Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication: An initial cross-cultural comparison

Angie Williams, Hiroshi Ota, Howard Giles, Herbert D. Pierson, Cynthia Gallois, Sik Hung Ng, Tae Seop Lim, Ellen Bouchard Ryan, Lilnabeth Somera, John Maker, Debra Cai, James T Harwood

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

69 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article examines young people's perceptions of their conversations with older people (age 65-85) across nine cultures - five Eastern and four Western. Responses from more than 1,000 participants were entered into a cross-national factor analysis, which revealed four initial factors that underlie perceptions of intergenerational conversations. Elder nonaccommodation was when young participants reported that older people negatively stereotyped the young and did not attend to their communication needs. On the other hand, elder accommodation was when older people were perceived as supportive, attentive and generally encouraging to young people. A third factor was respect/ obligation and a fourth factor labeled age-irrelevant positivity described a situation where young people felt conversations with much older people were emotionally positive and satisfying, age did not matter. Examining cross-cultural differences, some East versus West differences were observed, as might be expected, on the basis of simplistic accounts of Eastern collectivism versus Western individualism. However, the results challenge commonsense notions of the status of old age in Eastern versus Western cultures. On some dimensions, participants from Korea, Japan, People's Republic of China, Hong Kong, and the Philippines appear to have relatively less positive perceptions of their conversations with older people than the Western cultures - the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. But there was also evidence of considerable cultural variability, particularly among Eastern cultures - variability that has heretofore all too often been glossed over when global comparisons of East versus West are made. A range of explanations for these cultural differences is explored and implications for older people in these societies are also considered.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)370-393
Number of pages24
JournalCommunication Research
Volume24
Issue number4
StatePublished - Aug 1997
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

intercultural comparison
Factor analysis
communication
Communication
conversation
cultural difference
Intergenerational Communication
Older People
Cross-cultural Comparison
collectivism
individualism
old age
Philippines
accommodation
Korea
factor analysis
obligation
Hong Kong
respect
New Zealand

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Communication

Cite this

Williams, A., Ota, H., Giles, H., Pierson, H. D., Gallois, C., Ng, S. H., ... Harwood, J. T. (1997). Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication: An initial cross-cultural comparison. Communication Research, 24(4), 370-393.

Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication : An initial cross-cultural comparison. / Williams, Angie; Ota, Hiroshi; Giles, Howard; Pierson, Herbert D.; Gallois, Cynthia; Ng, Sik Hung; Lim, Tae Seop; Ryan, Ellen Bouchard; Somera, Lilnabeth; Maker, John; Cai, Debra; Harwood, James T.

In: Communication Research, Vol. 24, No. 4, 08.1997, p. 370-393.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Williams, A, Ota, H, Giles, H, Pierson, HD, Gallois, C, Ng, SH, Lim, TS, Ryan, EB, Somera, L, Maker, J, Cai, D & Harwood, JT 1997, 'Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication: An initial cross-cultural comparison', Communication Research, vol. 24, no. 4, pp. 370-393.
Williams A, Ota H, Giles H, Pierson HD, Gallois C, Ng SH et al. Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication: An initial cross-cultural comparison. Communication Research. 1997 Aug;24(4):370-393.
Williams, Angie ; Ota, Hiroshi ; Giles, Howard ; Pierson, Herbert D. ; Gallois, Cynthia ; Ng, Sik Hung ; Lim, Tae Seop ; Ryan, Ellen Bouchard ; Somera, Lilnabeth ; Maker, John ; Cai, Debra ; Harwood, James T. / Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication : An initial cross-cultural comparison. In: Communication Research. 1997 ; Vol. 24, No. 4. pp. 370-393.
@article{b2777f12b7b94874ae73832520c6e2c8,
title = "Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication: An initial cross-cultural comparison",
abstract = "This article examines young people's perceptions of their conversations with older people (age 65-85) across nine cultures - five Eastern and four Western. Responses from more than 1,000 participants were entered into a cross-national factor analysis, which revealed four initial factors that underlie perceptions of intergenerational conversations. Elder nonaccommodation was when young participants reported that older people negatively stereotyped the young and did not attend to their communication needs. On the other hand, elder accommodation was when older people were perceived as supportive, attentive and generally encouraging to young people. A third factor was respect/ obligation and a fourth factor labeled age-irrelevant positivity described a situation where young people felt conversations with much older people were emotionally positive and satisfying, age did not matter. Examining cross-cultural differences, some East versus West differences were observed, as might be expected, on the basis of simplistic accounts of Eastern collectivism versus Western individualism. However, the results challenge commonsense notions of the status of old age in Eastern versus Western cultures. On some dimensions, participants from Korea, Japan, People's Republic of China, Hong Kong, and the Philippines appear to have relatively less positive perceptions of their conversations with older people than the Western cultures - the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. But there was also evidence of considerable cultural variability, particularly among Eastern cultures - variability that has heretofore all too often been glossed over when global comparisons of East versus West are made. A range of explanations for these cultural differences is explored and implications for older people in these societies are also considered.",
author = "Angie Williams and Hiroshi Ota and Howard Giles and Pierson, {Herbert D.} and Cynthia Gallois and Ng, {Sik Hung} and Lim, {Tae Seop} and Ryan, {Ellen Bouchard} and Lilnabeth Somera and John Maker and Debra Cai and Harwood, {James T}",
year = "1997",
month = "8",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "24",
pages = "370--393",
journal = "Communication Research",
issn = "0093-6502",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Young people's beliefs about intergenerational communication

T2 - An initial cross-cultural comparison

AU - Williams, Angie

AU - Ota, Hiroshi

AU - Giles, Howard

AU - Pierson, Herbert D.

AU - Gallois, Cynthia

AU - Ng, Sik Hung

AU - Lim, Tae Seop

AU - Ryan, Ellen Bouchard

AU - Somera, Lilnabeth

AU - Maker, John

AU - Cai, Debra

AU - Harwood, James T

PY - 1997/8

Y1 - 1997/8

N2 - This article examines young people's perceptions of their conversations with older people (age 65-85) across nine cultures - five Eastern and four Western. Responses from more than 1,000 participants were entered into a cross-national factor analysis, which revealed four initial factors that underlie perceptions of intergenerational conversations. Elder nonaccommodation was when young participants reported that older people negatively stereotyped the young and did not attend to their communication needs. On the other hand, elder accommodation was when older people were perceived as supportive, attentive and generally encouraging to young people. A third factor was respect/ obligation and a fourth factor labeled age-irrelevant positivity described a situation where young people felt conversations with much older people were emotionally positive and satisfying, age did not matter. Examining cross-cultural differences, some East versus West differences were observed, as might be expected, on the basis of simplistic accounts of Eastern collectivism versus Western individualism. However, the results challenge commonsense notions of the status of old age in Eastern versus Western cultures. On some dimensions, participants from Korea, Japan, People's Republic of China, Hong Kong, and the Philippines appear to have relatively less positive perceptions of their conversations with older people than the Western cultures - the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. But there was also evidence of considerable cultural variability, particularly among Eastern cultures - variability that has heretofore all too often been glossed over when global comparisons of East versus West are made. A range of explanations for these cultural differences is explored and implications for older people in these societies are also considered.

AB - This article examines young people's perceptions of their conversations with older people (age 65-85) across nine cultures - five Eastern and four Western. Responses from more than 1,000 participants were entered into a cross-national factor analysis, which revealed four initial factors that underlie perceptions of intergenerational conversations. Elder nonaccommodation was when young participants reported that older people negatively stereotyped the young and did not attend to their communication needs. On the other hand, elder accommodation was when older people were perceived as supportive, attentive and generally encouraging to young people. A third factor was respect/ obligation and a fourth factor labeled age-irrelevant positivity described a situation where young people felt conversations with much older people were emotionally positive and satisfying, age did not matter. Examining cross-cultural differences, some East versus West differences were observed, as might be expected, on the basis of simplistic accounts of Eastern collectivism versus Western individualism. However, the results challenge commonsense notions of the status of old age in Eastern versus Western cultures. On some dimensions, participants from Korea, Japan, People's Republic of China, Hong Kong, and the Philippines appear to have relatively less positive perceptions of their conversations with older people than the Western cultures - the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. But there was also evidence of considerable cultural variability, particularly among Eastern cultures - variability that has heretofore all too often been glossed over when global comparisons of East versus West are made. A range of explanations for these cultural differences is explored and implications for older people in these societies are also considered.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031536764&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0031536764&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0031536764

VL - 24

SP - 370

EP - 393

JO - Communication Research

JF - Communication Research

SN - 0093-6502

IS - 4

ER -