Greening Displacements, Displacing Green: Environmental Subjectivity, Slum Clearance, and the Embodied Political Ecologies of Dispossession in Mumbai

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In Indian cities, informal ‘slum’ settlements have long been targeted for removal as an environmental improvement strategy, despite their relatively low impact. Slum clearance has escalated with the combination of speculative development and environmental change, creating uneven precarity throughout Mumbai's neighborhoods. State agents play a direct role in slum evictions, but they do not act unilaterally. Diverse lower-income and middle-class residents seeking better living conditions have sometimes converged in their embrace of slum clearances and resettlements that advance elite development interests. In other moments, the dispossessing effects of market-based and elite-biased slum rehabilitation have fomented contestation. This article analyzes how differently situated groups emerge as ‘environmental subjects’ that embrace or contest improvement projects. It suggests three dimensions of subject formation: governing logics and discourses of urban environmental improvement, the territorial politics of informality, and differentiated embodied experiences of precarity and dispossession. Environmental subject formation is explored through two interventions that entail slum clearance—mangrove and green space conservation and an urban transport infrastructure project. Findings suggest that the connection between displacement and improvement cannot be explained through theories of environmental gentrification but require attention to the simultaneously inclusive and dispossessing regimes of postcolonial development.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalInternational Journal of Urban and Regional Research
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

slum
environmental policy
subjectivity
urban transport
informal settlement
gentrification
environmental change
politics
infrastructure
income
market
elite
resettlement
living conditions
middle class
rehabilitation
political ecology
project
low income
conservation

Keywords

  • development
  • displacement
  • dispossession
  • embodiment
  • environmental subjectivity
  • India
  • Mumbai
  • postcolonial urbanism
  • urban political ecology
  • urban social movements

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Development
  • Sociology and Political Science
  • Urban Studies

Cite this

@article{7f5d5d8a07f54e2fb34812817ca6c3ff,
title = "Greening Displacements, Displacing Green: Environmental Subjectivity, Slum Clearance, and the Embodied Political Ecologies of Dispossession in Mumbai",
abstract = "In Indian cities, informal ‘slum’ settlements have long been targeted for removal as an environmental improvement strategy, despite their relatively low impact. Slum clearance has escalated with the combination of speculative development and environmental change, creating uneven precarity throughout Mumbai's neighborhoods. State agents play a direct role in slum evictions, but they do not act unilaterally. Diverse lower-income and middle-class residents seeking better living conditions have sometimes converged in their embrace of slum clearances and resettlements that advance elite development interests. In other moments, the dispossessing effects of market-based and elite-biased slum rehabilitation have fomented contestation. This article analyzes how differently situated groups emerge as ‘environmental subjects’ that embrace or contest improvement projects. It suggests three dimensions of subject formation: governing logics and discourses of urban environmental improvement, the territorial politics of informality, and differentiated embodied experiences of precarity and dispossession. Environmental subject formation is explored through two interventions that entail slum clearance—mangrove and green space conservation and an urban transport infrastructure project. Findings suggest that the connection between displacement and improvement cannot be explained through theories of environmental gentrification but require attention to the simultaneously inclusive and dispossessing regimes of postcolonial development.",
keywords = "development, displacement, dispossession, embodiment, environmental subjectivity, India, Mumbai, postcolonial urbanism, urban political ecology, urban social movements",
author = "Doshi, {Sapana L D}",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/1468-2427.12699",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "International Journal of Urban and Regional Research",
issn = "0309-1317",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Greening Displacements, Displacing Green

T2 - Environmental Subjectivity, Slum Clearance, and the Embodied Political Ecologies of Dispossession in Mumbai

AU - Doshi, Sapana L D

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - In Indian cities, informal ‘slum’ settlements have long been targeted for removal as an environmental improvement strategy, despite their relatively low impact. Slum clearance has escalated with the combination of speculative development and environmental change, creating uneven precarity throughout Mumbai's neighborhoods. State agents play a direct role in slum evictions, but they do not act unilaterally. Diverse lower-income and middle-class residents seeking better living conditions have sometimes converged in their embrace of slum clearances and resettlements that advance elite development interests. In other moments, the dispossessing effects of market-based and elite-biased slum rehabilitation have fomented contestation. This article analyzes how differently situated groups emerge as ‘environmental subjects’ that embrace or contest improvement projects. It suggests three dimensions of subject formation: governing logics and discourses of urban environmental improvement, the territorial politics of informality, and differentiated embodied experiences of precarity and dispossession. Environmental subject formation is explored through two interventions that entail slum clearance—mangrove and green space conservation and an urban transport infrastructure project. Findings suggest that the connection between displacement and improvement cannot be explained through theories of environmental gentrification but require attention to the simultaneously inclusive and dispossessing regimes of postcolonial development.

AB - In Indian cities, informal ‘slum’ settlements have long been targeted for removal as an environmental improvement strategy, despite their relatively low impact. Slum clearance has escalated with the combination of speculative development and environmental change, creating uneven precarity throughout Mumbai's neighborhoods. State agents play a direct role in slum evictions, but they do not act unilaterally. Diverse lower-income and middle-class residents seeking better living conditions have sometimes converged in their embrace of slum clearances and resettlements that advance elite development interests. In other moments, the dispossessing effects of market-based and elite-biased slum rehabilitation have fomented contestation. This article analyzes how differently situated groups emerge as ‘environmental subjects’ that embrace or contest improvement projects. It suggests three dimensions of subject formation: governing logics and discourses of urban environmental improvement, the territorial politics of informality, and differentiated embodied experiences of precarity and dispossession. Environmental subject formation is explored through two interventions that entail slum clearance—mangrove and green space conservation and an urban transport infrastructure project. Findings suggest that the connection between displacement and improvement cannot be explained through theories of environmental gentrification but require attention to the simultaneously inclusive and dispossessing regimes of postcolonial development.

KW - development

KW - displacement

KW - dispossession

KW - embodiment

KW - environmental subjectivity

KW - India

KW - Mumbai

KW - postcolonial urbanism

KW - urban political ecology

KW - urban social movements

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85056337241&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85056337241&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/1468-2427.12699

DO - 10.1111/1468-2427.12699

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85056337241

JO - International Journal of Urban and Regional Research

JF - International Journal of Urban and Regional Research

SN - 0309-1317

ER -