Kaposi's sarcoma, vascular permeability, and scientific integrity

Marlys H Witte, Peter Borgs, Dennis L. Way, Michael J Bernas, Geronimo Ramirez, Charles L. Witte

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

On March 13, 1992, Nakamura et al published an article in the journal Science reporting that sulfated polysaccharide peptidoglycan (SP-PG) inhibited the growth and vascular hyperpermeability characteristics of Kaposi's sarcoma-related cells and lesions in nude mice. While examining their key composite Fig 3, A through E, and related Table 2, we were surprised by several photographic features and other irregularities in the figures, which we explored further through a series of experiments. We were unable to confirm some of the pivotal findings. We communicated our concerns to Science but our letter was rejected. After submission of additional analysis, the matter was reopened by Science, but again our correspondence was rejected. Despite extensive review, the salient points raised in our initial correspondence remain unanswered or only tangentially addressed. The original conclusions by Nakamura et al are still not only highly dubious, but the validity of the peer review process and self-correcting nature of scientific inquiry are also called into question.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1769-1771
Number of pages3
JournalJournal of the American Medical Association
Volume271
Issue number22
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 8 1994

Fingerprint

Kaposi's Sarcoma
Capillary Permeability
Peer Review
Peptidoglycan
Nude Mice
Polysaccharides
Blood Vessels
Growth

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Kaposi's sarcoma, vascular permeability, and scientific integrity. / Witte, Marlys H; Borgs, Peter; Way, Dennis L.; Bernas, Michael J; Ramirez, Geronimo; Witte, Charles L.

In: Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol. 271, No. 22, 08.06.1994, p. 1769-1771.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Witte, Marlys H ; Borgs, Peter ; Way, Dennis L. ; Bernas, Michael J ; Ramirez, Geronimo ; Witte, Charles L. / Kaposi's sarcoma, vascular permeability, and scientific integrity. In: Journal of the American Medical Association. 1994 ; Vol. 271, No. 22. pp. 1769-1771.
@article{da23c3037eea492686e3babad0fed42c,
title = "Kaposi's sarcoma, vascular permeability, and scientific integrity",
abstract = "On March 13, 1992, Nakamura et al published an article in the journal Science reporting that sulfated polysaccharide peptidoglycan (SP-PG) inhibited the growth and vascular hyperpermeability characteristics of Kaposi's sarcoma-related cells and lesions in nude mice. While examining their key composite Fig 3, A through E, and related Table 2, we were surprised by several photographic features and other irregularities in the figures, which we explored further through a series of experiments. We were unable to confirm some of the pivotal findings. We communicated our concerns to Science but our letter was rejected. After submission of additional analysis, the matter was reopened by Science, but again our correspondence was rejected. Despite extensive review, the salient points raised in our initial correspondence remain unanswered or only tangentially addressed. The original conclusions by Nakamura et al are still not only highly dubious, but the validity of the peer review process and self-correcting nature of scientific inquiry are also called into question.",
author = "Witte, {Marlys H} and Peter Borgs and Way, {Dennis L.} and Bernas, {Michael J} and Geronimo Ramirez and Witte, {Charles L.}",
year = "1994",
month = "6",
day = "8",
doi = "10.1001/jama.271.22.1769",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "271",
pages = "1769--1771",
journal = "JAMA - Journal of the American Medical Association",
issn = "0002-9955",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "22",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Kaposi's sarcoma, vascular permeability, and scientific integrity

AU - Witte, Marlys H

AU - Borgs, Peter

AU - Way, Dennis L.

AU - Bernas, Michael J

AU - Ramirez, Geronimo

AU - Witte, Charles L.

PY - 1994/6/8

Y1 - 1994/6/8

N2 - On March 13, 1992, Nakamura et al published an article in the journal Science reporting that sulfated polysaccharide peptidoglycan (SP-PG) inhibited the growth and vascular hyperpermeability characteristics of Kaposi's sarcoma-related cells and lesions in nude mice. While examining their key composite Fig 3, A through E, and related Table 2, we were surprised by several photographic features and other irregularities in the figures, which we explored further through a series of experiments. We were unable to confirm some of the pivotal findings. We communicated our concerns to Science but our letter was rejected. After submission of additional analysis, the matter was reopened by Science, but again our correspondence was rejected. Despite extensive review, the salient points raised in our initial correspondence remain unanswered or only tangentially addressed. The original conclusions by Nakamura et al are still not only highly dubious, but the validity of the peer review process and self-correcting nature of scientific inquiry are also called into question.

AB - On March 13, 1992, Nakamura et al published an article in the journal Science reporting that sulfated polysaccharide peptidoglycan (SP-PG) inhibited the growth and vascular hyperpermeability characteristics of Kaposi's sarcoma-related cells and lesions in nude mice. While examining their key composite Fig 3, A through E, and related Table 2, we were surprised by several photographic features and other irregularities in the figures, which we explored further through a series of experiments. We were unable to confirm some of the pivotal findings. We communicated our concerns to Science but our letter was rejected. After submission of additional analysis, the matter was reopened by Science, but again our correspondence was rejected. Despite extensive review, the salient points raised in our initial correspondence remain unanswered or only tangentially addressed. The original conclusions by Nakamura et al are still not only highly dubious, but the validity of the peer review process and self-correcting nature of scientific inquiry are also called into question.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0028305770&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0028305770&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1001/jama.271.22.1769

DO - 10.1001/jama.271.22.1769

M3 - Article

VL - 271

SP - 1769

EP - 1771

JO - JAMA - Journal of the American Medical Association

JF - JAMA - Journal of the American Medical Association

SN - 0002-9955

IS - 22

ER -