In this short note I reply to criticisms of an argument in my paper  that appear in comment . I refer the reader to section 4 of  in which I described the scenario of a Gedankenexperiment on which is based the argument criticized in . The authors of  raise one “main criticism” then go on to claim that the argument of  contains a series of problems. But their “main criticism” is not an objection to the argument and the problems are of their own making. In replying to what they call their main criticism I will take this opportunity to exhibit the structure of the argument and so make clear why this is not an objection to that argument.
|Original language||English (US)|
|State||Published - Jul 24 2019|
ASJC Scopus subject areas