Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates

Vlad K. Kumirov, Emily M. Dykstra, Branwen M. Hall, William J. Anderson, Taylor N. Szyszka, Matthew Hj Cordes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

New protein folds may evolve from existing folds through metamorphic evolution involving a dramatic switch in structure. To mimic pathways by which amino acid sequence changes could induce a change in fold, we designed two folded hybrids of Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6, a pair of homologous Cro protein sequences with ~40% identity but different folds (all-α vs. α + β, respectively). Each hybrid, XPH1 or XPH2, is 85% identical in sequence to its parent, Xfaso 1 or Pfl 6, respectively; 55% identical to its noncognate parent; and ~70% identical to the other hybrid. XPH1 and XPH2 also feature a designed hybrid chameleon sequence corresponding to the C-terminal region, which switched from α-helical to β-sheet structure during Cro evolution. We report solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structures of XPH1 and XPH2 at 0.3 Å and 0.5 Å backbone root mean square deviation (RMSD), respectively. XPH1 retains a global fold generally similar to Xfaso 1, and XPH2 retains a fold similar to Pfl 6, as measured by TM-align scores (~0.7), DALI Z-scores (7-9), and backbone RMSD (2–3 Å RMSD for the most ordered regions). However, these scores also indicate significant deviations in structure. Most notably, XPH1 and XPH2 have different, and intermediate, secondary structure content relative to Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6. The multistep progression in sequence, from Xfaso 1 to XPH1 to XPH2 to Pfl 6, thus involves both abrupt and gradual changes in folding pattern. The plasticity of some protein folds may allow for “polymetamorphic” evolution through intermediate structures.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1767-1779
Number of pages13
JournalProtein Science
Volume27
Issue number10
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 1 2018

Fingerprint

Proteins
Lizards
Plasticity
Switches
Nuclear magnetic resonance
Amino Acids
Amino Acid Sequence
Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Keywords

  • chimera
  • folding specificity
  • hybrid sequence
  • metamorphic protein
  • NMR spectroscopy
  • Structural evolution

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry
  • Molecular Biology

Cite this

Kumirov, V. K., Dykstra, E. M., Hall, B. M., Anderson, W. J., Szyszka, T. N., & Cordes, M. H. (2018). Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates. Protein Science, 27(10), 1767-1779. https://doi.org/10.1002/pro.3488

Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates. / Kumirov, Vlad K.; Dykstra, Emily M.; Hall, Branwen M.; Anderson, William J.; Szyszka, Taylor N.; Cordes, Matthew Hj.

In: Protein Science, Vol. 27, No. 10, 01.10.2018, p. 1767-1779.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kumirov, VK, Dykstra, EM, Hall, BM, Anderson, WJ, Szyszka, TN & Cordes, MH 2018, 'Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates', Protein Science, vol. 27, no. 10, pp. 1767-1779. https://doi.org/10.1002/pro.3488
Kumirov, Vlad K. ; Dykstra, Emily M. ; Hall, Branwen M. ; Anderson, William J. ; Szyszka, Taylor N. ; Cordes, Matthew Hj. / Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates. In: Protein Science. 2018 ; Vol. 27, No. 10. pp. 1767-1779.
@article{3d721453a10843c8a898feb69fbdd74e,
title = "Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates",
abstract = "New protein folds may evolve from existing folds through metamorphic evolution involving a dramatic switch in structure. To mimic pathways by which amino acid sequence changes could induce a change in fold, we designed two folded hybrids of Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6, a pair of homologous Cro protein sequences with ~40{\%} identity but different folds (all-α vs. α + β, respectively). Each hybrid, XPH1 or XPH2, is 85{\%} identical in sequence to its parent, Xfaso 1 or Pfl 6, respectively; 55{\%} identical to its noncognate parent; and ~70{\%} identical to the other hybrid. XPH1 and XPH2 also feature a designed hybrid chameleon sequence corresponding to the C-terminal region, which switched from α-helical to β-sheet structure during Cro evolution. We report solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structures of XPH1 and XPH2 at 0.3 {\AA} and 0.5 {\AA} backbone root mean square deviation (RMSD), respectively. XPH1 retains a global fold generally similar to Xfaso 1, and XPH2 retains a fold similar to Pfl 6, as measured by TM-align scores (~0.7), DALI Z-scores (7-9), and backbone RMSD (2–3 {\AA} RMSD for the most ordered regions). However, these scores also indicate significant deviations in structure. Most notably, XPH1 and XPH2 have different, and intermediate, secondary structure content relative to Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6. The multistep progression in sequence, from Xfaso 1 to XPH1 to XPH2 to Pfl 6, thus involves both abrupt and gradual changes in folding pattern. The plasticity of some protein folds may allow for “polymetamorphic” evolution through intermediate structures.",
keywords = "chimera, folding specificity, hybrid sequence, metamorphic protein, NMR spectroscopy, Structural evolution",
author = "Kumirov, {Vlad K.} and Dykstra, {Emily M.} and Hall, {Branwen M.} and Anderson, {William J.} and Szyszka, {Taylor N.} and Cordes, {Matthew Hj}",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/pro.3488",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "27",
pages = "1767--1779",
journal = "Protein Science",
issn = "0961-8368",
publisher = "Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Multistep mutational transformation of a protein fold through structural intermediates

AU - Kumirov, Vlad K.

AU - Dykstra, Emily M.

AU - Hall, Branwen M.

AU - Anderson, William J.

AU - Szyszka, Taylor N.

AU - Cordes, Matthew Hj

PY - 2018/10/1

Y1 - 2018/10/1

N2 - New protein folds may evolve from existing folds through metamorphic evolution involving a dramatic switch in structure. To mimic pathways by which amino acid sequence changes could induce a change in fold, we designed two folded hybrids of Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6, a pair of homologous Cro protein sequences with ~40% identity but different folds (all-α vs. α + β, respectively). Each hybrid, XPH1 or XPH2, is 85% identical in sequence to its parent, Xfaso 1 or Pfl 6, respectively; 55% identical to its noncognate parent; and ~70% identical to the other hybrid. XPH1 and XPH2 also feature a designed hybrid chameleon sequence corresponding to the C-terminal region, which switched from α-helical to β-sheet structure during Cro evolution. We report solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structures of XPH1 and XPH2 at 0.3 Å and 0.5 Å backbone root mean square deviation (RMSD), respectively. XPH1 retains a global fold generally similar to Xfaso 1, and XPH2 retains a fold similar to Pfl 6, as measured by TM-align scores (~0.7), DALI Z-scores (7-9), and backbone RMSD (2–3 Å RMSD for the most ordered regions). However, these scores also indicate significant deviations in structure. Most notably, XPH1 and XPH2 have different, and intermediate, secondary structure content relative to Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6. The multistep progression in sequence, from Xfaso 1 to XPH1 to XPH2 to Pfl 6, thus involves both abrupt and gradual changes in folding pattern. The plasticity of some protein folds may allow for “polymetamorphic” evolution through intermediate structures.

AB - New protein folds may evolve from existing folds through metamorphic evolution involving a dramatic switch in structure. To mimic pathways by which amino acid sequence changes could induce a change in fold, we designed two folded hybrids of Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6, a pair of homologous Cro protein sequences with ~40% identity but different folds (all-α vs. α + β, respectively). Each hybrid, XPH1 or XPH2, is 85% identical in sequence to its parent, Xfaso 1 or Pfl 6, respectively; 55% identical to its noncognate parent; and ~70% identical to the other hybrid. XPH1 and XPH2 also feature a designed hybrid chameleon sequence corresponding to the C-terminal region, which switched from α-helical to β-sheet structure during Cro evolution. We report solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structures of XPH1 and XPH2 at 0.3 Å and 0.5 Å backbone root mean square deviation (RMSD), respectively. XPH1 retains a global fold generally similar to Xfaso 1, and XPH2 retains a fold similar to Pfl 6, as measured by TM-align scores (~0.7), DALI Z-scores (7-9), and backbone RMSD (2–3 Å RMSD for the most ordered regions). However, these scores also indicate significant deviations in structure. Most notably, XPH1 and XPH2 have different, and intermediate, secondary structure content relative to Xfaso 1 and Pfl 6. The multistep progression in sequence, from Xfaso 1 to XPH1 to XPH2 to Pfl 6, thus involves both abrupt and gradual changes in folding pattern. The plasticity of some protein folds may allow for “polymetamorphic” evolution through intermediate structures.

KW - chimera

KW - folding specificity

KW - hybrid sequence

KW - metamorphic protein

KW - NMR spectroscopy

KW - Structural evolution

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85055036997&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85055036997&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/pro.3488

DO - 10.1002/pro.3488

M3 - Article

C2 - 30051937

AN - SCOPUS:85055036997

VL - 27

SP - 1767

EP - 1779

JO - Protein Science

JF - Protein Science

SN - 0961-8368

IS - 10

ER -