Keeping up alliances: multifaceted values of pottery in eighth- to seventeenth-century eastern Botswana as reconstructed by optical petrography

Edwin Wilmsen, David Killick, James Denbow, Adrianne Daggett, Phenyo Thebe

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Many sites with Zhizo, Leopard's Kopje and Khami pottery have been identified around the southern and eastern margins of Sowa Pan, eastern Botswana. This paper presents results of the analysis of sherds from the three largest such sites — Kaitshàa, Thabadimasego, Tora Nju — plus clay from 39 geological deposits. Sherd fabrics identified by optical petrography reveal that pots were made of clays from several lithological terrains. This suggests associations with other sites. We demonstrate a north-south axis of pottery vessel movements — and thus of people — beginning about AD 900–1000 and extending from sites in the Chobe-Zambezi waterveld along Sowa Pan to Kaitshàa and onward to the Kalahari margins at Bosutswe; a later east-west axis connected Tora Nju with Bosutswe and the Khami regional centre at Domboshaba. Identical sherd fabrics, plus specific vessel design parallels, firmly establish the existence of alliances between these sites. This entailed a network of affiliations between potters whereby each preserved their own socially relevant precepts of potting, including potter-ancestor dynamics, while adapting alterations in new contexts of potting praxis. Sherds should thus be seen in terms of alliances rather than as an indicator merely of commodity-exchange. Our study demonstrates, on the basis of vessel fabric rather than of decorative data, that such interactions routinely took place in Botswana from Zhizo times onward. This paper therefore adds independent insights into studies of social alliance maintenance and pottery style syncretism in pre-colonial southern Africa.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)369-408
Number of pages40
JournalAzania
Volume54
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 3 2019

Fingerprint

Botswana
seventeenth century
syncretism
Southern Africa
commodity
Values
interaction
Alliances
Optical
Petrography
Pottery
time
Vessel

Keywords

  • Botswana
  • Iron Age
  • optical petrography
  • pottery
  • site social relationships

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Archaeology
  • Archaeology

Cite this

Keeping up alliances : multifaceted values of pottery in eighth- to seventeenth-century eastern Botswana as reconstructed by optical petrography. / Wilmsen, Edwin; Killick, David; Denbow, James; Daggett, Adrianne; Thebe, Phenyo.

In: Azania, Vol. 54, No. 3, 03.07.2019, p. 369-408.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wilmsen, Edwin ; Killick, David ; Denbow, James ; Daggett, Adrianne ; Thebe, Phenyo. / Keeping up alliances : multifaceted values of pottery in eighth- to seventeenth-century eastern Botswana as reconstructed by optical petrography. In: Azania. 2019 ; Vol. 54, No. 3. pp. 369-408.
@article{750faca918754e75abcd8a3966cfbdda,
title = "Keeping up alliances: multifaceted values of pottery in eighth- to seventeenth-century eastern Botswana as reconstructed by optical petrography",
abstract = "Many sites with Zhizo, Leopard's Kopje and Khami pottery have been identified around the southern and eastern margins of Sowa Pan, eastern Botswana. This paper presents results of the analysis of sherds from the three largest such sites — Kaitsh{\`a}a, Thabadimasego, Tora Nju — plus clay from 39 geological deposits. Sherd fabrics identified by optical petrography reveal that pots were made of clays from several lithological terrains. This suggests associations with other sites. We demonstrate a north-south axis of pottery vessel movements — and thus of people — beginning about AD 900–1000 and extending from sites in the Chobe-Zambezi waterveld along Sowa Pan to Kaitsh{\`a}a and onward to the Kalahari margins at Bosutswe; a later east-west axis connected Tora Nju with Bosutswe and the Khami regional centre at Domboshaba. Identical sherd fabrics, plus specific vessel design parallels, firmly establish the existence of alliances between these sites. This entailed a network of affiliations between potters whereby each preserved their own socially relevant precepts of potting, including potter-ancestor dynamics, while adapting alterations in new contexts of potting praxis. Sherds should thus be seen in terms of alliances rather than as an indicator merely of commodity-exchange. Our study demonstrates, on the basis of vessel fabric rather than of decorative data, that such interactions routinely took place in Botswana from Zhizo times onward. This paper therefore adds independent insights into studies of social alliance maintenance and pottery style syncretism in pre-colonial southern Africa.",
keywords = "Botswana, Iron Age, optical petrography, pottery, site social relationships",
author = "Edwin Wilmsen and David Killick and James Denbow and Adrianne Daggett and Phenyo Thebe",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1080/0067270X.2019.1650523",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "54",
pages = "369--408",
journal = "Azania",
issn = "0067-270X",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Keeping up alliances

T2 - multifaceted values of pottery in eighth- to seventeenth-century eastern Botswana as reconstructed by optical petrography

AU - Wilmsen, Edwin

AU - Killick, David

AU - Denbow, James

AU - Daggett, Adrianne

AU - Thebe, Phenyo

PY - 2019/7/3

Y1 - 2019/7/3

N2 - Many sites with Zhizo, Leopard's Kopje and Khami pottery have been identified around the southern and eastern margins of Sowa Pan, eastern Botswana. This paper presents results of the analysis of sherds from the three largest such sites — Kaitshàa, Thabadimasego, Tora Nju — plus clay from 39 geological deposits. Sherd fabrics identified by optical petrography reveal that pots were made of clays from several lithological terrains. This suggests associations with other sites. We demonstrate a north-south axis of pottery vessel movements — and thus of people — beginning about AD 900–1000 and extending from sites in the Chobe-Zambezi waterveld along Sowa Pan to Kaitshàa and onward to the Kalahari margins at Bosutswe; a later east-west axis connected Tora Nju with Bosutswe and the Khami regional centre at Domboshaba. Identical sherd fabrics, plus specific vessel design parallels, firmly establish the existence of alliances between these sites. This entailed a network of affiliations between potters whereby each preserved their own socially relevant precepts of potting, including potter-ancestor dynamics, while adapting alterations in new contexts of potting praxis. Sherds should thus be seen in terms of alliances rather than as an indicator merely of commodity-exchange. Our study demonstrates, on the basis of vessel fabric rather than of decorative data, that such interactions routinely took place in Botswana from Zhizo times onward. This paper therefore adds independent insights into studies of social alliance maintenance and pottery style syncretism in pre-colonial southern Africa.

AB - Many sites with Zhizo, Leopard's Kopje and Khami pottery have been identified around the southern and eastern margins of Sowa Pan, eastern Botswana. This paper presents results of the analysis of sherds from the three largest such sites — Kaitshàa, Thabadimasego, Tora Nju — plus clay from 39 geological deposits. Sherd fabrics identified by optical petrography reveal that pots were made of clays from several lithological terrains. This suggests associations with other sites. We demonstrate a north-south axis of pottery vessel movements — and thus of people — beginning about AD 900–1000 and extending from sites in the Chobe-Zambezi waterveld along Sowa Pan to Kaitshàa and onward to the Kalahari margins at Bosutswe; a later east-west axis connected Tora Nju with Bosutswe and the Khami regional centre at Domboshaba. Identical sherd fabrics, plus specific vessel design parallels, firmly establish the existence of alliances between these sites. This entailed a network of affiliations between potters whereby each preserved their own socially relevant precepts of potting, including potter-ancestor dynamics, while adapting alterations in new contexts of potting praxis. Sherds should thus be seen in terms of alliances rather than as an indicator merely of commodity-exchange. Our study demonstrates, on the basis of vessel fabric rather than of decorative data, that such interactions routinely took place in Botswana from Zhizo times onward. This paper therefore adds independent insights into studies of social alliance maintenance and pottery style syncretism in pre-colonial southern Africa.

KW - Botswana

KW - Iron Age

KW - optical petrography

KW - pottery

KW - site social relationships

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074192991&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85074192991&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/0067270X.2019.1650523

DO - 10.1080/0067270X.2019.1650523

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85074192991

VL - 54

SP - 369

EP - 408

JO - Azania

JF - Azania

SN - 0067-270X

IS - 3

ER -