Practicing physical geography: An actor-network view of physical geography exemplified by the rock art stability index

Casey D. Allen, Christopher L Lukinbeal

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper explores the use of a new pedagogy, the rock art stability index (RASI), to engender deeper understanding of weathering science concepts by students. Owing to its dynamic nature, RASI represents a quintessential actor network for weathering science, because it links task in the landscape with an active material practice and an alternative materialistic world-view recently called for in positivistic science, to create place. Using concept maps as an assessment tool, 571 college undergraduate students and 13 junior high school integrated science students (ages 12-13) were evaluated for increased learning potential between pre- and post-field experiences. Further, this article demonstrates that when students use RASI to learn the fundamental complex science of weathering they make in-depth connections between weathering form and process not achieved through traditional, positivistic weathering pedagogy. We argue that RASI draws upon inherent actor networks which allow students to link weathering form and process to an animate conceptualization of landscape. Conceptualizing landscape as sentient actor networks removes weathering science disciplinary connections and their inherent pedagogic practices. Our focus in this paper is not to challenge weathering ontology and epistemology, but rather to argue that there is a need for a pedagogical paradigm shift in weathering science.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)227-248
Number of pages22
JournalProgress in Physical Geography
Volume35
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 2011
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

rock art
physical geography
weathering
art
geography
science
student
pedagogics
epistemology
ontology
index
paradigm shift
paradigm
learning
school

Keywords

  • actor-network theory
  • fieldwork
  • philosophy of science
  • RASI
  • rock art stability index
  • weathering pedagogy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Earth and Planetary Sciences(all)
  • Geography, Planning and Development

Cite this

@article{c9c4a01a009242ad8d10616e65c32f41,
title = "Practicing physical geography: An actor-network view of physical geography exemplified by the rock art stability index",
abstract = "This paper explores the use of a new pedagogy, the rock art stability index (RASI), to engender deeper understanding of weathering science concepts by students. Owing to its dynamic nature, RASI represents a quintessential actor network for weathering science, because it links task in the landscape with an active material practice and an alternative materialistic world-view recently called for in positivistic science, to create place. Using concept maps as an assessment tool, 571 college undergraduate students and 13 junior high school integrated science students (ages 12-13) were evaluated for increased learning potential between pre- and post-field experiences. Further, this article demonstrates that when students use RASI to learn the fundamental complex science of weathering they make in-depth connections between weathering form and process not achieved through traditional, positivistic weathering pedagogy. We argue that RASI draws upon inherent actor networks which allow students to link weathering form and process to an animate conceptualization of landscape. Conceptualizing landscape as sentient actor networks removes weathering science disciplinary connections and their inherent pedagogic practices. Our focus in this paper is not to challenge weathering ontology and epistemology, but rather to argue that there is a need for a pedagogical paradigm shift in weathering science.",
keywords = "actor-network theory, fieldwork, philosophy of science, RASI, rock art stability index, weathering pedagogy",
author = "Allen, {Casey D.} and Lukinbeal, {Christopher L}",
year = "2011",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1177/0309133310364929",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "35",
pages = "227--248",
journal = "Progress in Physical Geography",
issn = "0309-1333",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Practicing physical geography

T2 - An actor-network view of physical geography exemplified by the rock art stability index

AU - Allen, Casey D.

AU - Lukinbeal, Christopher L

PY - 2011/4

Y1 - 2011/4

N2 - This paper explores the use of a new pedagogy, the rock art stability index (RASI), to engender deeper understanding of weathering science concepts by students. Owing to its dynamic nature, RASI represents a quintessential actor network for weathering science, because it links task in the landscape with an active material practice and an alternative materialistic world-view recently called for in positivistic science, to create place. Using concept maps as an assessment tool, 571 college undergraduate students and 13 junior high school integrated science students (ages 12-13) were evaluated for increased learning potential between pre- and post-field experiences. Further, this article demonstrates that when students use RASI to learn the fundamental complex science of weathering they make in-depth connections between weathering form and process not achieved through traditional, positivistic weathering pedagogy. We argue that RASI draws upon inherent actor networks which allow students to link weathering form and process to an animate conceptualization of landscape. Conceptualizing landscape as sentient actor networks removes weathering science disciplinary connections and their inherent pedagogic practices. Our focus in this paper is not to challenge weathering ontology and epistemology, but rather to argue that there is a need for a pedagogical paradigm shift in weathering science.

AB - This paper explores the use of a new pedagogy, the rock art stability index (RASI), to engender deeper understanding of weathering science concepts by students. Owing to its dynamic nature, RASI represents a quintessential actor network for weathering science, because it links task in the landscape with an active material practice and an alternative materialistic world-view recently called for in positivistic science, to create place. Using concept maps as an assessment tool, 571 college undergraduate students and 13 junior high school integrated science students (ages 12-13) were evaluated for increased learning potential between pre- and post-field experiences. Further, this article demonstrates that when students use RASI to learn the fundamental complex science of weathering they make in-depth connections between weathering form and process not achieved through traditional, positivistic weathering pedagogy. We argue that RASI draws upon inherent actor networks which allow students to link weathering form and process to an animate conceptualization of landscape. Conceptualizing landscape as sentient actor networks removes weathering science disciplinary connections and their inherent pedagogic practices. Our focus in this paper is not to challenge weathering ontology and epistemology, but rather to argue that there is a need for a pedagogical paradigm shift in weathering science.

KW - actor-network theory

KW - fieldwork

KW - philosophy of science

KW - RASI

KW - rock art stability index

KW - weathering pedagogy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79953238207&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79953238207&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0309133310364929

DO - 10.1177/0309133310364929

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:79953238207

VL - 35

SP - 227

EP - 248

JO - Progress in Physical Geography

JF - Progress in Physical Geography

SN - 0309-1333

IS - 2

ER -