Using cytochrome b to identify nests and museum specimens of cryptic songbirds

Anne E Arnold, Erik M. Andersen, Michael J. Taylor, Robert J Steidl

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Understanding demography of vertebrate populations requires quantifying reproductive success. For taxa that are difficult to distinguish, estimates of reproductive success can be biased if species are misidentified or if breeding concludes before identification is confirmed. We surveyed desert grasslands where three species of cryptic sparrows breed: Peucaea botterii, P. cassinii, and Aimophila ruficeps (Emberizidae). Nests, eggs, and nestlings of these species are similar, making it difficult to differentiate nests without observing adults, which can be challenging. We collected seven types of material from nests for DNA analysis: maternal cells from exterior surfaces of unhatched eggs, epithelial cells from the oropharyngeal cavity of nestlings, eggshells, feathers, feather sheaths, feces, and fecal sacs. From these materials, we amplified and sequenced a fragment of the diagnostic locus, mitochondrial cytochrome b (cyt b), and analyzed the data in a phylogenetic framework to classify nests to species. We validated our classification by sequencing the same locus from feathers of museum specimens. Overall, 72% of samples from nests yielded high-quality sequences. We identified to species 44 of 51 nests and identified museum specimens with archival ages of up to 47 years. Our study extends previous research by demonstrating the efficacy of standard kits, inexpensive reagents, low DNA concentrations, and diverse materials in classifying nests of grassland sparrows. Compared to more invasive methods of acquiring DNA, the approaches we describe are less likely to affect nesting behavior and bias estimates of nesting success of birds, issues especially important for species of conservation concern.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)451-458
Number of pages8
JournalConservation Genetics Resources
Volume9
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2017

Fingerprint

Feathers
Museums
Songbirds
Cytochromes b
songbird
songbirds
cytochrome b
Sparrows
museum
cytochrome
nest
nests
Eggs
Nesting Behavior
DNA
Egg Shell
feather
feathers
Passeriformes
Feces

Keywords

  • Aimophila
  • Cyt b
  • Emberizidae
  • Mitochondrial
  • Nest success
  • Peucaea
  • Polymerase chain reaction

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Genetics

Cite this

Using cytochrome b to identify nests and museum specimens of cryptic songbirds. / Arnold, Anne E; Andersen, Erik M.; Taylor, Michael J.; Steidl, Robert J.

In: Conservation Genetics Resources, Vol. 9, No. 3, 01.09.2017, p. 451-458.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b0ea3d4790bd474590ce6a31b43c43b6,
title = "Using cytochrome b to identify nests and museum specimens of cryptic songbirds",
abstract = "Understanding demography of vertebrate populations requires quantifying reproductive success. For taxa that are difficult to distinguish, estimates of reproductive success can be biased if species are misidentified or if breeding concludes before identification is confirmed. We surveyed desert grasslands where three species of cryptic sparrows breed: Peucaea botterii, P. cassinii, and Aimophila ruficeps (Emberizidae). Nests, eggs, and nestlings of these species are similar, making it difficult to differentiate nests without observing adults, which can be challenging. We collected seven types of material from nests for DNA analysis: maternal cells from exterior surfaces of unhatched eggs, epithelial cells from the oropharyngeal cavity of nestlings, eggshells, feathers, feather sheaths, feces, and fecal sacs. From these materials, we amplified and sequenced a fragment of the diagnostic locus, mitochondrial cytochrome b (cyt b), and analyzed the data in a phylogenetic framework to classify nests to species. We validated our classification by sequencing the same locus from feathers of museum specimens. Overall, 72{\%} of samples from nests yielded high-quality sequences. We identified to species 44 of 51 nests and identified museum specimens with archival ages of up to 47 years. Our study extends previous research by demonstrating the efficacy of standard kits, inexpensive reagents, low DNA concentrations, and diverse materials in classifying nests of grassland sparrows. Compared to more invasive methods of acquiring DNA, the approaches we describe are less likely to affect nesting behavior and bias estimates of nesting success of birds, issues especially important for species of conservation concern.",
keywords = "Aimophila, Cyt b, Emberizidae, Mitochondrial, Nest success, Peucaea, Polymerase chain reaction",
author = "Arnold, {Anne E} and Andersen, {Erik M.} and Taylor, {Michael J.} and Steidl, {Robert J}",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s12686-016-0680-2",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "9",
pages = "451--458",
journal = "Conservation Genetics Resources",
issn = "1877-7252",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using cytochrome b to identify nests and museum specimens of cryptic songbirds

AU - Arnold, Anne E

AU - Andersen, Erik M.

AU - Taylor, Michael J.

AU - Steidl, Robert J

PY - 2017/9/1

Y1 - 2017/9/1

N2 - Understanding demography of vertebrate populations requires quantifying reproductive success. For taxa that are difficult to distinguish, estimates of reproductive success can be biased if species are misidentified or if breeding concludes before identification is confirmed. We surveyed desert grasslands where three species of cryptic sparrows breed: Peucaea botterii, P. cassinii, and Aimophila ruficeps (Emberizidae). Nests, eggs, and nestlings of these species are similar, making it difficult to differentiate nests without observing adults, which can be challenging. We collected seven types of material from nests for DNA analysis: maternal cells from exterior surfaces of unhatched eggs, epithelial cells from the oropharyngeal cavity of nestlings, eggshells, feathers, feather sheaths, feces, and fecal sacs. From these materials, we amplified and sequenced a fragment of the diagnostic locus, mitochondrial cytochrome b (cyt b), and analyzed the data in a phylogenetic framework to classify nests to species. We validated our classification by sequencing the same locus from feathers of museum specimens. Overall, 72% of samples from nests yielded high-quality sequences. We identified to species 44 of 51 nests and identified museum specimens with archival ages of up to 47 years. Our study extends previous research by demonstrating the efficacy of standard kits, inexpensive reagents, low DNA concentrations, and diverse materials in classifying nests of grassland sparrows. Compared to more invasive methods of acquiring DNA, the approaches we describe are less likely to affect nesting behavior and bias estimates of nesting success of birds, issues especially important for species of conservation concern.

AB - Understanding demography of vertebrate populations requires quantifying reproductive success. For taxa that are difficult to distinguish, estimates of reproductive success can be biased if species are misidentified or if breeding concludes before identification is confirmed. We surveyed desert grasslands where three species of cryptic sparrows breed: Peucaea botterii, P. cassinii, and Aimophila ruficeps (Emberizidae). Nests, eggs, and nestlings of these species are similar, making it difficult to differentiate nests without observing adults, which can be challenging. We collected seven types of material from nests for DNA analysis: maternal cells from exterior surfaces of unhatched eggs, epithelial cells from the oropharyngeal cavity of nestlings, eggshells, feathers, feather sheaths, feces, and fecal sacs. From these materials, we amplified and sequenced a fragment of the diagnostic locus, mitochondrial cytochrome b (cyt b), and analyzed the data in a phylogenetic framework to classify nests to species. We validated our classification by sequencing the same locus from feathers of museum specimens. Overall, 72% of samples from nests yielded high-quality sequences. We identified to species 44 of 51 nests and identified museum specimens with archival ages of up to 47 years. Our study extends previous research by demonstrating the efficacy of standard kits, inexpensive reagents, low DNA concentrations, and diverse materials in classifying nests of grassland sparrows. Compared to more invasive methods of acquiring DNA, the approaches we describe are less likely to affect nesting behavior and bias estimates of nesting success of birds, issues especially important for species of conservation concern.

KW - Aimophila

KW - Cyt b

KW - Emberizidae

KW - Mitochondrial

KW - Nest success

KW - Peucaea

KW - Polymerase chain reaction

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85027048600&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85027048600&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s12686-016-0680-2

DO - 10.1007/s12686-016-0680-2

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85027048600

VL - 9

SP - 451

EP - 458

JO - Conservation Genetics Resources

JF - Conservation Genetics Resources

SN - 1877-7252

IS - 3

ER -