On the morphology and chemical composition of the hr 4796a debris disk

Timothy J. Rodigas, Christopher C. Stark, Alycia Weinberger, John H. Debes, Philip M Hinz, Laird M Close, Christine Chen, Paul S. Smith, Jared R. Males, Andrew J. Skemer, Alfio Puglisi, Katherine B. Follette, Katie Morzinski, Ya Lin Wu, Runa Briguglio, Simone Esposito, Enrico Pinna, Armando Riccardi, Glenn Schneider, Marco Xompero

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We present resolved images of the HR 4796A debris disk using the Magellan adaptive optics system paired with Clio-2 and VisAO. We detect the disk at 0.77μm, 0.91μm, 0.99μm, 2.15μm, 3.1μm, 3.3μm, and 3.8μm. We find that the deprojected center of the ring is offset from the star by 4.76 ?1.6 AU and that the deprojected eccentricity is 0.06 ±0.02, in general agreement with previous studies. We find that the average width of the ring is 14+3 -2% (11.1+2.4 -1.6 AU), also comparable to previous measurements. Combining our new scattered light data with archival Hubble Space Telescope images at ∼0.5-2μm, along with previously unpublished Spitzer/MIPS thermal emission data and all other literature thermal data, we set out to constrain the chemical composition of the dust grains. After testing 19 individual root compositions and more than 8400 unique mixtures of these compositions, we find that good fits to the scattered light alone and thermal emission alone are discrepant, suggesting that caution should be exercised if fitting to only one or the other. When we fit to both data sets simultaneously, we find that silicates and organics are generally the most favored, while large abundances of water ice are usually not favored. These results suggest the HR 4796A dust grains are similar to interstellar dust and solar system comets, though improved modeling is necessary to place better constraints on the exact chemical composition of the dust.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number96
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume798
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 10 2015

Fingerprint

debris
chemical composition
dust
thermal emission
rings
comets
eccentricity
adaptive optics
Hubble Space Telescope
solar system
comet
light emission
silicates
ice
silicate
stars
water
modeling

Keywords

  • circumstellar matter
  • instrumentation: adaptive optics
  • planetary systems
  • stars: individual (HR 4796A)
  • techniques: high angular resolution

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics

Cite this

On the morphology and chemical composition of the hr 4796a debris disk. / Rodigas, Timothy J.; Stark, Christopher C.; Weinberger, Alycia; Debes, John H.; Hinz, Philip M; Close, Laird M; Chen, Christine; Smith, Paul S.; Males, Jared R.; Skemer, Andrew J.; Puglisi, Alfio; Follette, Katherine B.; Morzinski, Katie; Wu, Ya Lin; Briguglio, Runa; Esposito, Simone; Pinna, Enrico; Riccardi, Armando; Schneider, Glenn; Xompero, Marco.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 798, No. 2, 96, 10.01.2015.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Rodigas, TJ, Stark, CC, Weinberger, A, Debes, JH, Hinz, PM, Close, LM, Chen, C, Smith, PS, Males, JR, Skemer, AJ, Puglisi, A, Follette, KB, Morzinski, K, Wu, YL, Briguglio, R, Esposito, S, Pinna, E, Riccardi, A, Schneider, G & Xompero, M 2015, 'On the morphology and chemical composition of the hr 4796a debris disk', Astrophysical Journal, vol. 798, no. 2, 96. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/798/2/96
Rodigas, Timothy J. ; Stark, Christopher C. ; Weinberger, Alycia ; Debes, John H. ; Hinz, Philip M ; Close, Laird M ; Chen, Christine ; Smith, Paul S. ; Males, Jared R. ; Skemer, Andrew J. ; Puglisi, Alfio ; Follette, Katherine B. ; Morzinski, Katie ; Wu, Ya Lin ; Briguglio, Runa ; Esposito, Simone ; Pinna, Enrico ; Riccardi, Armando ; Schneider, Glenn ; Xompero, Marco. / On the morphology and chemical composition of the hr 4796a debris disk. In: Astrophysical Journal. 2015 ; Vol. 798, No. 2.
@article{b20cf8392a6648a8be87d1fc26ecb9b9,
title = "On the morphology and chemical composition of the hr 4796a debris disk",
abstract = "We present resolved images of the HR 4796A debris disk using the Magellan adaptive optics system paired with Clio-2 and VisAO. We detect the disk at 0.77μm, 0.91μm, 0.99μm, 2.15μm, 3.1μm, 3.3μm, and 3.8μm. We find that the deprojected center of the ring is offset from the star by 4.76 ?1.6 AU and that the deprojected eccentricity is 0.06 ±0.02, in general agreement with previous studies. We find that the average width of the ring is 14+3 -2{\%} (11.1+2.4 -1.6 AU), also comparable to previous measurements. Combining our new scattered light data with archival Hubble Space Telescope images at ∼0.5-2μm, along with previously unpublished Spitzer/MIPS thermal emission data and all other literature thermal data, we set out to constrain the chemical composition of the dust grains. After testing 19 individual root compositions and more than 8400 unique mixtures of these compositions, we find that good fits to the scattered light alone and thermal emission alone are discrepant, suggesting that caution should be exercised if fitting to only one or the other. When we fit to both data sets simultaneously, we find that silicates and organics are generally the most favored, while large abundances of water ice are usually not favored. These results suggest the HR 4796A dust grains are similar to interstellar dust and solar system comets, though improved modeling is necessary to place better constraints on the exact chemical composition of the dust.",
keywords = "circumstellar matter, instrumentation: adaptive optics, planetary systems, stars: individual (HR 4796A), techniques: high angular resolution",
author = "Rodigas, {Timothy J.} and Stark, {Christopher C.} and Alycia Weinberger and Debes, {John H.} and Hinz, {Philip M} and Close, {Laird M} and Christine Chen and Smith, {Paul S.} and Males, {Jared R.} and Skemer, {Andrew J.} and Alfio Puglisi and Follette, {Katherine B.} and Katie Morzinski and Wu, {Ya Lin} and Runa Briguglio and Simone Esposito and Enrico Pinna and Armando Riccardi and Glenn Schneider and Marco Xompero",
year = "2015",
month = "1",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1088/0004-637X/798/2/96",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "798",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - On the morphology and chemical composition of the hr 4796a debris disk

AU - Rodigas, Timothy J.

AU - Stark, Christopher C.

AU - Weinberger, Alycia

AU - Debes, John H.

AU - Hinz, Philip M

AU - Close, Laird M

AU - Chen, Christine

AU - Smith, Paul S.

AU - Males, Jared R.

AU - Skemer, Andrew J.

AU - Puglisi, Alfio

AU - Follette, Katherine B.

AU - Morzinski, Katie

AU - Wu, Ya Lin

AU - Briguglio, Runa

AU - Esposito, Simone

AU - Pinna, Enrico

AU - Riccardi, Armando

AU - Schneider, Glenn

AU - Xompero, Marco

PY - 2015/1/10

Y1 - 2015/1/10

N2 - We present resolved images of the HR 4796A debris disk using the Magellan adaptive optics system paired with Clio-2 and VisAO. We detect the disk at 0.77μm, 0.91μm, 0.99μm, 2.15μm, 3.1μm, 3.3μm, and 3.8μm. We find that the deprojected center of the ring is offset from the star by 4.76 ?1.6 AU and that the deprojected eccentricity is 0.06 ±0.02, in general agreement with previous studies. We find that the average width of the ring is 14+3 -2% (11.1+2.4 -1.6 AU), also comparable to previous measurements. Combining our new scattered light data with archival Hubble Space Telescope images at ∼0.5-2μm, along with previously unpublished Spitzer/MIPS thermal emission data and all other literature thermal data, we set out to constrain the chemical composition of the dust grains. After testing 19 individual root compositions and more than 8400 unique mixtures of these compositions, we find that good fits to the scattered light alone and thermal emission alone are discrepant, suggesting that caution should be exercised if fitting to only one or the other. When we fit to both data sets simultaneously, we find that silicates and organics are generally the most favored, while large abundances of water ice are usually not favored. These results suggest the HR 4796A dust grains are similar to interstellar dust and solar system comets, though improved modeling is necessary to place better constraints on the exact chemical composition of the dust.

AB - We present resolved images of the HR 4796A debris disk using the Magellan adaptive optics system paired with Clio-2 and VisAO. We detect the disk at 0.77μm, 0.91μm, 0.99μm, 2.15μm, 3.1μm, 3.3μm, and 3.8μm. We find that the deprojected center of the ring is offset from the star by 4.76 ?1.6 AU and that the deprojected eccentricity is 0.06 ±0.02, in general agreement with previous studies. We find that the average width of the ring is 14+3 -2% (11.1+2.4 -1.6 AU), also comparable to previous measurements. Combining our new scattered light data with archival Hubble Space Telescope images at ∼0.5-2μm, along with previously unpublished Spitzer/MIPS thermal emission data and all other literature thermal data, we set out to constrain the chemical composition of the dust grains. After testing 19 individual root compositions and more than 8400 unique mixtures of these compositions, we find that good fits to the scattered light alone and thermal emission alone are discrepant, suggesting that caution should be exercised if fitting to only one or the other. When we fit to both data sets simultaneously, we find that silicates and organics are generally the most favored, while large abundances of water ice are usually not favored. These results suggest the HR 4796A dust grains are similar to interstellar dust and solar system comets, though improved modeling is necessary to place better constraints on the exact chemical composition of the dust.

KW - circumstellar matter

KW - instrumentation: adaptive optics

KW - planetary systems

KW - stars: individual (HR 4796A)

KW - techniques: high angular resolution

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84924268369&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84924268369&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/0004-637X/798/2/96

DO - 10.1088/0004-637X/798/2/96

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84924268369

VL - 798

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 2

M1 - 96

ER -