TY - JOUR

T1 - Impacts of terraces on phylogenetic inference

AU - Sanderson, Michael J.

AU - Mcmahon, Michelle M.

AU - Stamatakis, Alexandros

AU - Zwickl, Derrick J.

AU - Steel, Mike

N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2015.

PY - 2015/9

Y1 - 2015/9

N2 - Terraces are sets of trees with precisely the same likelihood or parsimony score, which can be induced by missing sequences in partitioned multi-locus phylogenetic data matrices. The potentially large set of trees on a terrace can be characterized by enumeration algorithms or consensus methods that exploit the pattern of partial taxon coverage in the data, independent of the sequence data themselves. Terraces can add ambiguity and complexity to phylogenetic inference, particularly in settings where inference is already challenging: data sets withmany taxa and relatively fewloci. In this article we present five newfindings about terraces and their impacts on phylogenetic inference. First,we clarify assumptions about partitioning scheme model parameters that are necessary for the existence of terraces. Second, we explore the dependence of terrace size on partitioning scheme and indicate how to find the partitioning scheme associated with the largest terrace containing a given tree. Third, we highlight the impact of terrace size on bootstrap estimates of confidence limits in clades, and characterize the surprising result that the bootstrap proportion for a clade, as it is usually calculated, can be entirely determined by the frequency of bipartitions on a terrace, with some bipartitions receiving high support even when incorrect. Fourth, we dissect some effects of prior distributions of edge lengths on the computed posterior probabilities of clades on terraces, to understand an example in which long edges "attract" each other in Bayesian inference. Fifth, we describe how assuming relationships between edge-lengths of different loci, as an attempt to avoid terraces, can also be problematic when taxon coverage is partial, specifically when heterotachy is present. Finally, we discuss strategies for remediation of some of these problems. One promising approach finds a minimal set of taxa which, when deleted from the data matrix, reduces the size of a terrace to a single tree.

AB - Terraces are sets of trees with precisely the same likelihood or parsimony score, which can be induced by missing sequences in partitioned multi-locus phylogenetic data matrices. The potentially large set of trees on a terrace can be characterized by enumeration algorithms or consensus methods that exploit the pattern of partial taxon coverage in the data, independent of the sequence data themselves. Terraces can add ambiguity and complexity to phylogenetic inference, particularly in settings where inference is already challenging: data sets withmany taxa and relatively fewloci. In this article we present five newfindings about terraces and their impacts on phylogenetic inference. First,we clarify assumptions about partitioning scheme model parameters that are necessary for the existence of terraces. Second, we explore the dependence of terrace size on partitioning scheme and indicate how to find the partitioning scheme associated with the largest terrace containing a given tree. Third, we highlight the impact of terrace size on bootstrap estimates of confidence limits in clades, and characterize the surprising result that the bootstrap proportion for a clade, as it is usually calculated, can be entirely determined by the frequency of bipartitions on a terrace, with some bipartitions receiving high support even when incorrect. Fourth, we dissect some effects of prior distributions of edge lengths on the computed posterior probabilities of clades on terraces, to understand an example in which long edges "attract" each other in Bayesian inference. Fifth, we describe how assuming relationships between edge-lengths of different loci, as an attempt to avoid terraces, can also be problematic when taxon coverage is partial, specifically when heterotachy is present. Finally, we discuss strategies for remediation of some of these problems. One promising approach finds a minimal set of taxa which, when deleted from the data matrix, reduces the size of a terrace to a single tree.

KW - Bootstrap

KW - Partitioned model

KW - Phylogenetics

KW - Posterior probability

KW - Terrace

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84946918783&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84946918783&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/sysbio/syv024

DO - 10.1093/sysbio/syv024

M3 - Article

C2 - 25999395

AN - SCOPUS:84946918783

VL - 64

SP - 709

EP - 726

JO - Systematic Biology

JF - Systematic Biology

SN - 1063-5157

IS - 5

ER -