Moral disorder in the DSM-IV? The Cluster B Personality Disorders

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Psychiatry has often been accused of 'medicalizing morals.' The DSM-IV's inclusion of the Cluster B Personality Disorders (Antisocial, Borderline, Histrionic, and Narcissistic) might seem to lend credence to this charge. Bioethicist Louis Charland and physicianphilosopher Carl Elliott would likely concur. Whereas Charland argues that the Cluster B disorders are 'moral rather than medical' conditions, that they are genuine 'illnesses' is an idea that, according to Elliott, 'should give us pause.' Although the intuitions captured in the arguments of Charland and Elliott are undeniably strong, the arguments themselves are rather weak. In responding to these arguments, I defend the view that the Cluster B Personality Disorders are 'fundamentally mental' and only 'contingently moral.' They are genuine mental disorders, rightly included in the DSM, whose symptoms consist largely of morally disvalued traits.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)203-215
Number of pages13
JournalPhilosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology
Volume20
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Ethicists
Intuition
Antisocial Personality Disorder
Borderline Personality Disorder
Personality Disorders
Mental Disorders
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
Psychiatry

Keywords

  • Carl Elliott
  • Louis Charland
  • Medicalization of morals
  • Mental disorder

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Philosophy
  • Ecology
  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

Moral disorder in the DSM-IV? The Cluster B Personality Disorders. / Reimer, Margaret -.

In: Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology, Vol. 20, No. 3, 2013, p. 203-215.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1de526b982a9462583b328818afa56de,
title = "Moral disorder in the DSM-IV? The Cluster B Personality Disorders",
abstract = "Psychiatry has often been accused of 'medicalizing morals.' The DSM-IV's inclusion of the Cluster B Personality Disorders (Antisocial, Borderline, Histrionic, and Narcissistic) might seem to lend credence to this charge. Bioethicist Louis Charland and physicianphilosopher Carl Elliott would likely concur. Whereas Charland argues that the Cluster B disorders are 'moral rather than medical' conditions, that they are genuine 'illnesses' is an idea that, according to Elliott, 'should give us pause.' Although the intuitions captured in the arguments of Charland and Elliott are undeniably strong, the arguments themselves are rather weak. In responding to these arguments, I defend the view that the Cluster B Personality Disorders are 'fundamentally mental' and only 'contingently moral.' They are genuine mental disorders, rightly included in the DSM, whose symptoms consist largely of morally disvalued traits.",
keywords = "Carl Elliott, Louis Charland, Medicalization of morals, Mental disorder",
author = "Reimer, {Margaret -}",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1353/ppp.2013.0034",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "20",
pages = "203--215",
journal = "Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology",
issn = "1071-6076",
publisher = "Johns Hopkins University Press",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Moral disorder in the DSM-IV? The Cluster B Personality Disorders

AU - Reimer, Margaret -

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Psychiatry has often been accused of 'medicalizing morals.' The DSM-IV's inclusion of the Cluster B Personality Disorders (Antisocial, Borderline, Histrionic, and Narcissistic) might seem to lend credence to this charge. Bioethicist Louis Charland and physicianphilosopher Carl Elliott would likely concur. Whereas Charland argues that the Cluster B disorders are 'moral rather than medical' conditions, that they are genuine 'illnesses' is an idea that, according to Elliott, 'should give us pause.' Although the intuitions captured in the arguments of Charland and Elliott are undeniably strong, the arguments themselves are rather weak. In responding to these arguments, I defend the view that the Cluster B Personality Disorders are 'fundamentally mental' and only 'contingently moral.' They are genuine mental disorders, rightly included in the DSM, whose symptoms consist largely of morally disvalued traits.

AB - Psychiatry has often been accused of 'medicalizing morals.' The DSM-IV's inclusion of the Cluster B Personality Disorders (Antisocial, Borderline, Histrionic, and Narcissistic) might seem to lend credence to this charge. Bioethicist Louis Charland and physicianphilosopher Carl Elliott would likely concur. Whereas Charland argues that the Cluster B disorders are 'moral rather than medical' conditions, that they are genuine 'illnesses' is an idea that, according to Elliott, 'should give us pause.' Although the intuitions captured in the arguments of Charland and Elliott are undeniably strong, the arguments themselves are rather weak. In responding to these arguments, I defend the view that the Cluster B Personality Disorders are 'fundamentally mental' and only 'contingently moral.' They are genuine mental disorders, rightly included in the DSM, whose symptoms consist largely of morally disvalued traits.

KW - Carl Elliott

KW - Louis Charland

KW - Medicalization of morals

KW - Mental disorder

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84897407710&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84897407710&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1353/ppp.2013.0034

DO - 10.1353/ppp.2013.0034

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84897407710

VL - 20

SP - 203

EP - 215

JO - Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology

JF - Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology

SN - 1071-6076

IS - 3

ER -