What are the instrumentation requirements for measuring the isotopic composition of net ecosystem exchange of CO2 using eddy covariance methods?

Scott Saleska, Joanne H. Shorter, Scott Herndon, Rodrxigo Jiménez, J. Barry McManus, J. William Munger, David D. Nelson, Mark S. Zahniser

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Better quantification of isotope ratios of atmosphere-ecosystem exchange of CO2 could substantially improve our ability to probe underlying physiological and ecological mechanisms controlling ecosystem carbon exchange, but the ability to make long-term continuous measurements of isotope ratios of exchange fluxes has been limited by measurement difficulties. In particular, direct eddy covariance methods have not yet been used for measuring the isotopic composition of ecosystem fluxes. In this article, we explore the feasibility of such measurements by (a) proposing a general criterion for judging whether a sensor's performance is sufficient for making such measurements (the criterion is met when the contribution of sensor error to the flux measurement error is comparable to or less than the contribution of meteorological noise inherently associated with turbulence flux measurements); (b) using data-based numerical simulations to quantify the level of sensor precision and stability required to meet this criterion for making direct eddy covariance measurements of the 13C/12C ratio of CO2 fluxes above a specific ecosystem (a mid-latitude temperate forest in central Massachusetts, USA); (c) testing whether the performance of a new sensor - a prototype pulsed quantum cascade laser (QCL) based isotope-ratio absorption spectrometer (and plausible improvements thereon) - is sufficient for meeting the criterion in this ecosystem. We found that the error contribution from a prototype sensor (∼0.2‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations) to total isoflux measurement error was comparable to (1.5 to 2×) the irreducible 'meteorological' noise inherently associated with turbulent flux measurements above this ecosystem (daytime measurement error SD of ∼60% of flux versus meteorological noise of 30-40% for instantaneous half-hour fluxes). Our analysis also shows that plausible instrument improvements (increase of sensor precision to ∼0.1‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations, and increased sensor stability during the half-hour needed to integrate eddy covariance measurements) should decrease the contribution of sensor error to the point where it is less than the contribution from meteorological noise. This suggests that new sensors using QCL-based isotope ratio absorption spectroscopy should make continuous long-term observations of the isotopic composition of CO2 fluxes via eddy covariance methods feasible.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)115-133
Number of pages19
JournalIsotopes in Environmental and Health Studies
Volume42
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 2006

Fingerprint

net ecosystem exchange
eddy covariance
Ecosystems
instrumentation
isotopic composition
Fluxes
sensor
Sensors
Chemical analysis
Isotopes
ecosystem
flux measurement
Measurement errors
isotope
Quantum cascade lasers
laser
method
measuring
atomic absorption spectroscopy
temperate forest

Keywords

  • Calculation
  • Carbon-13
  • Carbon-dioxide
  • Fluxus
  • Measurement
  • Methods
  • Modelling

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Inorganic Chemistry
  • Environmental Science(all)
  • Environmental Chemistry

Cite this

What are the instrumentation requirements for measuring the isotopic composition of net ecosystem exchange of CO2 using eddy covariance methods? / Saleska, Scott; Shorter, Joanne H.; Herndon, Scott; Jiménez, Rodrxigo; McManus, J. Barry; Munger, J. William; Nelson, David D.; Zahniser, Mark S.

In: Isotopes in Environmental and Health Studies, Vol. 42, No. 2, 06.2006, p. 115-133.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Saleska, Scott ; Shorter, Joanne H. ; Herndon, Scott ; Jiménez, Rodrxigo ; McManus, J. Barry ; Munger, J. William ; Nelson, David D. ; Zahniser, Mark S. / What are the instrumentation requirements for measuring the isotopic composition of net ecosystem exchange of CO2 using eddy covariance methods?. In: Isotopes in Environmental and Health Studies. 2006 ; Vol. 42, No. 2. pp. 115-133.
@article{7cd7e5930ebd4fffa511513d0836e33a,
title = "What are the instrumentation requirements for measuring the isotopic composition of net ecosystem exchange of CO2 using eddy covariance methods?",
abstract = "Better quantification of isotope ratios of atmosphere-ecosystem exchange of CO2 could substantially improve our ability to probe underlying physiological and ecological mechanisms controlling ecosystem carbon exchange, but the ability to make long-term continuous measurements of isotope ratios of exchange fluxes has been limited by measurement difficulties. In particular, direct eddy covariance methods have not yet been used for measuring the isotopic composition of ecosystem fluxes. In this article, we explore the feasibility of such measurements by (a) proposing a general criterion for judging whether a sensor's performance is sufficient for making such measurements (the criterion is met when the contribution of sensor error to the flux measurement error is comparable to or less than the contribution of meteorological noise inherently associated with turbulence flux measurements); (b) using data-based numerical simulations to quantify the level of sensor precision and stability required to meet this criterion for making direct eddy covariance measurements of the 13C/12C ratio of CO2 fluxes above a specific ecosystem (a mid-latitude temperate forest in central Massachusetts, USA); (c) testing whether the performance of a new sensor - a prototype pulsed quantum cascade laser (QCL) based isotope-ratio absorption spectrometer (and plausible improvements thereon) - is sufficient for meeting the criterion in this ecosystem. We found that the error contribution from a prototype sensor (∼0.2‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations) to total isoflux measurement error was comparable to (1.5 to 2×) the irreducible 'meteorological' noise inherently associated with turbulent flux measurements above this ecosystem (daytime measurement error SD of ∼60{\%} of flux versus meteorological noise of 30-40{\%} for instantaneous half-hour fluxes). Our analysis also shows that plausible instrument improvements (increase of sensor precision to ∼0.1‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations, and increased sensor stability during the half-hour needed to integrate eddy covariance measurements) should decrease the contribution of sensor error to the point where it is less than the contribution from meteorological noise. This suggests that new sensors using QCL-based isotope ratio absorption spectroscopy should make continuous long-term observations of the isotopic composition of CO2 fluxes via eddy covariance methods feasible.",
keywords = "Calculation, Carbon-13, Carbon-dioxide, Fluxus, Measurement, Methods, Modelling",
author = "Scott Saleska and Shorter, {Joanne H.} and Scott Herndon and Rodrxigo Jim{\'e}nez and McManus, {J. Barry} and Munger, {J. William} and Nelson, {David D.} and Zahniser, {Mark S.}",
year = "2006",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1080/10256010600672959",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "42",
pages = "115--133",
journal = "Isotopes in Environmental and Health Studies",
issn = "1025-6016",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - What are the instrumentation requirements for measuring the isotopic composition of net ecosystem exchange of CO2 using eddy covariance methods?

AU - Saleska, Scott

AU - Shorter, Joanne H.

AU - Herndon, Scott

AU - Jiménez, Rodrxigo

AU - McManus, J. Barry

AU - Munger, J. William

AU - Nelson, David D.

AU - Zahniser, Mark S.

PY - 2006/6

Y1 - 2006/6

N2 - Better quantification of isotope ratios of atmosphere-ecosystem exchange of CO2 could substantially improve our ability to probe underlying physiological and ecological mechanisms controlling ecosystem carbon exchange, but the ability to make long-term continuous measurements of isotope ratios of exchange fluxes has been limited by measurement difficulties. In particular, direct eddy covariance methods have not yet been used for measuring the isotopic composition of ecosystem fluxes. In this article, we explore the feasibility of such measurements by (a) proposing a general criterion for judging whether a sensor's performance is sufficient for making such measurements (the criterion is met when the contribution of sensor error to the flux measurement error is comparable to or less than the contribution of meteorological noise inherently associated with turbulence flux measurements); (b) using data-based numerical simulations to quantify the level of sensor precision and stability required to meet this criterion for making direct eddy covariance measurements of the 13C/12C ratio of CO2 fluxes above a specific ecosystem (a mid-latitude temperate forest in central Massachusetts, USA); (c) testing whether the performance of a new sensor - a prototype pulsed quantum cascade laser (QCL) based isotope-ratio absorption spectrometer (and plausible improvements thereon) - is sufficient for meeting the criterion in this ecosystem. We found that the error contribution from a prototype sensor (∼0.2‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations) to total isoflux measurement error was comparable to (1.5 to 2×) the irreducible 'meteorological' noise inherently associated with turbulent flux measurements above this ecosystem (daytime measurement error SD of ∼60% of flux versus meteorological noise of 30-40% for instantaneous half-hour fluxes). Our analysis also shows that plausible instrument improvements (increase of sensor precision to ∼0.1‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations, and increased sensor stability during the half-hour needed to integrate eddy covariance measurements) should decrease the contribution of sensor error to the point where it is less than the contribution from meteorological noise. This suggests that new sensors using QCL-based isotope ratio absorption spectroscopy should make continuous long-term observations of the isotopic composition of CO2 fluxes via eddy covariance methods feasible.

AB - Better quantification of isotope ratios of atmosphere-ecosystem exchange of CO2 could substantially improve our ability to probe underlying physiological and ecological mechanisms controlling ecosystem carbon exchange, but the ability to make long-term continuous measurements of isotope ratios of exchange fluxes has been limited by measurement difficulties. In particular, direct eddy covariance methods have not yet been used for measuring the isotopic composition of ecosystem fluxes. In this article, we explore the feasibility of such measurements by (a) proposing a general criterion for judging whether a sensor's performance is sufficient for making such measurements (the criterion is met when the contribution of sensor error to the flux measurement error is comparable to or less than the contribution of meteorological noise inherently associated with turbulence flux measurements); (b) using data-based numerical simulations to quantify the level of sensor precision and stability required to meet this criterion for making direct eddy covariance measurements of the 13C/12C ratio of CO2 fluxes above a specific ecosystem (a mid-latitude temperate forest in central Massachusetts, USA); (c) testing whether the performance of a new sensor - a prototype pulsed quantum cascade laser (QCL) based isotope-ratio absorption spectrometer (and plausible improvements thereon) - is sufficient for meeting the criterion in this ecosystem. We found that the error contribution from a prototype sensor (∼0.2‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations) to total isoflux measurement error was comparable to (1.5 to 2×) the irreducible 'meteorological' noise inherently associated with turbulent flux measurements above this ecosystem (daytime measurement error SD of ∼60% of flux versus meteorological noise of 30-40% for instantaneous half-hour fluxes). Our analysis also shows that plausible instrument improvements (increase of sensor precision to ∼0.1‰, 1 SD of 10s integrations, and increased sensor stability during the half-hour needed to integrate eddy covariance measurements) should decrease the contribution of sensor error to the point where it is less than the contribution from meteorological noise. This suggests that new sensors using QCL-based isotope ratio absorption spectroscopy should make continuous long-term observations of the isotopic composition of CO2 fluxes via eddy covariance methods feasible.

KW - Calculation

KW - Carbon-13

KW - Carbon-dioxide

KW - Fluxus

KW - Measurement

KW - Methods

KW - Modelling

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33646807488&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33646807488&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/10256010600672959

DO - 10.1080/10256010600672959

M3 - Article

C2 - 16707314

AN - SCOPUS:33646807488

VL - 42

SP - 115

EP - 133

JO - Isotopes in Environmental and Health Studies

JF - Isotopes in Environmental and Health Studies

SN - 1025-6016

IS - 2

ER -