Large-scale mantle metasomatism: A Re-Os perspective

John Chesley, Kevin Righter, Joaquin Ruiz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

65 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

There is a debate on the behavior of Re and Os during mantle metasomatism. Some argue that the mantle can acquire high 187Os/188Os (0.15 to >1.0) either directly from metasomatic events or by the growth of 187Os from 187Re over time. However, any suggestions of subduction-related Os metasomatism producing whole-scale elevation of the mantle to 187Os/188Os values greater than 0.15 need to be supported by comparisons of increased Re and Os concentrations and isotopic ratios, with like and consistent increases in elements (i.e., Ba, B, Rb) and isotopic ratios (i.e., Nd, Pb, Sr) known to be affected by metasomatic processes. All of the samples in the literature, either xenoliths or minerals (sulfides, pyroxene, phlogopite or amphibole) that are thought to represent the products of mantle metasomatism, follow a clear correlation of increasing Re/Os with decreasing Os concentration. This inverse correlation requires enrichment in Os concentrations in the metasomatizing agent by two to four orders of magnitude relative to the original subduction component in order to substantially elevate 187Os/188Os, eliminating sediment or slab melts as an effective metasomatic component. To date there is no evidence to support conclusions that Os metasomatism, either directly or by a two-stage process involving Re metasomatism and 187Os growth over time, will substantially change the 187Os/188Os of the mantle to values >0.15. When other isotopic systems are considered along with Os, in metasomatism-based models, these models are not plausible. Consequently, large-scale mantle melts should reflect near-chondritic values. The recognition of the robustness of the Re-Os system will allow for the discrimination of different mantle and crustal reservoirs involved in magmatic processes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)49-60
Number of pages12
JournalEarth and Planetary Science Letters
Volume219
Issue number1-2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 28 2004

Fingerprint

metasomatism
Earth mantle
Amphibole Asbestos
mantle
Sulfide minerals
Sediments
isotopic ratio
subduction
melt
amphiboles
phlogopite
pyroxene
amphibole
suggestion
discrimination
sulfides
slab
sediments
slabs
minerals

Keywords

  • Mantle melt
  • Metasomatism
  • Osmium
  • Rhenium
  • Subduction fluids

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geochemistry and Petrology
  • Geophysics

Cite this

Large-scale mantle metasomatism : A Re-Os perspective. / Chesley, John; Righter, Kevin; Ruiz, Joaquin.

In: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, Vol. 219, No. 1-2, 28.02.2004, p. 49-60.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Chesley, John ; Righter, Kevin ; Ruiz, Joaquin. / Large-scale mantle metasomatism : A Re-Os perspective. In: Earth and Planetary Science Letters. 2004 ; Vol. 219, No. 1-2. pp. 49-60.
@article{7a5d338277544b32a1ba52d69278f949,
title = "Large-scale mantle metasomatism: A Re-Os perspective",
abstract = "There is a debate on the behavior of Re and Os during mantle metasomatism. Some argue that the mantle can acquire high 187Os/188Os (0.15 to >1.0) either directly from metasomatic events or by the growth of 187Os from 187Re over time. However, any suggestions of subduction-related Os metasomatism producing whole-scale elevation of the mantle to 187Os/188Os values greater than 0.15 need to be supported by comparisons of increased Re and Os concentrations and isotopic ratios, with like and consistent increases in elements (i.e., Ba, B, Rb) and isotopic ratios (i.e., Nd, Pb, Sr) known to be affected by metasomatic processes. All of the samples in the literature, either xenoliths or minerals (sulfides, pyroxene, phlogopite or amphibole) that are thought to represent the products of mantle metasomatism, follow a clear correlation of increasing Re/Os with decreasing Os concentration. This inverse correlation requires enrichment in Os concentrations in the metasomatizing agent by two to four orders of magnitude relative to the original subduction component in order to substantially elevate 187Os/188Os, eliminating sediment or slab melts as an effective metasomatic component. To date there is no evidence to support conclusions that Os metasomatism, either directly or by a two-stage process involving Re metasomatism and 187Os growth over time, will substantially change the 187Os/188Os of the mantle to values >0.15. When other isotopic systems are considered along with Os, in metasomatism-based models, these models are not plausible. Consequently, large-scale mantle melts should reflect near-chondritic values. The recognition of the robustness of the Re-Os system will allow for the discrimination of different mantle and crustal reservoirs involved in magmatic processes.",
keywords = "Mantle melt, Metasomatism, Osmium, Rhenium, Subduction fluids",
author = "John Chesley and Kevin Righter and Joaquin Ruiz",
year = "2004",
month = "2",
day = "28",
doi = "10.1016/S0012-821X(03)00698-8",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "219",
pages = "49--60",
journal = "Earth and Planetary Sciences Letters",
issn = "0012-821X",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Large-scale mantle metasomatism

T2 - A Re-Os perspective

AU - Chesley, John

AU - Righter, Kevin

AU - Ruiz, Joaquin

PY - 2004/2/28

Y1 - 2004/2/28

N2 - There is a debate on the behavior of Re and Os during mantle metasomatism. Some argue that the mantle can acquire high 187Os/188Os (0.15 to >1.0) either directly from metasomatic events or by the growth of 187Os from 187Re over time. However, any suggestions of subduction-related Os metasomatism producing whole-scale elevation of the mantle to 187Os/188Os values greater than 0.15 need to be supported by comparisons of increased Re and Os concentrations and isotopic ratios, with like and consistent increases in elements (i.e., Ba, B, Rb) and isotopic ratios (i.e., Nd, Pb, Sr) known to be affected by metasomatic processes. All of the samples in the literature, either xenoliths or minerals (sulfides, pyroxene, phlogopite or amphibole) that are thought to represent the products of mantle metasomatism, follow a clear correlation of increasing Re/Os with decreasing Os concentration. This inverse correlation requires enrichment in Os concentrations in the metasomatizing agent by two to four orders of magnitude relative to the original subduction component in order to substantially elevate 187Os/188Os, eliminating sediment or slab melts as an effective metasomatic component. To date there is no evidence to support conclusions that Os metasomatism, either directly or by a two-stage process involving Re metasomatism and 187Os growth over time, will substantially change the 187Os/188Os of the mantle to values >0.15. When other isotopic systems are considered along with Os, in metasomatism-based models, these models are not plausible. Consequently, large-scale mantle melts should reflect near-chondritic values. The recognition of the robustness of the Re-Os system will allow for the discrimination of different mantle and crustal reservoirs involved in magmatic processes.

AB - There is a debate on the behavior of Re and Os during mantle metasomatism. Some argue that the mantle can acquire high 187Os/188Os (0.15 to >1.0) either directly from metasomatic events or by the growth of 187Os from 187Re over time. However, any suggestions of subduction-related Os metasomatism producing whole-scale elevation of the mantle to 187Os/188Os values greater than 0.15 need to be supported by comparisons of increased Re and Os concentrations and isotopic ratios, with like and consistent increases in elements (i.e., Ba, B, Rb) and isotopic ratios (i.e., Nd, Pb, Sr) known to be affected by metasomatic processes. All of the samples in the literature, either xenoliths or minerals (sulfides, pyroxene, phlogopite or amphibole) that are thought to represent the products of mantle metasomatism, follow a clear correlation of increasing Re/Os with decreasing Os concentration. This inverse correlation requires enrichment in Os concentrations in the metasomatizing agent by two to four orders of magnitude relative to the original subduction component in order to substantially elevate 187Os/188Os, eliminating sediment or slab melts as an effective metasomatic component. To date there is no evidence to support conclusions that Os metasomatism, either directly or by a two-stage process involving Re metasomatism and 187Os growth over time, will substantially change the 187Os/188Os of the mantle to values >0.15. When other isotopic systems are considered along with Os, in metasomatism-based models, these models are not plausible. Consequently, large-scale mantle melts should reflect near-chondritic values. The recognition of the robustness of the Re-Os system will allow for the discrimination of different mantle and crustal reservoirs involved in magmatic processes.

KW - Mantle melt

KW - Metasomatism

KW - Osmium

KW - Rhenium

KW - Subduction fluids

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=1342331847&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=1342331847&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S0012-821X(03)00698-8

DO - 10.1016/S0012-821X(03)00698-8

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:1342331847

VL - 219

SP - 49

EP - 60

JO - Earth and Planetary Sciences Letters

JF - Earth and Planetary Sciences Letters

SN - 0012-821X

IS - 1-2

ER -