared to the equilibrium chemistry models used for field brown dwarfs, which predict that planets should be faint at 3.3μm due to CH4 opacity. We attempt to model the planets with thick-cloudy, non-equilibrium chemistry atmospheres but find that removing CH4 to fit the 3.3μm photometry increases the predicted L′ (3.8μm) flux enough that it is inconsistent with observations. In an effort to fit the spectral energy distribution of the HR 8799 planets, we construct mixtures of cloudy atmospheres, which are intended to represent planets covered by clouds of varying opacity. In this scenario, regions with low opacity look hot and bright, while regions with high opacity look faint, similar to the patchy cloud structures on Jupiter and L/T transition brown dwarfs. Our mixed-cloud models reproduce all of the available data, but self-consistent models are still necessary to demonstrate their viability.

AB - As the only directly imaged multiple planet system, HR 8799 provides a unique opportunity to study the physical properties of several planets in parallel. In this paper, we image all four of the HR 8799 planets at H band and 3.3μm with the new Large Binocular Telescope adaptive optics system, PISCES, and LBTI/LMIRCam. Our images offer an unprecedented view of the system, allowing us to obtain H and 3.3μm photometry of the innermost planet (for the first time) and put strong upper limits on the presence of a hypothetical fifth companion. We find that all four planets are unexpectedly bright at 3.3μm compared to the equilibrium chemistry models used for field brown dwarfs, which predict that planets should be faint at 3.3μm due to CH4 opacity. We attempt to model the planets with thick-cloudy, non-equilibrium chemistry atmospheres but find that removing CH4 to fit the 3.3μm photometry increases the predicted L′ (3.8μm) flux enough that it is inconsistent with observations. In an effort to fit the spectral energy distribution of the HR 8799 planets, we construct mixtures of cloudy atmospheres, which are intended to represent planets covered by clouds of varying opacity. In this scenario, regions with low opacity look hot and bright, while regions with high opacity look faint, similar to the patchy cloud structures on Jupiter and L/T transition brown dwarfs. Our mixed-cloud models reproduce all of the available data, but self-consistent models are still necessary to demonstrate their viability.

KW - Brown dwarfs

KW - Instrumentation: adaptive optics

KW - Planetary systems

KW - Planets and satellites: atmospheres

KW - Stars: individual (HR 8799)

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84862546903&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84862546903&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/0004-637X/753/1/14

DO - 10.1088/0004-637X/753/1/14

M3 - Article

VL - 753

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 1

M1 - 14

ER -