Reliability of multitaxon, multiproxy reconstructions of environmental conditions from accretionary biogenic skeletons

Bernd R. Schöne, David L. Rodland, Jens Fiebig, Wolfgang Oschmann, David Goodwin, Karl Flessa, David Dettman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

31 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Evaluation and quantification of climate change require data on subseasonal to daily environmental extremes from those periods before instrumental records were available. This study employs a high-resolution, multitaxon, multiproxy approach and analyzes how faithfully accretionary biogenic skeletons record environmental extremes. Six specimens of two bivalve mollusks (Chione fluctifraga, Mytella guyanensi) and one barnacle species (Chthamalus fissus) from a single habitat (northern Gulf of California, Mexico) were collected. Contemporaneous shell portions from these specimens were analyzed for shell growth rates (sclerochronology) and stable isotopes (δ18O, δ13C) and were compared to instrumental records. The results of these analyses included some significant observations. First, shell δ18O values overestimate winter temperatures and underestimate summer temperatures. Second, the actual diurnal temperature range is not recorded in the biogenic skeletons. Third, skeletal growth is biased toward a species-specific optimum growth temperature (24°-30.9°C. Therefore, higher sampling resolution will not necessarily capture actual environmental extremes. Despite measured temperature extremes of 37.8° and 4.5°C, none of the studied species recorded temperatures above 30.9° or below 12.2°C. Duration and timing of the annual growing period is species specific as well. Faster shell growth occurred at higher temperatures. Up to 58% (C. fissus) of the variability in shell growth can be explained by water temperature during growth. Contemporaneous trends in shell δ13C show a weak correlation with pigment concentration (R2 = 0.17). Higher levels of chlorophyll appear to increase shell production. rates. Our study highlights the difficulties inherent in using biogenic skeletons for the reconstruction of paleoenvironmental extremes and demonstrates the power and utility of multiproxy and multitaxon approaches.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)267-285
Number of pages19
JournalJournal of Geology
Volume114
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - May 2006

Fingerprint

skeleton
environmental conditions
shell
temperature
pigment
bivalve
chlorophyll
stable isotope
water temperature
climate change
winter
sampling
summer
habitat

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geology

Cite this

Reliability of multitaxon, multiproxy reconstructions of environmental conditions from accretionary biogenic skeletons. / Schöne, Bernd R.; Rodland, David L.; Fiebig, Jens; Oschmann, Wolfgang; Goodwin, David; Flessa, Karl; Dettman, David.

In: Journal of Geology, Vol. 114, No. 3, 05.2006, p. 267-285.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Schöne, Bernd R. ; Rodland, David L. ; Fiebig, Jens ; Oschmann, Wolfgang ; Goodwin, David ; Flessa, Karl ; Dettman, David. / Reliability of multitaxon, multiproxy reconstructions of environmental conditions from accretionary biogenic skeletons. In: Journal of Geology. 2006 ; Vol. 114, No. 3. pp. 267-285.
@article{e6daf7c055004e008f8cacf44eb91d3c,
title = "Reliability of multitaxon, multiproxy reconstructions of environmental conditions from accretionary biogenic skeletons",
abstract = "Evaluation and quantification of climate change require data on subseasonal to daily environmental extremes from those periods before instrumental records were available. This study employs a high-resolution, multitaxon, multiproxy approach and analyzes how faithfully accretionary biogenic skeletons record environmental extremes. Six specimens of two bivalve mollusks (Chione fluctifraga, Mytella guyanensi) and one barnacle species (Chthamalus fissus) from a single habitat (northern Gulf of California, Mexico) were collected. Contemporaneous shell portions from these specimens were analyzed for shell growth rates (sclerochronology) and stable isotopes (δ18O, δ13C) and were compared to instrumental records. The results of these analyses included some significant observations. First, shell δ18O values overestimate winter temperatures and underestimate summer temperatures. Second, the actual diurnal temperature range is not recorded in the biogenic skeletons. Third, skeletal growth is biased toward a species-specific optimum growth temperature (24°-30.9°C. Therefore, higher sampling resolution will not necessarily capture actual environmental extremes. Despite measured temperature extremes of 37.8° and 4.5°C, none of the studied species recorded temperatures above 30.9° or below 12.2°C. Duration and timing of the annual growing period is species specific as well. Faster shell growth occurred at higher temperatures. Up to 58{\%} (C. fissus) of the variability in shell growth can be explained by water temperature during growth. Contemporaneous trends in shell δ13C show a weak correlation with pigment concentration (R2 = 0.17). Higher levels of chlorophyll appear to increase shell production. rates. Our study highlights the difficulties inherent in using biogenic skeletons for the reconstruction of paleoenvironmental extremes and demonstrates the power and utility of multiproxy and multitaxon approaches.",
author = "Sch{\"o}ne, {Bernd R.} and Rodland, {David L.} and Jens Fiebig and Wolfgang Oschmann and David Goodwin and Karl Flessa and David Dettman",
year = "2006",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1086/501219",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "114",
pages = "267--285",
journal = "Journal of Geology",
issn = "0022-1376",
publisher = "University of Chicago",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reliability of multitaxon, multiproxy reconstructions of environmental conditions from accretionary biogenic skeletons

AU - Schöne, Bernd R.

AU - Rodland, David L.

AU - Fiebig, Jens

AU - Oschmann, Wolfgang

AU - Goodwin, David

AU - Flessa, Karl

AU - Dettman, David

PY - 2006/5

Y1 - 2006/5

N2 - Evaluation and quantification of climate change require data on subseasonal to daily environmental extremes from those periods before instrumental records were available. This study employs a high-resolution, multitaxon, multiproxy approach and analyzes how faithfully accretionary biogenic skeletons record environmental extremes. Six specimens of two bivalve mollusks (Chione fluctifraga, Mytella guyanensi) and one barnacle species (Chthamalus fissus) from a single habitat (northern Gulf of California, Mexico) were collected. Contemporaneous shell portions from these specimens were analyzed for shell growth rates (sclerochronology) and stable isotopes (δ18O, δ13C) and were compared to instrumental records. The results of these analyses included some significant observations. First, shell δ18O values overestimate winter temperatures and underestimate summer temperatures. Second, the actual diurnal temperature range is not recorded in the biogenic skeletons. Third, skeletal growth is biased toward a species-specific optimum growth temperature (24°-30.9°C. Therefore, higher sampling resolution will not necessarily capture actual environmental extremes. Despite measured temperature extremes of 37.8° and 4.5°C, none of the studied species recorded temperatures above 30.9° or below 12.2°C. Duration and timing of the annual growing period is species specific as well. Faster shell growth occurred at higher temperatures. Up to 58% (C. fissus) of the variability in shell growth can be explained by water temperature during growth. Contemporaneous trends in shell δ13C show a weak correlation with pigment concentration (R2 = 0.17). Higher levels of chlorophyll appear to increase shell production. rates. Our study highlights the difficulties inherent in using biogenic skeletons for the reconstruction of paleoenvironmental extremes and demonstrates the power and utility of multiproxy and multitaxon approaches.

AB - Evaluation and quantification of climate change require data on subseasonal to daily environmental extremes from those periods before instrumental records were available. This study employs a high-resolution, multitaxon, multiproxy approach and analyzes how faithfully accretionary biogenic skeletons record environmental extremes. Six specimens of two bivalve mollusks (Chione fluctifraga, Mytella guyanensi) and one barnacle species (Chthamalus fissus) from a single habitat (northern Gulf of California, Mexico) were collected. Contemporaneous shell portions from these specimens were analyzed for shell growth rates (sclerochronology) and stable isotopes (δ18O, δ13C) and were compared to instrumental records. The results of these analyses included some significant observations. First, shell δ18O values overestimate winter temperatures and underestimate summer temperatures. Second, the actual diurnal temperature range is not recorded in the biogenic skeletons. Third, skeletal growth is biased toward a species-specific optimum growth temperature (24°-30.9°C. Therefore, higher sampling resolution will not necessarily capture actual environmental extremes. Despite measured temperature extremes of 37.8° and 4.5°C, none of the studied species recorded temperatures above 30.9° or below 12.2°C. Duration and timing of the annual growing period is species specific as well. Faster shell growth occurred at higher temperatures. Up to 58% (C. fissus) of the variability in shell growth can be explained by water temperature during growth. Contemporaneous trends in shell δ13C show a weak correlation with pigment concentration (R2 = 0.17). Higher levels of chlorophyll appear to increase shell production. rates. Our study highlights the difficulties inherent in using biogenic skeletons for the reconstruction of paleoenvironmental extremes and demonstrates the power and utility of multiproxy and multitaxon approaches.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33744793453&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33744793453&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1086/501219

DO - 10.1086/501219

M3 - Article

VL - 114

SP - 267

EP - 285

JO - Journal of Geology

JF - Journal of Geology

SN - 0022-1376

IS - 3

ER -