On-axis and off-axis viewing of images on CRT displays and LCDs: Observer performance and vision model predictions

Elizabeth A Krupinski, Jeffrey Johnson, Hans Roehrig, John Nafziger, Jeffrey Lubin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

36 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Rationale and Objectives. Although cathode-ray tube (CRT) displays typically are used for softcopy display of radiographs in the digital reading environment, liquid crystal displays (LCDs) currently are being used as an alternative. LCDs have many desirable viewing properties compared with a CRT, but significant image degradation can occur with off-axis viewing. This study compares observer performance and predictions from a human visual system model for on-axis and off-axis viewing for CRT displays versus LCDs. Materials and Methods. A set of mammograms with different lesion contrasts (n = 400) were shown to six radiologists on CRT and LCD monitors, once on-axis and once off-axis. Observer performance was measured by using receiver operating characteristic techniques. Performance was correlated with results of a human vision model designed to predict observer performance (just noticeable difference [JND]metrix model). Two approaches were used to generate model metrics; a paired discrimination and channelized model observer approach. Results. The performance of human observers indicated that on-axis viewing with the LCD was better than with the CRT, but off-axis viewing was significantly better with the CRT than LCD (F = 8.8175; P < .0001). The paired discrimination model correctly predicted on-axis, but not off-axis, results. The channelized model observer correctly predicted both on- and off-axis results. Conclusion. Off-axis viewing of radiographic images on an LCD monitor degrades human observer performance significantly compared with a CRT display. Care should be taken in the clinic to avoid off-axis viewing during diagnostic interpretation.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)957-964
Number of pages8
JournalAcademic Radiology
Volume12
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 2005

Fingerprint

Cathode Ray Tube
Liquid Crystals
Differential Threshold
ROC Curve
Reading

Keywords

  • Channelized model observer
  • Digital display
  • Just noticeable difference (JND) metrix
  • Observer performance
  • Off-axis viewing
  • Vision model

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

On-axis and off-axis viewing of images on CRT displays and LCDs : Observer performance and vision model predictions. / Krupinski, Elizabeth A; Johnson, Jeffrey; Roehrig, Hans; Nafziger, John; Lubin, Jeffrey.

In: Academic Radiology, Vol. 12, No. 8, 08.2005, p. 957-964.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Krupinski, Elizabeth A ; Johnson, Jeffrey ; Roehrig, Hans ; Nafziger, John ; Lubin, Jeffrey. / On-axis and off-axis viewing of images on CRT displays and LCDs : Observer performance and vision model predictions. In: Academic Radiology. 2005 ; Vol. 12, No. 8. pp. 957-964.
@article{fc4c0b770ccb4e5eb33e62f2fcb4b236,
title = "On-axis and off-axis viewing of images on CRT displays and LCDs: Observer performance and vision model predictions",
abstract = "Rationale and Objectives. Although cathode-ray tube (CRT) displays typically are used for softcopy display of radiographs in the digital reading environment, liquid crystal displays (LCDs) currently are being used as an alternative. LCDs have many desirable viewing properties compared with a CRT, but significant image degradation can occur with off-axis viewing. This study compares observer performance and predictions from a human visual system model for on-axis and off-axis viewing for CRT displays versus LCDs. Materials and Methods. A set of mammograms with different lesion contrasts (n = 400) were shown to six radiologists on CRT and LCD monitors, once on-axis and once off-axis. Observer performance was measured by using receiver operating characteristic techniques. Performance was correlated with results of a human vision model designed to predict observer performance (just noticeable difference [JND]metrix model). Two approaches were used to generate model metrics; a paired discrimination and channelized model observer approach. Results. The performance of human observers indicated that on-axis viewing with the LCD was better than with the CRT, but off-axis viewing was significantly better with the CRT than LCD (F = 8.8175; P < .0001). The paired discrimination model correctly predicted on-axis, but not off-axis, results. The channelized model observer correctly predicted both on- and off-axis results. Conclusion. Off-axis viewing of radiographic images on an LCD monitor degrades human observer performance significantly compared with a CRT display. Care should be taken in the clinic to avoid off-axis viewing during diagnostic interpretation.",
keywords = "Channelized model observer, Digital display, Just noticeable difference (JND) metrix, Observer performance, Off-axis viewing, Vision model",
author = "Krupinski, {Elizabeth A} and Jeffrey Johnson and Hans Roehrig and John Nafziger and Jeffrey Lubin",
year = "2005",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1016/j.acra.2005.04.015",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "12",
pages = "957--964",
journal = "Academic Radiology",
issn = "1076-6332",
publisher = "Elsevier USA",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - On-axis and off-axis viewing of images on CRT displays and LCDs

T2 - Observer performance and vision model predictions

AU - Krupinski, Elizabeth A

AU - Johnson, Jeffrey

AU - Roehrig, Hans

AU - Nafziger, John

AU - Lubin, Jeffrey

PY - 2005/8

Y1 - 2005/8

N2 - Rationale and Objectives. Although cathode-ray tube (CRT) displays typically are used for softcopy display of radiographs in the digital reading environment, liquid crystal displays (LCDs) currently are being used as an alternative. LCDs have many desirable viewing properties compared with a CRT, but significant image degradation can occur with off-axis viewing. This study compares observer performance and predictions from a human visual system model for on-axis and off-axis viewing for CRT displays versus LCDs. Materials and Methods. A set of mammograms with different lesion contrasts (n = 400) were shown to six radiologists on CRT and LCD monitors, once on-axis and once off-axis. Observer performance was measured by using receiver operating characteristic techniques. Performance was correlated with results of a human vision model designed to predict observer performance (just noticeable difference [JND]metrix model). Two approaches were used to generate model metrics; a paired discrimination and channelized model observer approach. Results. The performance of human observers indicated that on-axis viewing with the LCD was better than with the CRT, but off-axis viewing was significantly better with the CRT than LCD (F = 8.8175; P < .0001). The paired discrimination model correctly predicted on-axis, but not off-axis, results. The channelized model observer correctly predicted both on- and off-axis results. Conclusion. Off-axis viewing of radiographic images on an LCD monitor degrades human observer performance significantly compared with a CRT display. Care should be taken in the clinic to avoid off-axis viewing during diagnostic interpretation.

AB - Rationale and Objectives. Although cathode-ray tube (CRT) displays typically are used for softcopy display of radiographs in the digital reading environment, liquid crystal displays (LCDs) currently are being used as an alternative. LCDs have many desirable viewing properties compared with a CRT, but significant image degradation can occur with off-axis viewing. This study compares observer performance and predictions from a human visual system model for on-axis and off-axis viewing for CRT displays versus LCDs. Materials and Methods. A set of mammograms with different lesion contrasts (n = 400) were shown to six radiologists on CRT and LCD monitors, once on-axis and once off-axis. Observer performance was measured by using receiver operating characteristic techniques. Performance was correlated with results of a human vision model designed to predict observer performance (just noticeable difference [JND]metrix model). Two approaches were used to generate model metrics; a paired discrimination and channelized model observer approach. Results. The performance of human observers indicated that on-axis viewing with the LCD was better than with the CRT, but off-axis viewing was significantly better with the CRT than LCD (F = 8.8175; P < .0001). The paired discrimination model correctly predicted on-axis, but not off-axis, results. The channelized model observer correctly predicted both on- and off-axis results. Conclusion. Off-axis viewing of radiographic images on an LCD monitor degrades human observer performance significantly compared with a CRT display. Care should be taken in the clinic to avoid off-axis viewing during diagnostic interpretation.

KW - Channelized model observer

KW - Digital display

KW - Just noticeable difference (JND) metrix

KW - Observer performance

KW - Off-axis viewing

KW - Vision model

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=23644440256&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=23644440256&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.acra.2005.04.015

DO - 10.1016/j.acra.2005.04.015

M3 - Article

C2 - 16023384

AN - SCOPUS:23644440256

VL - 12

SP - 957

EP - 964

JO - Academic Radiology

JF - Academic Radiology

SN - 1076-6332

IS - 8

ER -