The paleoaltimetry of Tibet: An isotopic perspective

Jay Quade, Daniel O. Breecker, Mathieu Daëron, John Eiler

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

143 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Stable isotopes provide a valuable perspective on the timing of elevation change of the Tibetan Plateau. We begin our paper by looking in depth at isotopic patterns in modern Tibet. We show that the δ18O value of surface waters decreases systematically up the Himalayan front in central Nepal by about -2.8%/km, in agreement with the patterns documented and modeled by previous research. On the Tibetan plateau itself there is no apparent correlation between elevation and the δ18O value of flowing surface waters. Both surface waters and soil carbonates display a northward increase in δ18O values, of about 1.5%° north of the Himalayan crest, even though elevation increases modestly. The isotopic increase with latitude reduces the isotope-elevation gradient for water in the northernmost plateau to-1 to-2%/km. Carbonates in both soils and lakes form at higher temperatures than assumed by previous studies on the plateau. Temperature estimates from clumped-isotope (Δ47) analyses of modern soil carbonates significantly exceed mean annual air T and modeled maximum summer soil temperatures by 15.8±2.8° and 9.7±2.5 °C, respectively. Similarly elevated temperatures best account for the δ18O values observed in modern soil and lake carbonates. We recalculated paleoelevations from previous studies on the plateau using both higher formation temperatures and latitude-corrected isotopic values. With one notable exception, our revised model produces paleoelevation estimates very close to previous estimates. The exception is the reconstruction from late Eocene age deposits at Xoh Xil, for which we calculate elevations that are higher and much closer to the current elevation than previously reconstructed. Therefore, there is no evidence for northward progression through time of Tibetan elevation change. Instead, the available-but admittedly very scanty-evidence suggests that much of Tibet attained its modern elevation by the mid-Eocene. A truly robust test of the various geodynamic models of uplift await expansion and replication of isotopic records all across Tibet, especially in the center and north and for >15 Ma.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)77-115
Number of pages39
JournalAmerican Journal of Science
Volume311
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 2011

Fingerprint

plateau
carbonate
surface water
Eocene
soil
isotope
temperature
lake
soil temperature
geodynamics
stable isotope
uplift
air
summer
water

Keywords

  • Carbonates
  • Oxygen isotopes
  • Paleoaltimetry
  • Tibet
  • Uplift

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Earth and Planetary Sciences(all)

Cite this

The paleoaltimetry of Tibet : An isotopic perspective. / Quade, Jay; Breecker, Daniel O.; Daëron, Mathieu; Eiler, John.

In: American Journal of Science, Vol. 311, No. 2, 02.2011, p. 77-115.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Quade, Jay ; Breecker, Daniel O. ; Daëron, Mathieu ; Eiler, John. / The paleoaltimetry of Tibet : An isotopic perspective. In: American Journal of Science. 2011 ; Vol. 311, No. 2. pp. 77-115.
@article{71d67da677174b67aead261582b0820b,
title = "The paleoaltimetry of Tibet: An isotopic perspective",
abstract = "Stable isotopes provide a valuable perspective on the timing of elevation change of the Tibetan Plateau. We begin our paper by looking in depth at isotopic patterns in modern Tibet. We show that the δ18O value of surface waters decreases systematically up the Himalayan front in central Nepal by about -2.8{\%}/km, in agreement with the patterns documented and modeled by previous research. On the Tibetan plateau itself there is no apparent correlation between elevation and the δ18O value of flowing surface waters. Both surface waters and soil carbonates display a northward increase in δ18O values, of about 1.5{\%}° north of the Himalayan crest, even though elevation increases modestly. The isotopic increase with latitude reduces the isotope-elevation gradient for water in the northernmost plateau to-1 to-2{\%}/km. Carbonates in both soils and lakes form at higher temperatures than assumed by previous studies on the plateau. Temperature estimates from clumped-isotope (Δ47) analyses of modern soil carbonates significantly exceed mean annual air T and modeled maximum summer soil temperatures by 15.8±2.8° and 9.7±2.5 °C, respectively. Similarly elevated temperatures best account for the δ18O values observed in modern soil and lake carbonates. We recalculated paleoelevations from previous studies on the plateau using both higher formation temperatures and latitude-corrected isotopic values. With one notable exception, our revised model produces paleoelevation estimates very close to previous estimates. The exception is the reconstruction from late Eocene age deposits at Xoh Xil, for which we calculate elevations that are higher and much closer to the current elevation than previously reconstructed. Therefore, there is no evidence for northward progression through time of Tibetan elevation change. Instead, the available-but admittedly very scanty-evidence suggests that much of Tibet attained its modern elevation by the mid-Eocene. A truly robust test of the various geodynamic models of uplift await expansion and replication of isotopic records all across Tibet, especially in the center and north and for >15 Ma.",
keywords = "Carbonates, Oxygen isotopes, Paleoaltimetry, Tibet, Uplift",
author = "Jay Quade and Breecker, {Daniel O.} and Mathieu Da{\"e}ron and John Eiler",
year = "2011",
month = "2",
doi = "10.2475/02.2011.01",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "311",
pages = "77--115",
journal = "American Journal of Science",
issn = "0002-9599",
publisher = "Yale University",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The paleoaltimetry of Tibet

T2 - An isotopic perspective

AU - Quade, Jay

AU - Breecker, Daniel O.

AU - Daëron, Mathieu

AU - Eiler, John

PY - 2011/2

Y1 - 2011/2

N2 - Stable isotopes provide a valuable perspective on the timing of elevation change of the Tibetan Plateau. We begin our paper by looking in depth at isotopic patterns in modern Tibet. We show that the δ18O value of surface waters decreases systematically up the Himalayan front in central Nepal by about -2.8%/km, in agreement with the patterns documented and modeled by previous research. On the Tibetan plateau itself there is no apparent correlation between elevation and the δ18O value of flowing surface waters. Both surface waters and soil carbonates display a northward increase in δ18O values, of about 1.5%° north of the Himalayan crest, even though elevation increases modestly. The isotopic increase with latitude reduces the isotope-elevation gradient for water in the northernmost plateau to-1 to-2%/km. Carbonates in both soils and lakes form at higher temperatures than assumed by previous studies on the plateau. Temperature estimates from clumped-isotope (Δ47) analyses of modern soil carbonates significantly exceed mean annual air T and modeled maximum summer soil temperatures by 15.8±2.8° and 9.7±2.5 °C, respectively. Similarly elevated temperatures best account for the δ18O values observed in modern soil and lake carbonates. We recalculated paleoelevations from previous studies on the plateau using both higher formation temperatures and latitude-corrected isotopic values. With one notable exception, our revised model produces paleoelevation estimates very close to previous estimates. The exception is the reconstruction from late Eocene age deposits at Xoh Xil, for which we calculate elevations that are higher and much closer to the current elevation than previously reconstructed. Therefore, there is no evidence for northward progression through time of Tibetan elevation change. Instead, the available-but admittedly very scanty-evidence suggests that much of Tibet attained its modern elevation by the mid-Eocene. A truly robust test of the various geodynamic models of uplift await expansion and replication of isotopic records all across Tibet, especially in the center and north and for >15 Ma.

AB - Stable isotopes provide a valuable perspective on the timing of elevation change of the Tibetan Plateau. We begin our paper by looking in depth at isotopic patterns in modern Tibet. We show that the δ18O value of surface waters decreases systematically up the Himalayan front in central Nepal by about -2.8%/km, in agreement with the patterns documented and modeled by previous research. On the Tibetan plateau itself there is no apparent correlation between elevation and the δ18O value of flowing surface waters. Both surface waters and soil carbonates display a northward increase in δ18O values, of about 1.5%° north of the Himalayan crest, even though elevation increases modestly. The isotopic increase with latitude reduces the isotope-elevation gradient for water in the northernmost plateau to-1 to-2%/km. Carbonates in both soils and lakes form at higher temperatures than assumed by previous studies on the plateau. Temperature estimates from clumped-isotope (Δ47) analyses of modern soil carbonates significantly exceed mean annual air T and modeled maximum summer soil temperatures by 15.8±2.8° and 9.7±2.5 °C, respectively. Similarly elevated temperatures best account for the δ18O values observed in modern soil and lake carbonates. We recalculated paleoelevations from previous studies on the plateau using both higher formation temperatures and latitude-corrected isotopic values. With one notable exception, our revised model produces paleoelevation estimates very close to previous estimates. The exception is the reconstruction from late Eocene age deposits at Xoh Xil, for which we calculate elevations that are higher and much closer to the current elevation than previously reconstructed. Therefore, there is no evidence for northward progression through time of Tibetan elevation change. Instead, the available-but admittedly very scanty-evidence suggests that much of Tibet attained its modern elevation by the mid-Eocene. A truly robust test of the various geodynamic models of uplift await expansion and replication of isotopic records all across Tibet, especially in the center and north and for >15 Ma.

KW - Carbonates

KW - Oxygen isotopes

KW - Paleoaltimetry

KW - Tibet

KW - Uplift

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79957463118&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79957463118&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2475/02.2011.01

DO - 10.2475/02.2011.01

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:79957463118

VL - 311

SP - 77

EP - 115

JO - American Journal of Science

JF - American Journal of Science

SN - 0002-9599

IS - 2

ER -