Formation and evolution of planetary systems: Upper limits to the gas mass in disks around sun-like stars

Ilaria Pascucci, U. Gorti, D. Hollenbach, J. Najita, M. R. Meyer, J. M. Carpenter, L. A. Hillenbrand, G. J. Herczeg, D. L. Padgett, E. E. Mamajek, M. D. Silverstone, W. M. Schlingman, J. S. Kim, E. B. Stobie, J. Bouwman, S. Wolf, J. Rodmann, D. C. Hines, J. Lunine, Renu Malhotra

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

98 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We have carried out a sensitive search for gas emission lines at IR and millimeter wavelengths for a sample of 15 young Sun-like stars selected from our dust disk survey with Spitzer. We have used mid-IR lines to trace the warm (300-100 K) gas in the inner disk and millimeter transitions of 12CO to probe the cold (∼20 K) outer disk. We report no gas line detections from our sample. Line flux upper limits are first converted to warm and cold gas mass limits using simple approximations allowing a direct comparison with values from the literature. We also present results from more sophisticated models following Gorti & Hollenbach that confirm and extend our simple analysis. These models show that the [S I] 25.23 μm line can set constraining limits on the gas surface density at the disk inner radius and traces disk regions up to a few AU. We find that none of the 15 systems have more than 0.04 MJ of gas within a few AU from the disk inner radius for disk radii from 1 to ∼40 AU. These gas mass upper limits even in the eight systems younger than ∼30 Myr suggest that most of the gas is dispersed early. The gas mass upper limits in the 10-40 AU region, which is mainly traced by our CO data, are <2 M. If these systems are analogs of the solar system, they either have already formed Uranus- and Neptune-like planets or will not form them beyond 100 Myr. Finally, the gas surface density upper limits at 1 AU are smaller than 0.01% of the minimum mass solar nebula for most of the sources. If terrestrial planets form frequently and their orbits are circularized by gas, then circularization occurs early.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1177-1193
Number of pages17
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume651
Issue number2 I
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 10 2006

Fingerprint

planetary systems
sun
stars
gases
gas
radii
planet
Uranus (planet)
solar nebula
Uranus
Neptune (planet)
terrestrial planets
cold gas
Neptune
solar system
dust
probe
analogs
wavelength
orbits

Keywords

  • Circumstellar matter
  • Infrared: stars
  • Planetary systems: formation
  • Solar system: formation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Formation and evolution of planetary systems : Upper limits to the gas mass in disks around sun-like stars. / Pascucci, Ilaria; Gorti, U.; Hollenbach, D.; Najita, J.; Meyer, M. R.; Carpenter, J. M.; Hillenbrand, L. A.; Herczeg, G. J.; Padgett, D. L.; Mamajek, E. E.; Silverstone, M. D.; Schlingman, W. M.; Kim, J. S.; Stobie, E. B.; Bouwman, J.; Wolf, S.; Rodmann, J.; Hines, D. C.; Lunine, J.; Malhotra, Renu.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 651, No. 2 I, 10.11.2006, p. 1177-1193.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Pascucci, I, Gorti, U, Hollenbach, D, Najita, J, Meyer, MR, Carpenter, JM, Hillenbrand, LA, Herczeg, GJ, Padgett, DL, Mamajek, EE, Silverstone, MD, Schlingman, WM, Kim, JS, Stobie, EB, Bouwman, J, Wolf, S, Rodmann, J, Hines, DC, Lunine, J & Malhotra, R 2006, 'Formation and evolution of planetary systems: Upper limits to the gas mass in disks around sun-like stars', Astrophysical Journal, vol. 651, no. 2 I, pp. 1177-1193. https://doi.org/10.1086/507761
Pascucci, Ilaria ; Gorti, U. ; Hollenbach, D. ; Najita, J. ; Meyer, M. R. ; Carpenter, J. M. ; Hillenbrand, L. A. ; Herczeg, G. J. ; Padgett, D. L. ; Mamajek, E. E. ; Silverstone, M. D. ; Schlingman, W. M. ; Kim, J. S. ; Stobie, E. B. ; Bouwman, J. ; Wolf, S. ; Rodmann, J. ; Hines, D. C. ; Lunine, J. ; Malhotra, Renu. / Formation and evolution of planetary systems : Upper limits to the gas mass in disks around sun-like stars. In: Astrophysical Journal. 2006 ; Vol. 651, No. 2 I. pp. 1177-1193.
@article{fd99a891dca14d718a876be692165443,
title = "Formation and evolution of planetary systems: Upper limits to the gas mass in disks around sun-like stars",
abstract = "We have carried out a sensitive search for gas emission lines at IR and millimeter wavelengths for a sample of 15 young Sun-like stars selected from our dust disk survey with Spitzer. We have used mid-IR lines to trace the warm (300-100 K) gas in the inner disk and millimeter transitions of 12CO to probe the cold (∼20 K) outer disk. We report no gas line detections from our sample. Line flux upper limits are first converted to warm and cold gas mass limits using simple approximations allowing a direct comparison with values from the literature. We also present results from more sophisticated models following Gorti & Hollenbach that confirm and extend our simple analysis. These models show that the [S I] 25.23 μm line can set constraining limits on the gas surface density at the disk inner radius and traces disk regions up to a few AU. We find that none of the 15 systems have more than 0.04 MJ of gas within a few AU from the disk inner radius for disk radii from 1 to ∼40 AU. These gas mass upper limits even in the eight systems younger than ∼30 Myr suggest that most of the gas is dispersed early. The gas mass upper limits in the 10-40 AU region, which is mainly traced by our CO data, are <2 M⊕. If these systems are analogs of the solar system, they either have already formed Uranus- and Neptune-like planets or will not form them beyond 100 Myr. Finally, the gas surface density upper limits at 1 AU are smaller than 0.01{\%} of the minimum mass solar nebula for most of the sources. If terrestrial planets form frequently and their orbits are circularized by gas, then circularization occurs early.",
keywords = "Circumstellar matter, Infrared: stars, Planetary systems: formation, Solar system: formation",
author = "Ilaria Pascucci and U. Gorti and D. Hollenbach and J. Najita and Meyer, {M. R.} and Carpenter, {J. M.} and Hillenbrand, {L. A.} and Herczeg, {G. J.} and Padgett, {D. L.} and Mamajek, {E. E.} and Silverstone, {M. D.} and Schlingman, {W. M.} and Kim, {J. S.} and Stobie, {E. B.} and J. Bouwman and S. Wolf and J. Rodmann and Hines, {D. C.} and J. Lunine and Renu Malhotra",
year = "2006",
month = "11",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1086/507761",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "651",
pages = "1177--1193",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "2 I",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Formation and evolution of planetary systems

T2 - Upper limits to the gas mass in disks around sun-like stars

AU - Pascucci, Ilaria

AU - Gorti, U.

AU - Hollenbach, D.

AU - Najita, J.

AU - Meyer, M. R.

AU - Carpenter, J. M.

AU - Hillenbrand, L. A.

AU - Herczeg, G. J.

AU - Padgett, D. L.

AU - Mamajek, E. E.

AU - Silverstone, M. D.

AU - Schlingman, W. M.

AU - Kim, J. S.

AU - Stobie, E. B.

AU - Bouwman, J.

AU - Wolf, S.

AU - Rodmann, J.

AU - Hines, D. C.

AU - Lunine, J.

AU - Malhotra, Renu

PY - 2006/11/10

Y1 - 2006/11/10

N2 - We have carried out a sensitive search for gas emission lines at IR and millimeter wavelengths for a sample of 15 young Sun-like stars selected from our dust disk survey with Spitzer. We have used mid-IR lines to trace the warm (300-100 K) gas in the inner disk and millimeter transitions of 12CO to probe the cold (∼20 K) outer disk. We report no gas line detections from our sample. Line flux upper limits are first converted to warm and cold gas mass limits using simple approximations allowing a direct comparison with values from the literature. We also present results from more sophisticated models following Gorti & Hollenbach that confirm and extend our simple analysis. These models show that the [S I] 25.23 μm line can set constraining limits on the gas surface density at the disk inner radius and traces disk regions up to a few AU. We find that none of the 15 systems have more than 0.04 MJ of gas within a few AU from the disk inner radius for disk radii from 1 to ∼40 AU. These gas mass upper limits even in the eight systems younger than ∼30 Myr suggest that most of the gas is dispersed early. The gas mass upper limits in the 10-40 AU region, which is mainly traced by our CO data, are <2 M⊕. If these systems are analogs of the solar system, they either have already formed Uranus- and Neptune-like planets or will not form them beyond 100 Myr. Finally, the gas surface density upper limits at 1 AU are smaller than 0.01% of the minimum mass solar nebula for most of the sources. If terrestrial planets form frequently and their orbits are circularized by gas, then circularization occurs early.

AB - We have carried out a sensitive search for gas emission lines at IR and millimeter wavelengths for a sample of 15 young Sun-like stars selected from our dust disk survey with Spitzer. We have used mid-IR lines to trace the warm (300-100 K) gas in the inner disk and millimeter transitions of 12CO to probe the cold (∼20 K) outer disk. We report no gas line detections from our sample. Line flux upper limits are first converted to warm and cold gas mass limits using simple approximations allowing a direct comparison with values from the literature. We also present results from more sophisticated models following Gorti & Hollenbach that confirm and extend our simple analysis. These models show that the [S I] 25.23 μm line can set constraining limits on the gas surface density at the disk inner radius and traces disk regions up to a few AU. We find that none of the 15 systems have more than 0.04 MJ of gas within a few AU from the disk inner radius for disk radii from 1 to ∼40 AU. These gas mass upper limits even in the eight systems younger than ∼30 Myr suggest that most of the gas is dispersed early. The gas mass upper limits in the 10-40 AU region, which is mainly traced by our CO data, are <2 M⊕. If these systems are analogs of the solar system, they either have already formed Uranus- and Neptune-like planets or will not form them beyond 100 Myr. Finally, the gas surface density upper limits at 1 AU are smaller than 0.01% of the minimum mass solar nebula for most of the sources. If terrestrial planets form frequently and their orbits are circularized by gas, then circularization occurs early.

KW - Circumstellar matter

KW - Infrared: stars

KW - Planetary systems: formation

KW - Solar system: formation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33845746232&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33845746232&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1086/507761

DO - 10.1086/507761

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:33845746232

VL - 651

SP - 1177

EP - 1193

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 2 I

ER -