Synergistic antinociceptive interactions of morphine and clonidine in rats with nerve-ligation injury

Michael H. Ossipov, Yvan Lopez, Di Bian, Michael L. Nichols, Frank Porreca

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

81 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Ligation injury of the L5/L6 nerve roots in rats produces behavioral signs representative of clinical conditions of neuropathic pain, including tactile allodynia and thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia. In this model, intrathecal morphine shows no antiallodynic activity, as well as decreased antinociceptive potency and efficacy. This study was designed to explore the antinociceptive activity of intrathecal clonidine alone or in combination with intrathecal morphine (1:3 fixed ratio) in nerve-injured rats. The aims, with this study, were to use nerve-injured animals to determine: (1) whether the combination of intrathecal morphine and clonidine would act synergistically to produce antinociception. Methods: Unilateral nerve injury was produced by ligation of the L5 and L6 spinal roots of male Sprague-Dawley rats. Sham-operated rats underwent a similar surgical procedure but without nerve ligation. Morphine and clonidine were given intrathecally through implanted catheters alone or in a 1:3 fixed ratio. Nociceptive responses were measured by recording tail withdrawal latency from a 55°C water bath, and data were calculated as % maximal possible effect (%MPE). Results: Morphine produced a dose-dependent antinociceptive effect in both sham-operated and nerve injured rats. The doses calculated to produce a 50%MPE (i.e., A50)(+95% confidence intervals [CI]) were 15 ± 4.9 μg and 30 ± 18μg, respectively. Though morphine was able to produce a maximal response (100%). In sham-operated rats, the maximal response achieved in nerve-injured animals was only 69 ± 21.9 %MPE. Clonidine produced a dose- dependent effect, with an A50 (95% CI) of 120 ± 24 μg in sham-operated rats. In nerve-ligated rats, clonidine produced a maximal effect that reached a plateau of 55 ± 10.9 %MPE and 49 ± 10.2 %MPE at 100 and 200 μg, respectively, preventing the calculation of an A50. In sham-operated rats, a morphine-clonidine mixture produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (< 95% CI) of 15 ± 9.2 μg (total dose), significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 44 ± 10μg. in L5/L6 nerve-ligated rats, the morphine- clonidine combination produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (<95% CI) of 44 ± 5.4 μg (total dose), which was significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 118 ± 73 μg, indicating a synergistic antinociceptive interaction. The intrathecal injection of [D-Ala2, NMePhe4, Gly- ol]enkephalin (DAMGO) produced A50 values of 0.23 μg (range, 0.09-0.6) and 0.97 μg (range, 0.34-2.7) in sham-operated and ligated rats, respectively, Phentolamine (4 mg/kg, intraperitoneally) produced no antinociceptive effect alone and attenuated rather than enhanced, the effect of morphine in both groups of rats. Conclusions: These data show that: (1) clonidine, like morphine, loses antinociceptive potency and efficacy after nerve ligationinjury, and (2) strongly suggest that a spinal combinations of morphine and clonidine synergize under conditions of nerve injury to elicit a significant antinociceptive action when either drug alone may be lacking in efficacy. It is unlikely that the synergy of morphine with clonidine is due to an attenuation of spinal sympathetic outflow by clonidine, because the sympatholytic agent phentolamine produced an opposing effect on morphine antinociception. The data suggest that combinations of morphine and clonidine may prove useful in controlling pain in patients with neuropathic conditions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)196-204
Number of pages9
JournalAnesthesiology
Volume86
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 1997

Fingerprint

Clonidine
Morphine
Ligation
Wounds and Injuries
Hyperalgesia
Confidence Intervals
Phentolamine
Sympatholytics
Spinal Injections
Spinal Nerve Roots
Enkephalins
Neuralgia
Baths
Sprague Dawley Rats
Tail
Catheters

Keywords

  • morphine-clonidine synergy, neuropathic pain, antinociception, rat,intrathecal

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine

Cite this

Synergistic antinociceptive interactions of morphine and clonidine in rats with nerve-ligation injury. / Ossipov, Michael H.; Lopez, Yvan; Bian, Di; Nichols, Michael L.; Porreca, Frank.

In: Anesthesiology, Vol. 86, No. 1, 1997, p. 196-204.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ossipov, Michael H. ; Lopez, Yvan ; Bian, Di ; Nichols, Michael L. ; Porreca, Frank. / Synergistic antinociceptive interactions of morphine and clonidine in rats with nerve-ligation injury. In: Anesthesiology. 1997 ; Vol. 86, No. 1. pp. 196-204.
@article{73c45f0acc524d10bc8e43d4b6e80730,
title = "Synergistic antinociceptive interactions of morphine and clonidine in rats with nerve-ligation injury",
abstract = "Background: Ligation injury of the L5/L6 nerve roots in rats produces behavioral signs representative of clinical conditions of neuropathic pain, including tactile allodynia and thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia. In this model, intrathecal morphine shows no antiallodynic activity, as well as decreased antinociceptive potency and efficacy. This study was designed to explore the antinociceptive activity of intrathecal clonidine alone or in combination with intrathecal morphine (1:3 fixed ratio) in nerve-injured rats. The aims, with this study, were to use nerve-injured animals to determine: (1) whether the combination of intrathecal morphine and clonidine would act synergistically to produce antinociception. Methods: Unilateral nerve injury was produced by ligation of the L5 and L6 spinal roots of male Sprague-Dawley rats. Sham-operated rats underwent a similar surgical procedure but without nerve ligation. Morphine and clonidine were given intrathecally through implanted catheters alone or in a 1:3 fixed ratio. Nociceptive responses were measured by recording tail withdrawal latency from a 55°C water bath, and data were calculated as {\%} maximal possible effect ({\%}MPE). Results: Morphine produced a dose-dependent antinociceptive effect in both sham-operated and nerve injured rats. The doses calculated to produce a 50{\%}MPE (i.e., A50)(+95{\%} confidence intervals [CI]) were 15 ± 4.9 μg and 30 ± 18μg, respectively. Though morphine was able to produce a maximal response (100{\%}). In sham-operated rats, the maximal response achieved in nerve-injured animals was only 69 ± 21.9 {\%}MPE. Clonidine produced a dose- dependent effect, with an A50 (95{\%} CI) of 120 ± 24 μg in sham-operated rats. In nerve-ligated rats, clonidine produced a maximal effect that reached a plateau of 55 ± 10.9 {\%}MPE and 49 ± 10.2 {\%}MPE at 100 and 200 μg, respectively, preventing the calculation of an A50. In sham-operated rats, a morphine-clonidine mixture produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (< 95{\%} CI) of 15 ± 9.2 μg (total dose), significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 44 ± 10μg. in L5/L6 nerve-ligated rats, the morphine- clonidine combination produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (<95{\%} CI) of 44 ± 5.4 μg (total dose), which was significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 118 ± 73 μg, indicating a synergistic antinociceptive interaction. The intrathecal injection of [D-Ala2, NMePhe4, Gly- ol]enkephalin (DAMGO) produced A50 values of 0.23 μg (range, 0.09-0.6) and 0.97 μg (range, 0.34-2.7) in sham-operated and ligated rats, respectively, Phentolamine (4 mg/kg, intraperitoneally) produced no antinociceptive effect alone and attenuated rather than enhanced, the effect of morphine in both groups of rats. Conclusions: These data show that: (1) clonidine, like morphine, loses antinociceptive potency and efficacy after nerve ligationinjury, and (2) strongly suggest that a spinal combinations of morphine and clonidine synergize under conditions of nerve injury to elicit a significant antinociceptive action when either drug alone may be lacking in efficacy. It is unlikely that the synergy of morphine with clonidine is due to an attenuation of spinal sympathetic outflow by clonidine, because the sympatholytic agent phentolamine produced an opposing effect on morphine antinociception. The data suggest that combinations of morphine and clonidine may prove useful in controlling pain in patients with neuropathic conditions.",
keywords = "morphine-clonidine synergy, neuropathic pain, antinociception, rat,intrathecal",
author = "Ossipov, {Michael H.} and Yvan Lopez and Di Bian and Nichols, {Michael L.} and Frank Porreca",
year = "1997",
doi = "10.1097/00000542-199701000-00024",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "86",
pages = "196--204",
journal = "Anesthesiology",
issn = "0003-3022",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Synergistic antinociceptive interactions of morphine and clonidine in rats with nerve-ligation injury

AU - Ossipov, Michael H.

AU - Lopez, Yvan

AU - Bian, Di

AU - Nichols, Michael L.

AU - Porreca, Frank

PY - 1997

Y1 - 1997

N2 - Background: Ligation injury of the L5/L6 nerve roots in rats produces behavioral signs representative of clinical conditions of neuropathic pain, including tactile allodynia and thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia. In this model, intrathecal morphine shows no antiallodynic activity, as well as decreased antinociceptive potency and efficacy. This study was designed to explore the antinociceptive activity of intrathecal clonidine alone or in combination with intrathecal morphine (1:3 fixed ratio) in nerve-injured rats. The aims, with this study, were to use nerve-injured animals to determine: (1) whether the combination of intrathecal morphine and clonidine would act synergistically to produce antinociception. Methods: Unilateral nerve injury was produced by ligation of the L5 and L6 spinal roots of male Sprague-Dawley rats. Sham-operated rats underwent a similar surgical procedure but without nerve ligation. Morphine and clonidine were given intrathecally through implanted catheters alone or in a 1:3 fixed ratio. Nociceptive responses were measured by recording tail withdrawal latency from a 55°C water bath, and data were calculated as % maximal possible effect (%MPE). Results: Morphine produced a dose-dependent antinociceptive effect in both sham-operated and nerve injured rats. The doses calculated to produce a 50%MPE (i.e., A50)(+95% confidence intervals [CI]) were 15 ± 4.9 μg and 30 ± 18μg, respectively. Though morphine was able to produce a maximal response (100%). In sham-operated rats, the maximal response achieved in nerve-injured animals was only 69 ± 21.9 %MPE. Clonidine produced a dose- dependent effect, with an A50 (95% CI) of 120 ± 24 μg in sham-operated rats. In nerve-ligated rats, clonidine produced a maximal effect that reached a plateau of 55 ± 10.9 %MPE and 49 ± 10.2 %MPE at 100 and 200 μg, respectively, preventing the calculation of an A50. In sham-operated rats, a morphine-clonidine mixture produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (< 95% CI) of 15 ± 9.2 μg (total dose), significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 44 ± 10μg. in L5/L6 nerve-ligated rats, the morphine- clonidine combination produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (<95% CI) of 44 ± 5.4 μg (total dose), which was significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 118 ± 73 μg, indicating a synergistic antinociceptive interaction. The intrathecal injection of [D-Ala2, NMePhe4, Gly- ol]enkephalin (DAMGO) produced A50 values of 0.23 μg (range, 0.09-0.6) and 0.97 μg (range, 0.34-2.7) in sham-operated and ligated rats, respectively, Phentolamine (4 mg/kg, intraperitoneally) produced no antinociceptive effect alone and attenuated rather than enhanced, the effect of morphine in both groups of rats. Conclusions: These data show that: (1) clonidine, like morphine, loses antinociceptive potency and efficacy after nerve ligationinjury, and (2) strongly suggest that a spinal combinations of morphine and clonidine synergize under conditions of nerve injury to elicit a significant antinociceptive action when either drug alone may be lacking in efficacy. It is unlikely that the synergy of morphine with clonidine is due to an attenuation of spinal sympathetic outflow by clonidine, because the sympatholytic agent phentolamine produced an opposing effect on morphine antinociception. The data suggest that combinations of morphine and clonidine may prove useful in controlling pain in patients with neuropathic conditions.

AB - Background: Ligation injury of the L5/L6 nerve roots in rats produces behavioral signs representative of clinical conditions of neuropathic pain, including tactile allodynia and thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia. In this model, intrathecal morphine shows no antiallodynic activity, as well as decreased antinociceptive potency and efficacy. This study was designed to explore the antinociceptive activity of intrathecal clonidine alone or in combination with intrathecal morphine (1:3 fixed ratio) in nerve-injured rats. The aims, with this study, were to use nerve-injured animals to determine: (1) whether the combination of intrathecal morphine and clonidine would act synergistically to produce antinociception. Methods: Unilateral nerve injury was produced by ligation of the L5 and L6 spinal roots of male Sprague-Dawley rats. Sham-operated rats underwent a similar surgical procedure but without nerve ligation. Morphine and clonidine were given intrathecally through implanted catheters alone or in a 1:3 fixed ratio. Nociceptive responses were measured by recording tail withdrawal latency from a 55°C water bath, and data were calculated as % maximal possible effect (%MPE). Results: Morphine produced a dose-dependent antinociceptive effect in both sham-operated and nerve injured rats. The doses calculated to produce a 50%MPE (i.e., A50)(+95% confidence intervals [CI]) were 15 ± 4.9 μg and 30 ± 18μg, respectively. Though morphine was able to produce a maximal response (100%). In sham-operated rats, the maximal response achieved in nerve-injured animals was only 69 ± 21.9 %MPE. Clonidine produced a dose- dependent effect, with an A50 (95% CI) of 120 ± 24 μg in sham-operated rats. In nerve-ligated rats, clonidine produced a maximal effect that reached a plateau of 55 ± 10.9 %MPE and 49 ± 10.2 %MPE at 100 and 200 μg, respectively, preventing the calculation of an A50. In sham-operated rats, a morphine-clonidine mixture produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (< 95% CI) of 15 ± 9.2 μg (total dose), significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 44 ± 10μg. in L5/L6 nerve-ligated rats, the morphine- clonidine combination produced maximal efficacy, with an A50 (<95% CI) of 44 ± 5.4 μg (total dose), which was significantly less than the theoretical additive A50 of 118 ± 73 μg, indicating a synergistic antinociceptive interaction. The intrathecal injection of [D-Ala2, NMePhe4, Gly- ol]enkephalin (DAMGO) produced A50 values of 0.23 μg (range, 0.09-0.6) and 0.97 μg (range, 0.34-2.7) in sham-operated and ligated rats, respectively, Phentolamine (4 mg/kg, intraperitoneally) produced no antinociceptive effect alone and attenuated rather than enhanced, the effect of morphine in both groups of rats. Conclusions: These data show that: (1) clonidine, like morphine, loses antinociceptive potency and efficacy after nerve ligationinjury, and (2) strongly suggest that a spinal combinations of morphine and clonidine synergize under conditions of nerve injury to elicit a significant antinociceptive action when either drug alone may be lacking in efficacy. It is unlikely that the synergy of morphine with clonidine is due to an attenuation of spinal sympathetic outflow by clonidine, because the sympatholytic agent phentolamine produced an opposing effect on morphine antinociception. The data suggest that combinations of morphine and clonidine may prove useful in controlling pain in patients with neuropathic conditions.

KW - morphine-clonidine synergy, neuropathic pain, antinociception, rat,intrathecal

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031013659&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0031013659&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/00000542-199701000-00024

DO - 10.1097/00000542-199701000-00024

M3 - Article

C2 - 9009955

AN - SCOPUS:0031013659

VL - 86

SP - 196

EP - 204

JO - Anesthesiology

JF - Anesthesiology

SN - 0003-3022

IS - 1

ER -