Uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater model parameter identification

Tian-Chyi J Yeh, De qiang Mao, Yuan yuan Zha, Jet chau Wen, Li Wan, Kuo chin Hsu, Cheng haw Lee

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper first visits uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater flow forward modeling problems. It then makes the point that non-unique solutions to groundwater flow inverse problems arise from a lack of information necessary to make the problems well defined. Subsequently, it presents the necessary conditions for a well-defined inverse problem. They are full specifications of (1) flux boundaries and sources/sinks, and (2) heads everywhere in the domain at at least three times (one of which is t = 0), with head change everywhere at those times being nonzero for transient flow. Numerical experiments are presented to corroborate the fact that, once the necessary conditions are met, the inverse problem has a unique solution. We also demonstrate that measurement noise, instability, and sensitivity are issues related to solution techniques rather than the inverse problems themselves. In addition, we show that a mathematically well-defined inverse problem, based on an equivalent homogeneous or a layered conceptual model, may yield physically incorrect and scenario-dependent parameter values. These issues are attributed to inconsistency between the scale of the head observed and that implied by these models. Such issues can be reduced only if a sufficiently large number of observation wells are used in the equivalent homogeneous domain or each layer. With a large number of wells, we then show that increase in parameterization can lead to a higher-resolution depiction of heterogeneity if an appropriate inverse methodology is used. Furthermore, we illustrate that, using the same number of wells, a highly parameterized model in conjunction with hydraulic tomography can yield better characterization of the aquifer and minimize the scale and scenario-dependent problems. Lastly, benefits of the highly parameterized model and hydraulic tomography are tested according to their ability to improve predictions of aquifer responses induced by independent stresses not used in the inverse modeling efforts.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)175-194
Number of pages20
JournalWater Science and Engineering
Volume8
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2015

Fingerprint

Inverse problems
Groundwater
Identification (control systems)
Groundwater flow
Aquifers
Tomography
Hydraulics
Parameterization
Fluxes
Specifications
Experiments

Keywords

  • Forward and inverse problems
  • Hydraulic tomography
  • Resolution
  • Scale
  • Uniqueness

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Ocean Engineering

Cite this

Uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater model parameter identification. / Yeh, Tian-Chyi J; Mao, De qiang; Zha, Yuan yuan; Wen, Jet chau; Wan, Li; Hsu, Kuo chin; Lee, Cheng haw.

In: Water Science and Engineering, Vol. 8, No. 3, 01.07.2015, p. 175-194.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Yeh, Tian-Chyi J ; Mao, De qiang ; Zha, Yuan yuan ; Wen, Jet chau ; Wan, Li ; Hsu, Kuo chin ; Lee, Cheng haw. / Uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater model parameter identification. In: Water Science and Engineering. 2015 ; Vol. 8, No. 3. pp. 175-194.
@article{262c67f28fa346f18985c79552bdeb78,
title = "Uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater model parameter identification",
abstract = "This paper first visits uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater flow forward modeling problems. It then makes the point that non-unique solutions to groundwater flow inverse problems arise from a lack of information necessary to make the problems well defined. Subsequently, it presents the necessary conditions for a well-defined inverse problem. They are full specifications of (1) flux boundaries and sources/sinks, and (2) heads everywhere in the domain at at least three times (one of which is t = 0), with head change everywhere at those times being nonzero for transient flow. Numerical experiments are presented to corroborate the fact that, once the necessary conditions are met, the inverse problem has a unique solution. We also demonstrate that measurement noise, instability, and sensitivity are issues related to solution techniques rather than the inverse problems themselves. In addition, we show that a mathematically well-defined inverse problem, based on an equivalent homogeneous or a layered conceptual model, may yield physically incorrect and scenario-dependent parameter values. These issues are attributed to inconsistency between the scale of the head observed and that implied by these models. Such issues can be reduced only if a sufficiently large number of observation wells are used in the equivalent homogeneous domain or each layer. With a large number of wells, we then show that increase in parameterization can lead to a higher-resolution depiction of heterogeneity if an appropriate inverse methodology is used. Furthermore, we illustrate that, using the same number of wells, a highly parameterized model in conjunction with hydraulic tomography can yield better characterization of the aquifer and minimize the scale and scenario-dependent problems. Lastly, benefits of the highly parameterized model and hydraulic tomography are tested according to their ability to improve predictions of aquifer responses induced by independent stresses not used in the inverse modeling efforts.",
keywords = "Forward and inverse problems, Hydraulic tomography, Resolution, Scale, Uniqueness",
author = "Yeh, {Tian-Chyi J} and Mao, {De qiang} and Zha, {Yuan yuan} and Wen, {Jet chau} and Li Wan and Hsu, {Kuo chin} and Lee, {Cheng haw}",
year = "2015",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.wse.2015.08.002",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "8",
pages = "175--194",
journal = "Water Science and Engineering",
issn = "1674-2370",
publisher = "Water Science and Engineering",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater model parameter identification

AU - Yeh, Tian-Chyi J

AU - Mao, De qiang

AU - Zha, Yuan yuan

AU - Wen, Jet chau

AU - Wan, Li

AU - Hsu, Kuo chin

AU - Lee, Cheng haw

PY - 2015/7/1

Y1 - 2015/7/1

N2 - This paper first visits uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater flow forward modeling problems. It then makes the point that non-unique solutions to groundwater flow inverse problems arise from a lack of information necessary to make the problems well defined. Subsequently, it presents the necessary conditions for a well-defined inverse problem. They are full specifications of (1) flux boundaries and sources/sinks, and (2) heads everywhere in the domain at at least three times (one of which is t = 0), with head change everywhere at those times being nonzero for transient flow. Numerical experiments are presented to corroborate the fact that, once the necessary conditions are met, the inverse problem has a unique solution. We also demonstrate that measurement noise, instability, and sensitivity are issues related to solution techniques rather than the inverse problems themselves. In addition, we show that a mathematically well-defined inverse problem, based on an equivalent homogeneous or a layered conceptual model, may yield physically incorrect and scenario-dependent parameter values. These issues are attributed to inconsistency between the scale of the head observed and that implied by these models. Such issues can be reduced only if a sufficiently large number of observation wells are used in the equivalent homogeneous domain or each layer. With a large number of wells, we then show that increase in parameterization can lead to a higher-resolution depiction of heterogeneity if an appropriate inverse methodology is used. Furthermore, we illustrate that, using the same number of wells, a highly parameterized model in conjunction with hydraulic tomography can yield better characterization of the aquifer and minimize the scale and scenario-dependent problems. Lastly, benefits of the highly parameterized model and hydraulic tomography are tested according to their ability to improve predictions of aquifer responses induced by independent stresses not used in the inverse modeling efforts.

AB - This paper first visits uniqueness, scale, and resolution issues in groundwater flow forward modeling problems. It then makes the point that non-unique solutions to groundwater flow inverse problems arise from a lack of information necessary to make the problems well defined. Subsequently, it presents the necessary conditions for a well-defined inverse problem. They are full specifications of (1) flux boundaries and sources/sinks, and (2) heads everywhere in the domain at at least three times (one of which is t = 0), with head change everywhere at those times being nonzero for transient flow. Numerical experiments are presented to corroborate the fact that, once the necessary conditions are met, the inverse problem has a unique solution. We also demonstrate that measurement noise, instability, and sensitivity are issues related to solution techniques rather than the inverse problems themselves. In addition, we show that a mathematically well-defined inverse problem, based on an equivalent homogeneous or a layered conceptual model, may yield physically incorrect and scenario-dependent parameter values. These issues are attributed to inconsistency between the scale of the head observed and that implied by these models. Such issues can be reduced only if a sufficiently large number of observation wells are used in the equivalent homogeneous domain or each layer. With a large number of wells, we then show that increase in parameterization can lead to a higher-resolution depiction of heterogeneity if an appropriate inverse methodology is used. Furthermore, we illustrate that, using the same number of wells, a highly parameterized model in conjunction with hydraulic tomography can yield better characterization of the aquifer and minimize the scale and scenario-dependent problems. Lastly, benefits of the highly parameterized model and hydraulic tomography are tested according to their ability to improve predictions of aquifer responses induced by independent stresses not used in the inverse modeling efforts.

KW - Forward and inverse problems

KW - Hydraulic tomography

KW - Resolution

KW - Scale

KW - Uniqueness

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84943383917&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84943383917&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.wse.2015.08.002

DO - 10.1016/j.wse.2015.08.002

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84943383917

VL - 8

SP - 175

EP - 194

JO - Water Science and Engineering

JF - Water Science and Engineering

SN - 1674-2370

IS - 3

ER -