The logic of identity and resemblance in culturally appropriate health care

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Greater diversity in the health care workforce is frequently proposed as a means of addressing health disparities between minority and majority populations in the USA by improving health care access and quality for minority groups. 'Culturally appropriate' health care programs that include ethnic resemblance between physician and patient are emerging as new technologies of knowledge and power in a wide range of health care settings. Based on participant-observation research and interviews with patients and health care providers at a federally funded New England clinic, this article uses theories of cultural identity supported by ethnographic examples to examine arguments in favor of patient-provider resemblance. While ethnic identity is often assumed to incorporate cultural expertise or competence, in practice, developing and maintaining such expertise is the result of repeated performances developed in part through didactic trainings described herein. Claims for the efficacy of patient-provider resemblance in addressing disparities in quality of care mobilize notions of specificity, difference and recognition that both depend on and construct racialized ethnic identities. Proposed as a means to expand access to health care, resemblance programs nonetheless perpetuate segregation in health care by relying on minority health care providers to care for the minority poor. Both patients and health care providers I interviewed perceived benefits associated with ethnic resemblance, yet also articulated critiques of the essentialized notions of identity that render ethnicity automatically efficacious. Following Laclau, I argue that an exclusive focus on physician-patient resemblance constructs ethnicity as 'mere particularity' and in so doing helps to obscure the relations of power and inequality that produce the very health disparities that resemblance is meant to solve.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)523-544
Number of pages22
JournalHealth
Volume14
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2010

Fingerprint

logic
Health Personnel
health care
Delivery of Health Care
Quality of Health Care
Patient Care
Minority Health
Physicians
Health Manpower
minority
Minority Groups
New England
Health Services Accessibility
Health
Mental Competency
ethnic identity
patient care
Observation
expertise
Interviews

Keywords

  • ethnicity and health
  • ethnography
  • patient-physician relationship
  • post-structuralism
  • postmodernism
  • race
  • social inequalities in health

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health(social science)

Cite this

The logic of identity and resemblance in culturally appropriate health care. / Shaw, Susan J.

In: Health, Vol. 14, No. 5, 2010, p. 523-544.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1589f87f5edb4c71a87ba11e2859a1e0,
title = "The logic of identity and resemblance in culturally appropriate health care",
abstract = "Greater diversity in the health care workforce is frequently proposed as a means of addressing health disparities between minority and majority populations in the USA by improving health care access and quality for minority groups. 'Culturally appropriate' health care programs that include ethnic resemblance between physician and patient are emerging as new technologies of knowledge and power in a wide range of health care settings. Based on participant-observation research and interviews with patients and health care providers at a federally funded New England clinic, this article uses theories of cultural identity supported by ethnographic examples to examine arguments in favor of patient-provider resemblance. While ethnic identity is often assumed to incorporate cultural expertise or competence, in practice, developing and maintaining such expertise is the result of repeated performances developed in part through didactic trainings described herein. Claims for the efficacy of patient-provider resemblance in addressing disparities in quality of care mobilize notions of specificity, difference and recognition that both depend on and construct racialized ethnic identities. Proposed as a means to expand access to health care, resemblance programs nonetheless perpetuate segregation in health care by relying on minority health care providers to care for the minority poor. Both patients and health care providers I interviewed perceived benefits associated with ethnic resemblance, yet also articulated critiques of the essentialized notions of identity that render ethnicity automatically efficacious. Following Laclau, I argue that an exclusive focus on physician-patient resemblance constructs ethnicity as 'mere particularity' and in so doing helps to obscure the relations of power and inequality that produce the very health disparities that resemblance is meant to solve.",
keywords = "ethnicity and health, ethnography, patient-physician relationship, post-structuralism, postmodernism, race, social inequalities in health",
author = "Shaw, {Susan J}",
year = "2010",
doi = "10.1177/1363459309360973",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "14",
pages = "523--544",
journal = "Health (United Kingdom)",
issn = "1363-4593",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The logic of identity and resemblance in culturally appropriate health care

AU - Shaw, Susan J

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - Greater diversity in the health care workforce is frequently proposed as a means of addressing health disparities between minority and majority populations in the USA by improving health care access and quality for minority groups. 'Culturally appropriate' health care programs that include ethnic resemblance between physician and patient are emerging as new technologies of knowledge and power in a wide range of health care settings. Based on participant-observation research and interviews with patients and health care providers at a federally funded New England clinic, this article uses theories of cultural identity supported by ethnographic examples to examine arguments in favor of patient-provider resemblance. While ethnic identity is often assumed to incorporate cultural expertise or competence, in practice, developing and maintaining such expertise is the result of repeated performances developed in part through didactic trainings described herein. Claims for the efficacy of patient-provider resemblance in addressing disparities in quality of care mobilize notions of specificity, difference and recognition that both depend on and construct racialized ethnic identities. Proposed as a means to expand access to health care, resemblance programs nonetheless perpetuate segregation in health care by relying on minority health care providers to care for the minority poor. Both patients and health care providers I interviewed perceived benefits associated with ethnic resemblance, yet also articulated critiques of the essentialized notions of identity that render ethnicity automatically efficacious. Following Laclau, I argue that an exclusive focus on physician-patient resemblance constructs ethnicity as 'mere particularity' and in so doing helps to obscure the relations of power and inequality that produce the very health disparities that resemblance is meant to solve.

AB - Greater diversity in the health care workforce is frequently proposed as a means of addressing health disparities between minority and majority populations in the USA by improving health care access and quality for minority groups. 'Culturally appropriate' health care programs that include ethnic resemblance between physician and patient are emerging as new technologies of knowledge and power in a wide range of health care settings. Based on participant-observation research and interviews with patients and health care providers at a federally funded New England clinic, this article uses theories of cultural identity supported by ethnographic examples to examine arguments in favor of patient-provider resemblance. While ethnic identity is often assumed to incorporate cultural expertise or competence, in practice, developing and maintaining such expertise is the result of repeated performances developed in part through didactic trainings described herein. Claims for the efficacy of patient-provider resemblance in addressing disparities in quality of care mobilize notions of specificity, difference and recognition that both depend on and construct racialized ethnic identities. Proposed as a means to expand access to health care, resemblance programs nonetheless perpetuate segregation in health care by relying on minority health care providers to care for the minority poor. Both patients and health care providers I interviewed perceived benefits associated with ethnic resemblance, yet also articulated critiques of the essentialized notions of identity that render ethnicity automatically efficacious. Following Laclau, I argue that an exclusive focus on physician-patient resemblance constructs ethnicity as 'mere particularity' and in so doing helps to obscure the relations of power and inequality that produce the very health disparities that resemblance is meant to solve.

KW - ethnicity and health

KW - ethnography

KW - patient-physician relationship

KW - post-structuralism

KW - postmodernism

KW - race

KW - social inequalities in health

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77956076392&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77956076392&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1363459309360973

DO - 10.1177/1363459309360973

M3 - Article

C2 - 20801998

AN - SCOPUS:77956076392

VL - 14

SP - 523

EP - 544

JO - Health (United Kingdom)

JF - Health (United Kingdom)

SN - 1363-4593

IS - 5

ER -