Reconciliation of diverse telepathology system designs. Historic issues and implications for emerging markets and new applications

Ronald S Weinstein, Anna R. Graham, Fangru Lian, Beth L. Braunhut, Gail P Barker, Elizabeth A Krupinski, Achyut K Bhattacharyya

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

27 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Telepathology, the distant service component of digital pathology, is a growth industry. The word "telepathology" was introduced into the English Language in 1986. Initially, two different, competing imaging modalities were used for telepathology. These were dynamic (real time) robotic telepathology and static image (store-and-forward) telepathology. In 1989, a hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology system was developed in Norway. This hybrid imaging system bundled these two primary pathology imaging modalities into a single multi-modality pathology imaging system. Similar hybrid systems were subsequently developed and marketed in other countries as well. It is noteworthy that hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology systems provided the infrastructure for the first truly sustainable telepathology services. Since then, impressive progress has been made in developing another telepathology technology, so-called "virtual microscopy" telepathology (also called "whole slide image" telepathology or "WSI" telepathology). Over the past decade, WSI has appeared to be emerging as the preferred digital telepathology digital imaging modality. However, recently, there has been a re-emergence of interest in dynamic-robotic telepathology driven, in part, by concerns over the lack of a means for up-and-down focusing (i.e., Z-axis focusing) using early WSI processors. In 2010, the initial two U.S. patents for robotic telepathology (issued in 1993 and 1994) expired enabling many digital pathology equipment companies to incorporate dynamic-robotic telepathology modules into their WSI products for the first time. The dynamic-robotic telepathology module provided a solution to the up-and-down focusing issue. WSI and dynamic robotic telepathology are now, rapidly, being bundled into a new class of telepathology/digital pathology imaging system, the "WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology system". To date, six major WSI processor equipment companies have embraced the approach and developed WSI-enhanced dynamic-robotic digital telepathology systems, marketed under a variety of labels. Successful commercialization of such systems could help overcome the current resistance of some pathologists to incorporate digital pathology, and telepathology, into their routine and esoteric laboratory services. Also, WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology could be useful for providing general pathology and subspecialty pathology services to many of the world's underserved populations in the decades ahead. This could become an important enabler for the delivery of patient-centered healthcare in the future.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)256-275
Number of pages20
JournalAPMIS
Volume120
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 2012

Fingerprint

Telepathology
Robotics
Pathology

Keywords

  • Cloud computing
  • Digital pathology
  • Robotic microscopy
  • Surgical pathology
  • Telepathology
  • Telepathology networks
  • Virtual microscopy
  • Virtual slides
  • Whole slide imaging (WSI)

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pathology and Forensic Medicine
  • Microbiology (medical)
  • Immunology and Allergy

Cite this

Reconciliation of diverse telepathology system designs. Historic issues and implications for emerging markets and new applications. / Weinstein, Ronald S; Graham, Anna R.; Lian, Fangru; Braunhut, Beth L.; Barker, Gail P; Krupinski, Elizabeth A; Bhattacharyya, Achyut K.

In: APMIS, Vol. 120, No. 4, 04.2012, p. 256-275.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{c2083abc12214f38a536d43b6c490194,
title = "Reconciliation of diverse telepathology system designs. Historic issues and implications for emerging markets and new applications",
abstract = "Telepathology, the distant service component of digital pathology, is a growth industry. The word {"}telepathology{"} was introduced into the English Language in 1986. Initially, two different, competing imaging modalities were used for telepathology. These were dynamic (real time) robotic telepathology and static image (store-and-forward) telepathology. In 1989, a hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology system was developed in Norway. This hybrid imaging system bundled these two primary pathology imaging modalities into a single multi-modality pathology imaging system. Similar hybrid systems were subsequently developed and marketed in other countries as well. It is noteworthy that hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology systems provided the infrastructure for the first truly sustainable telepathology services. Since then, impressive progress has been made in developing another telepathology technology, so-called {"}virtual microscopy{"} telepathology (also called {"}whole slide image{"} telepathology or {"}WSI{"} telepathology). Over the past decade, WSI has appeared to be emerging as the preferred digital telepathology digital imaging modality. However, recently, there has been a re-emergence of interest in dynamic-robotic telepathology driven, in part, by concerns over the lack of a means for up-and-down focusing (i.e., Z-axis focusing) using early WSI processors. In 2010, the initial two U.S. patents for robotic telepathology (issued in 1993 and 1994) expired enabling many digital pathology equipment companies to incorporate dynamic-robotic telepathology modules into their WSI products for the first time. The dynamic-robotic telepathology module provided a solution to the up-and-down focusing issue. WSI and dynamic robotic telepathology are now, rapidly, being bundled into a new class of telepathology/digital pathology imaging system, the {"}WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology system{"}. To date, six major WSI processor equipment companies have embraced the approach and developed WSI-enhanced dynamic-robotic digital telepathology systems, marketed under a variety of labels. Successful commercialization of such systems could help overcome the current resistance of some pathologists to incorporate digital pathology, and telepathology, into their routine and esoteric laboratory services. Also, WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology could be useful for providing general pathology and subspecialty pathology services to many of the world's underserved populations in the decades ahead. This could become an important enabler for the delivery of patient-centered healthcare in the future.",
keywords = "Cloud computing, Digital pathology, Robotic microscopy, Surgical pathology, Telepathology, Telepathology networks, Virtual microscopy, Virtual slides, Whole slide imaging (WSI)",
author = "Weinstein, {Ronald S} and Graham, {Anna R.} and Fangru Lian and Braunhut, {Beth L.} and Barker, {Gail P} and Krupinski, {Elizabeth A} and Bhattacharyya, {Achyut K}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1111/j.1600-0463.2011.02866.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "120",
pages = "256--275",
journal = "Acta Pathologica Microbiologica et Immunologica Scandinavica - Section B Microbiology",
issn = "0365-5555",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reconciliation of diverse telepathology system designs. Historic issues and implications for emerging markets and new applications

AU - Weinstein, Ronald S

AU - Graham, Anna R.

AU - Lian, Fangru

AU - Braunhut, Beth L.

AU - Barker, Gail P

AU - Krupinski, Elizabeth A

AU - Bhattacharyya, Achyut K

PY - 2012/4

Y1 - 2012/4

N2 - Telepathology, the distant service component of digital pathology, is a growth industry. The word "telepathology" was introduced into the English Language in 1986. Initially, two different, competing imaging modalities were used for telepathology. These were dynamic (real time) robotic telepathology and static image (store-and-forward) telepathology. In 1989, a hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology system was developed in Norway. This hybrid imaging system bundled these two primary pathology imaging modalities into a single multi-modality pathology imaging system. Similar hybrid systems were subsequently developed and marketed in other countries as well. It is noteworthy that hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology systems provided the infrastructure for the first truly sustainable telepathology services. Since then, impressive progress has been made in developing another telepathology technology, so-called "virtual microscopy" telepathology (also called "whole slide image" telepathology or "WSI" telepathology). Over the past decade, WSI has appeared to be emerging as the preferred digital telepathology digital imaging modality. However, recently, there has been a re-emergence of interest in dynamic-robotic telepathology driven, in part, by concerns over the lack of a means for up-and-down focusing (i.e., Z-axis focusing) using early WSI processors. In 2010, the initial two U.S. patents for robotic telepathology (issued in 1993 and 1994) expired enabling many digital pathology equipment companies to incorporate dynamic-robotic telepathology modules into their WSI products for the first time. The dynamic-robotic telepathology module provided a solution to the up-and-down focusing issue. WSI and dynamic robotic telepathology are now, rapidly, being bundled into a new class of telepathology/digital pathology imaging system, the "WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology system". To date, six major WSI processor equipment companies have embraced the approach and developed WSI-enhanced dynamic-robotic digital telepathology systems, marketed under a variety of labels. Successful commercialization of such systems could help overcome the current resistance of some pathologists to incorporate digital pathology, and telepathology, into their routine and esoteric laboratory services. Also, WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology could be useful for providing general pathology and subspecialty pathology services to many of the world's underserved populations in the decades ahead. This could become an important enabler for the delivery of patient-centered healthcare in the future.

AB - Telepathology, the distant service component of digital pathology, is a growth industry. The word "telepathology" was introduced into the English Language in 1986. Initially, two different, competing imaging modalities were used for telepathology. These were dynamic (real time) robotic telepathology and static image (store-and-forward) telepathology. In 1989, a hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology system was developed in Norway. This hybrid imaging system bundled these two primary pathology imaging modalities into a single multi-modality pathology imaging system. Similar hybrid systems were subsequently developed and marketed in other countries as well. It is noteworthy that hybrid dynamic robotic/static image telepathology systems provided the infrastructure for the first truly sustainable telepathology services. Since then, impressive progress has been made in developing another telepathology technology, so-called "virtual microscopy" telepathology (also called "whole slide image" telepathology or "WSI" telepathology). Over the past decade, WSI has appeared to be emerging as the preferred digital telepathology digital imaging modality. However, recently, there has been a re-emergence of interest in dynamic-robotic telepathology driven, in part, by concerns over the lack of a means for up-and-down focusing (i.e., Z-axis focusing) using early WSI processors. In 2010, the initial two U.S. patents for robotic telepathology (issued in 1993 and 1994) expired enabling many digital pathology equipment companies to incorporate dynamic-robotic telepathology modules into their WSI products for the first time. The dynamic-robotic telepathology module provided a solution to the up-and-down focusing issue. WSI and dynamic robotic telepathology are now, rapidly, being bundled into a new class of telepathology/digital pathology imaging system, the "WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology system". To date, six major WSI processor equipment companies have embraced the approach and developed WSI-enhanced dynamic-robotic digital telepathology systems, marketed under a variety of labels. Successful commercialization of such systems could help overcome the current resistance of some pathologists to incorporate digital pathology, and telepathology, into their routine and esoteric laboratory services. Also, WSI-enhanced dynamic robotic telepathology could be useful for providing general pathology and subspecialty pathology services to many of the world's underserved populations in the decades ahead. This could become an important enabler for the delivery of patient-centered healthcare in the future.

KW - Cloud computing

KW - Digital pathology

KW - Robotic microscopy

KW - Surgical pathology

KW - Telepathology

KW - Telepathology networks

KW - Virtual microscopy

KW - Virtual slides

KW - Whole slide imaging (WSI)

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84858690647&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84858690647&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1600-0463.2011.02866.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1600-0463.2011.02866.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 22429209

AN - SCOPUS:84858690647

VL - 120

SP - 256

EP - 275

JO - Acta Pathologica Microbiologica et Immunologica Scandinavica - Section B Microbiology

JF - Acta Pathologica Microbiologica et Immunologica Scandinavica - Section B Microbiology

SN - 0365-5555

IS - 4

ER -