Sustainability of mangrove harvesting: How do harvesters' perceptions differ from ecological analysis?

Laura López-Hoffman, Ian E. Monroe, Enrique Narváez, Miguel Martínez-Ramos, David D. Ackerly

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

To harvest biological resources sustainably, it is first necessary to understand what "sustainability" means in an ecological context, and what it means to the people who use the resources. As a case study, we examined the extractive logging of the mangrove Rhizophora mangle in the Río Limón area of Lake Maracaibo, in western Venezuela. The ecological definition of sustainable harvesting is harvesting that allows population numbers to be maintained or to increase over time. In interviews, the harvesters defined sustainable harvesting as levels permitting the maintenance of the mangrove population over two human generations, about 50 yr. In Río Limón, harvesters extract a combination of small adult and juvenile trees. Harvesting rates ranged from 7-35% of small adult trees. These harvesting levels would be sustainable according to the harvester's definition as long as juvenile harvesting was less than 40%. However, some harvesting levels that would be sustainable according to the harvesters were ecologically unsustainable, i.e., eventually causing declines in mangrove population numbers. It was also determined that the structure of mangrove forests was significantly affected by harvesting; even areas harvested at low, ecologically sustainable intensities had significantly fewer adult trees than undisturbed sites. Western Venezuela has no organized timber industry, so mangrove logs are used in many types of construction. A lagging economy and a lack of alternative construction materials make mangrove harvesting inevitable, and for local people, an economic necessity. This creates a trade-off between preserving the ecological characteristics of the mangrove population and responding to human needs. In order to resolve this situation, we recommended a limited and adaptive mangrove harvesting regime. We also suggest that harvesters could participate in community-based management programs as harvesting monitors.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number14
JournalEcology and Society
Volume11
Issue number2
StatePublished - Dec 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

mangrove
sustainability
analysis
timber industry
trade-off
lake
resource

Keywords

  • Conservation
  • Sustainable management
  • Tropical forest
  • Venezuela

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Nature and Landscape Conservation

Cite this

López-Hoffman, L., Monroe, I. E., Narváez, E., Martínez-Ramos, M., & Ackerly, D. D. (2006). Sustainability of mangrove harvesting: How do harvesters' perceptions differ from ecological analysis? Ecology and Society, 11(2), [14].

Sustainability of mangrove harvesting : How do harvesters' perceptions differ from ecological analysis? / López-Hoffman, Laura; Monroe, Ian E.; Narváez, Enrique; Martínez-Ramos, Miguel; Ackerly, David D.

In: Ecology and Society, Vol. 11, No. 2, 14, 12.2006.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

López-Hoffman, Laura ; Monroe, Ian E. ; Narváez, Enrique ; Martínez-Ramos, Miguel ; Ackerly, David D. / Sustainability of mangrove harvesting : How do harvesters' perceptions differ from ecological analysis?. In: Ecology and Society. 2006 ; Vol. 11, No. 2.
@article{2abf31e850c540f0acf6caa8fe54735d,
title = "Sustainability of mangrove harvesting: How do harvesters' perceptions differ from ecological analysis?",
abstract = "To harvest biological resources sustainably, it is first necessary to understand what {"}sustainability{"} means in an ecological context, and what it means to the people who use the resources. As a case study, we examined the extractive logging of the mangrove Rhizophora mangle in the R{\'i}o Lim{\'o}n area of Lake Maracaibo, in western Venezuela. The ecological definition of sustainable harvesting is harvesting that allows population numbers to be maintained or to increase over time. In interviews, the harvesters defined sustainable harvesting as levels permitting the maintenance of the mangrove population over two human generations, about 50 yr. In R{\'i}o Lim{\'o}n, harvesters extract a combination of small adult and juvenile trees. Harvesting rates ranged from 7-35{\%} of small adult trees. These harvesting levels would be sustainable according to the harvester's definition as long as juvenile harvesting was less than 40{\%}. However, some harvesting levels that would be sustainable according to the harvesters were ecologically unsustainable, i.e., eventually causing declines in mangrove population numbers. It was also determined that the structure of mangrove forests was significantly affected by harvesting; even areas harvested at low, ecologically sustainable intensities had significantly fewer adult trees than undisturbed sites. Western Venezuela has no organized timber industry, so mangrove logs are used in many types of construction. A lagging economy and a lack of alternative construction materials make mangrove harvesting inevitable, and for local people, an economic necessity. This creates a trade-off between preserving the ecological characteristics of the mangrove population and responding to human needs. In order to resolve this situation, we recommended a limited and adaptive mangrove harvesting regime. We also suggest that harvesters could participate in community-based management programs as harvesting monitors.",
keywords = "Conservation, Sustainable management, Tropical forest, Venezuela",
author = "Laura L{\'o}pez-Hoffman and Monroe, {Ian E.} and Enrique Narv{\'a}ez and Miguel Mart{\'i}nez-Ramos and Ackerly, {David D.}",
year = "2006",
month = "12",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "11",
journal = "Ecology and Society",
issn = "1708-3087",
publisher = "The Resilience Alliance",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sustainability of mangrove harvesting

T2 - How do harvesters' perceptions differ from ecological analysis?

AU - López-Hoffman, Laura

AU - Monroe, Ian E.

AU - Narváez, Enrique

AU - Martínez-Ramos, Miguel

AU - Ackerly, David D.

PY - 2006/12

Y1 - 2006/12

N2 - To harvest biological resources sustainably, it is first necessary to understand what "sustainability" means in an ecological context, and what it means to the people who use the resources. As a case study, we examined the extractive logging of the mangrove Rhizophora mangle in the Río Limón area of Lake Maracaibo, in western Venezuela. The ecological definition of sustainable harvesting is harvesting that allows population numbers to be maintained or to increase over time. In interviews, the harvesters defined sustainable harvesting as levels permitting the maintenance of the mangrove population over two human generations, about 50 yr. In Río Limón, harvesters extract a combination of small adult and juvenile trees. Harvesting rates ranged from 7-35% of small adult trees. These harvesting levels would be sustainable according to the harvester's definition as long as juvenile harvesting was less than 40%. However, some harvesting levels that would be sustainable according to the harvesters were ecologically unsustainable, i.e., eventually causing declines in mangrove population numbers. It was also determined that the structure of mangrove forests was significantly affected by harvesting; even areas harvested at low, ecologically sustainable intensities had significantly fewer adult trees than undisturbed sites. Western Venezuela has no organized timber industry, so mangrove logs are used in many types of construction. A lagging economy and a lack of alternative construction materials make mangrove harvesting inevitable, and for local people, an economic necessity. This creates a trade-off between preserving the ecological characteristics of the mangrove population and responding to human needs. In order to resolve this situation, we recommended a limited and adaptive mangrove harvesting regime. We also suggest that harvesters could participate in community-based management programs as harvesting monitors.

AB - To harvest biological resources sustainably, it is first necessary to understand what "sustainability" means in an ecological context, and what it means to the people who use the resources. As a case study, we examined the extractive logging of the mangrove Rhizophora mangle in the Río Limón area of Lake Maracaibo, in western Venezuela. The ecological definition of sustainable harvesting is harvesting that allows population numbers to be maintained or to increase over time. In interviews, the harvesters defined sustainable harvesting as levels permitting the maintenance of the mangrove population over two human generations, about 50 yr. In Río Limón, harvesters extract a combination of small adult and juvenile trees. Harvesting rates ranged from 7-35% of small adult trees. These harvesting levels would be sustainable according to the harvester's definition as long as juvenile harvesting was less than 40%. However, some harvesting levels that would be sustainable according to the harvesters were ecologically unsustainable, i.e., eventually causing declines in mangrove population numbers. It was also determined that the structure of mangrove forests was significantly affected by harvesting; even areas harvested at low, ecologically sustainable intensities had significantly fewer adult trees than undisturbed sites. Western Venezuela has no organized timber industry, so mangrove logs are used in many types of construction. A lagging economy and a lack of alternative construction materials make mangrove harvesting inevitable, and for local people, an economic necessity. This creates a trade-off between preserving the ecological characteristics of the mangrove population and responding to human needs. In order to resolve this situation, we recommended a limited and adaptive mangrove harvesting regime. We also suggest that harvesters could participate in community-based management programs as harvesting monitors.

KW - Conservation

KW - Sustainable management

KW - Tropical forest

KW - Venezuela

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33846068109&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33846068109&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:33846068109

VL - 11

JO - Ecology and Society

JF - Ecology and Society

SN - 1708-3087

IS - 2

M1 - 14

ER -