Trouble with the lorentz law of force: Incompatibility with special relativity and momentum conservation

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

64 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Lorentz law of force is the fifth pillar of classical electrodynamics, the other four being Maxwell's macroscopic equations. The Lorentz law is the universal expression of the force exerted by electromagnetic fields on a volume containing a distribution of electrical charges and currents. If electric and magnetic dipoles also happen to be present in a material medium, they are traditionally treated by expressing the corresponding polarization and magnetization distributions in terms of bound-charge and bound-current densities, which are subsequently added to free-charge and free-current densities, respectively. In this way, Maxwell's macroscopic equations are reduced to his microscopic equations, and the Lorentz law is expected to provide a precise expression of the electromagnetic force density on material bodies at all points in space and time. This Letter presents incontrovertible theoretical evidence of the incompatibility of the Lorentz law with the fundamental tenets of special relativity. We argue that the Lorentz law must be abandoned in favor of a more general expression of the electromagnetic force density, such as the one discovered by Einstein and Laub in 1908. Not only is the Einstein-Laub formula consistent with special relativity, it also solves the long-standing problem of "hidden momentum" in classical electrodynamics.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number193901
JournalPhysical Review Letters
Volume108
Issue number19
DOIs
StatePublished - May 7 2012

Fingerprint

incompatibility
relativity
conservation
momentum
macroscopic equations
electrodynamics
current density
electromagnetism
magnetic dipoles
electric dipoles
electromagnetic fields
magnetization
polarization

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Physics and Astronomy(all)

Cite this

Trouble with the lorentz law of force : Incompatibility with special relativity and momentum conservation. / Mansuripur, Masud.

In: Physical Review Letters, Vol. 108, No. 19, 193901, 07.05.2012.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{8b8b902db7ae498ea9cbb6548164cbeb,
title = "Trouble with the lorentz law of force: Incompatibility with special relativity and momentum conservation",
abstract = "The Lorentz law of force is the fifth pillar of classical electrodynamics, the other four being Maxwell's macroscopic equations. The Lorentz law is the universal expression of the force exerted by electromagnetic fields on a volume containing a distribution of electrical charges and currents. If electric and magnetic dipoles also happen to be present in a material medium, they are traditionally treated by expressing the corresponding polarization and magnetization distributions in terms of bound-charge and bound-current densities, which are subsequently added to free-charge and free-current densities, respectively. In this way, Maxwell's macroscopic equations are reduced to his microscopic equations, and the Lorentz law is expected to provide a precise expression of the electromagnetic force density on material bodies at all points in space and time. This Letter presents incontrovertible theoretical evidence of the incompatibility of the Lorentz law with the fundamental tenets of special relativity. We argue that the Lorentz law must be abandoned in favor of a more general expression of the electromagnetic force density, such as the one discovered by Einstein and Laub in 1908. Not only is the Einstein-Laub formula consistent with special relativity, it also solves the long-standing problem of {"}hidden momentum{"} in classical electrodynamics.",
author = "Masud Mansuripur",
year = "2012",
month = "5",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.193901",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "108",
journal = "Physical Review Letters",
issn = "0031-9007",
publisher = "American Physical Society",
number = "19",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Trouble with the lorentz law of force

T2 - Incompatibility with special relativity and momentum conservation

AU - Mansuripur, Masud

PY - 2012/5/7

Y1 - 2012/5/7

N2 - The Lorentz law of force is the fifth pillar of classical electrodynamics, the other four being Maxwell's macroscopic equations. The Lorentz law is the universal expression of the force exerted by electromagnetic fields on a volume containing a distribution of electrical charges and currents. If electric and magnetic dipoles also happen to be present in a material medium, they are traditionally treated by expressing the corresponding polarization and magnetization distributions in terms of bound-charge and bound-current densities, which are subsequently added to free-charge and free-current densities, respectively. In this way, Maxwell's macroscopic equations are reduced to his microscopic equations, and the Lorentz law is expected to provide a precise expression of the electromagnetic force density on material bodies at all points in space and time. This Letter presents incontrovertible theoretical evidence of the incompatibility of the Lorentz law with the fundamental tenets of special relativity. We argue that the Lorentz law must be abandoned in favor of a more general expression of the electromagnetic force density, such as the one discovered by Einstein and Laub in 1908. Not only is the Einstein-Laub formula consistent with special relativity, it also solves the long-standing problem of "hidden momentum" in classical electrodynamics.

AB - The Lorentz law of force is the fifth pillar of classical electrodynamics, the other four being Maxwell's macroscopic equations. The Lorentz law is the universal expression of the force exerted by electromagnetic fields on a volume containing a distribution of electrical charges and currents. If electric and magnetic dipoles also happen to be present in a material medium, they are traditionally treated by expressing the corresponding polarization and magnetization distributions in terms of bound-charge and bound-current densities, which are subsequently added to free-charge and free-current densities, respectively. In this way, Maxwell's macroscopic equations are reduced to his microscopic equations, and the Lorentz law is expected to provide a precise expression of the electromagnetic force density on material bodies at all points in space and time. This Letter presents incontrovertible theoretical evidence of the incompatibility of the Lorentz law with the fundamental tenets of special relativity. We argue that the Lorentz law must be abandoned in favor of a more general expression of the electromagnetic force density, such as the one discovered by Einstein and Laub in 1908. Not only is the Einstein-Laub formula consistent with special relativity, it also solves the long-standing problem of "hidden momentum" in classical electrodynamics.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84860719252&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84860719252&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.193901

DO - 10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.193901

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84860719252

VL - 108

JO - Physical Review Letters

JF - Physical Review Letters

SN - 0031-9007

IS - 19

M1 - 193901

ER -